Software
Houzz Logo Print
lspswr

15 years ago
last modified: 15 years ago
What floors will survive longest in a home with pets and kids?
I'm so completely frustrated with trying to choose flooring. We have pets and children, high echo-y ceilings, open floor plan, and I need new flooring in the living room, dining room, entryway, hallway, family room, and kitchen. We have travertine in the bathrooms and carpet in the bedrooms which will stay, but everything else is up for change. We have birch floors in the entry through to the kitchen which look horrible and have been refinished twice already (they're too soft for our lifestyle), and we have carpet in the hallway, living room, dining room, and family room. I was thinking of replacing the carpet with hardwood, but am afraid the noise will be too much, and while I love hardwoods we're hard on the floors and they won't look nice for long. The carpets are a constant chore to keep clean and stain-free which is why I wanted to replace them with hard surface flooring, but I wonder if anything is really going to be "the answer." We live in the PNW mountains and cold winters are also a concern. HELP! I need your suggestions and experience!! Thanks!

Comments (16)

  • 15 years ago
    Have you considered ceramic tile or even stained concrete floors?
    With an underfloor radiant heat system and area rugs in your seating areas, you would be amazed at how warm and durable such floors can be.
  • 15 years ago
    Pocelain tile. Very durable, doesn't absorb, easy to maintain.
  • 15 years ago
    Wow Lisa - very intriguing and looks great. Will definitely be researching this further! Thanks so much for the reply and great info!
  • 15 years ago
    Totally agree with Lisa. Wood tile is a great choice. Certainly not inexpensive but will definetely last. Any porcelain will do. We carry two different wood tile lines that are pocelain. One line is more rustic made by Serenissima Barrique series and the other is our line Wood Impressions by Crossville. You can check it out on crossvilleinc.com.
  • 15 years ago
    I do want to mention few things about wood tile compared to hardwood floors:
    - kids run around and drop stuff all the time. tile cracks and breaks. hardwood only dents, which is an easy fix.
    - tile cannot be resanded to change the look (stain/color), hardwood can be. so if you style/decor changes, it's an easy change compared to lifting tile & buying it again.
    - kids run around the house bare foot all the time. hardwood is a natural insulator, but tile will remain cold.. its stone. kids might get sick more often.

    Just a few things to consider. Proper care and maintenance will make hardwood floors last a lifetime even with heavy traffic. Keep in mind, the value of home will go up a lot with hardwood floors unlike tile.

    Hope this helps =) Here's a blog post on advantages of hardwood
    http://bit.ly/jw3N2q

    viktor
  • 14 years ago
    Hi, Lise. Nice pictures. Does the wood tile have grout line? How thick? I like the concept but I am concerned that the grout will throw off the look. I've seen some pictures where the grout lines are pretty substantial.
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    Everyone still wants neat, clean carpet in the bedroom though. as long as its looked after and a carpet cleaner is called when spot and stain removal is needed (like http://www.go-clean.com.au ), then you dont have to worry about warped/scratched floorboards or dirty grout between tiles, and you get a much homelier feel!
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Hello lspswr,

    As you can see, there are some good points to consider hardwood for your floor however in your situation I would definitively go with tiles. "bepsf", "roxie30", and "Lisa Bogo" pointed the benefits of tiles out. There are so many different kind of tiles which different sizes and different shapes on the market. It will look great, is durable, comfortable and easy to clean. There are so many "pros". The only "contra" in my opinion would be the higher price.

    I am from Germany and over there lots of houses (especially the new ones) have almost the whole floor area tiled. The stairs are mostly "open" and built from natural stones like granite. Most of the floors have an under floor radiant heat system.

    However if you want to go with tiles, the preparation work is essential. There are a couple important things to do, to achieve a durable and "non breaking" tile floor.

    If you have any further questions or if you need any advise, we will be glad to help you.

    Regards,

    3D-Tile-Design - Bertram Tasch
    Maple Ridge, BC (Greater Vancouver)
    http://www.3D-Tile-Design.ca
    .
  • 14 years ago
    You should consider the new high end Laminate floors by Pergo.
  • 14 years ago
    HI -- Have a look at commercial flooring. If it lasts in malls and other public places it will last with your family. There is also Marmoliam (sp?)flooring.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    I'm a big fan of porcelain "wood". If you get the narrow widths (just like real wood) and use a 1/16" grout line, and if you choose something with a low patina that looks 3-dimensional and a little rustic, you will never know it isn't wood AND it will wear as though it is in a commercial installation. I absolutely swear by it.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Hello lspswr,

    If you decide to go with "hard-wood-looking" tiles please read this thread.

    https://www.houzz.com/discussions/looking-for-a-good-hand-scraped-wood-tile-dsvw-vd~151997

    Regards,

    3D-Tile-Design - Bertram Tasch
    Maple Ridge, BC (Greater Vancouver)
    http://www.3D-Tile-Design.ca
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Have you considered continuing the travertine? I really like this look and use it often. Have a look...
    Charmean Neithart Interiors, LLC. · More Info

    I have put this in many homes with pets and kids. It's very easy to take care of and no scratches. This picture is of a chiseled edge option, but it comes in a straight edge and many shades. Hope that helps. Charmean Neithart
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Since you have pets and kids , I suggest polyester / nylon rugs.Dhurries are another good option. Do not go in for a woolen rug in an all wool or an all loop pile as the pets have claws and the claws if entangled in the loop , will result in patches , thereby destroying the rug. You cannot stop pet wetting the floors. So let's say they wet the rugs . Overtime , if not treated with immediate effect , they give a bad , unpleasant odour. More importantly , colors may fade from that moist area. So I recommend you go in for druggets or Shag Rugs. They can be washed easily too.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Definitely CORK! For your family I would suggest a glue down application for it's longevity (it can last 75-100 years). If you are looking for an easy install then you can move towards the floating floor. Seal the floating floor against spills and accidents and you have a 25 year solution. By working with a floating floor, you can install cork underlayment (increases thermal efficiency and decrease echos) to add to the home's comfort level. Multiple options and looks (we carry more than 30 different styles to choose from) there is a look/color for every taste.