You have a beautiful space, and I think it deserves a more sophisticated chandeiler. I see something bigger, with cristals.

painting it might help.

It depends on what direction you want to go with your interior design. Certainly the brass chandelier speaks of Williamsburg. So evidently you want an updated look. But do you want to remain traditional, or are you heading toward transitional, or even contemporary? Does one of these appeal to you, and if so, which one? The first one is transitional and the second more contemporary, though they are similar in style.
Carolyn Albert-Kincl, ASID

If you want something modern then you could look at something like this.