Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_1333051

Fixing newbie mistakes

11 years ago

Cross-posted with landscape design... but may be more perennial-specific advice here...

This townhouse is our first owned home with outdoor space for gardens. Not much, just narrow border gardens around our front and back patios and along our walkway. We moved in in 2012 and the place had only dirt with a few weeds in the rock hard dried out soil. I merrily spent money and backbreaking hours digging compost into the soil, removing weeds and finally planting with low water use perennials (we are in the San Francisco bay area).


Along our walkway I planted bush germander, pinata lavenders, russian sage and some blue spire salvia. The germanders were labeled to reach 2-3' tall and wide, but I have since learned that they naturally reach 4-5' tall and wide.


Since then, things have grown a lot, and I've had to remove 2 of the lavenders because we got a frost in winter that damaged them and then they never really recovered, I tried to prune off the damaged areas but some of them were beyond repair. Too bad, they were pretty - but they did get too wide for the space and needed a lot of pruning.


I love the germanders as plants - their silvery foliage and pretty blue purple flowers, their hardiness etc, But they really are big for this area.


I don't necessarily like a super tidy look, I love plants that appear blurred into eachother and was very happy with the color pallet and appearance of the garden a year or 2 ago.


So right now, this is the walkway to our front door, flanked by the fence and the carport on either side - it doesn't look very good. There are huge spaces left by the removal of the lavenders, made more apparent by the giant germanders dominating the space. I'm afraid it might look better if I just removed them and found plants more appropriately sized, but I would really hate to destroy these plants and there is no other space for them even if I could transplant these established perennials which likely have giant root systems. But, I really don't think it looks attractive to have "walls" of hedge along either side of the walkway - even when I prune them back then the germanders lose their airy natural structure and become a messy hedge.

Can I salvage anything of this overgrown mess, or should I dig up the overgrown plants and start over? What low water use full sun/heat tolerant and appropriately-sized plants could I use here? My tastes are for the blue-purple pallet, love silvery foliage.

In 2012 when first planted (oh how naive I was!)

In 2013-14 when I think everything looked perfect IMO!


and... now.



Comments (8)

  • 11 years ago

    Wow! That is a lot of growth! I don't know a whole lot about these particular plants, but I cut plants back all the time even if they aren't intended to be pruned.

    User thanked C F
  • 11 years ago

    I can totally relate to the newbie mistakes. I purchased my townhome the same year actually and it was my first outdoor space. I'm one for the tidy look... I'm also super indecisive and change my mind a lot. I say don't be afraid to dig things up or cut things back hard. If it doesn't work out or you want to replace something -- do it!

    I've had to give plants away or sell them because I planted too close... I think it's a common mistake for those just starting out.

    User thanked ked1985
  • 11 years ago

    How about artimesia in place of the germander? I agree that the look in 2013-14 was wonderful. One thing to remember and which everyone is saying, is that you can always prune, take out, move, whatever, so don't worry about that. I am still making mistakes after 18 years in this house! Sigh.

    User thanked cyn427 (z. 7, N. VA)
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Well, one thing for certain is that you've experienced and passed New Gardener 101. Congratulations. I'll leave suggestions to people who are experienced with your climate and space restrictions. What about a gorgeous bright colored pot by front door which could be used for your colorful, loose and blousy statement?

    User thanked Marie Tulin Boston burbs z 6a
  • 11 years ago

    An area like that will need a lot of good pruning to keep it looking nice all of the time. I'd cut the germander WAY back (to smaller than you'd really want it) and trim the rest back to a size you like. Then as things grow, I'd prune regularly, not just length, but thinning out about 1/4 of each bush every three months, This way they will always have some nice mature growth, and always have some nice new growth.

    User thanked socalgal_gw Zone USDA 10b Sunset 24
  • 11 years ago

    I actually think most of the plants still look good now, except for the germanders but only because there are so many of them. The rest of the plants, though full, don't look overgrown to me but I like things spilling or bursting out a bit in a less formal look. Even the one germander on the right in your first "now" picture looks like it could stay as is, but it's just combined with the others that they look too dominant. I'd leave that one, take out the others, and fill in the holes with plants of your choice. Catmint is another choice for the color schemes you say you like (pick a smaller cultivar).

    User thanked ajs317
  • 11 years ago

    There are actually only 3 germanders total - one on the left when facing our front door and 2 on the right, they have just sprawled so enormously! I have hacked them back from the path but they spread about 6-7' wide along the length of the path the the 2 on the right have blended into a single hedge more or less. I am not even sure if I can physically hack them back to 6", I will have to buy an electric hedge cutter or something, I think. I use hand shears to keep things under some degree of control now and that means weekly hedging. But it's even difficult to walk up the path with groceries or items because it's pretty narrow.


    Unfortunately, I think I will have to dig them up. I think I will list them free on craigslist for someone with a larger space to enjoy, because I hate to kill perfectly good, vigorous plants. Anyone on this list in the SF bar area who would like them? I dread digging them up I bet the roots are tree-like!


    Thanks for the artemisia suggestion, it looks like a plant I would enjoy. I'm also considering trying again with russian sage, but using "little spire" the shorter kind, i absolutely love the color. Maybe paired with something yellow, like I had in my original garden but all those smaller plants got crowded out.

Sponsored
Snider & Metcalf Interior Design, LTD
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars25 Reviews
Leading Interior Designers in Columbus, Ohio & Ponte Vedra, Florida