Software
Houzz Logo Print
mkirkwag

Buying encapsulated earthworm cocoons?

11 years ago

We haven't touched our front yard in 15 years. A tree came down on a giant viburnum so we took them both out to use as hugel beds. We discovered digging in the oddly sandy soil *not one earthworm*! I was astonished. I didn't expect rich soil, but that was a surprise. Now I wonder if there are any worms anywhere near enough to be attracted to the new beds. I'm working on the soil throughout the yard, and putting down things worms love, but I'm wondering if it will work. I know some places sell encapsulated work cocoons. I've always been leery about it - I'm not sure we should be importing "foreign worms" and I don't know what the survival rate would be. Anyone know the science behind it? Does it do any harm to bring them from elsewhere?

Comments (15)

  • 11 years ago

    Earthworms live on organic matter in the soil and will not be found in soils with very little or no organic matter. Get the level of organic matter up to a goodly amount and the worms will show up. Provide them with an environment they can live in and they will. There is no good reason to spend money buying earthworms.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 11 years ago

    Hi, kimmq. I think you missed part of my post. We're adding organic matter. My concern is that it's such a large area with concrete around it, they won't show up. My question is or isn't; it's what the science is around the efficacy and safety of this practice.

  • 11 years ago

    I did not miss anything in your post. The people that sell earthworms and earthworm eggs will tell you that it is a good thing for you to send them your money but whether you will get what you need depends on too much guess work on your part. Which earthworms do you need, what species?

    Get the environment that earthworms like made and they will appear.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 11 years ago

    Actually kimmq, I have reason for my (minor) concern. I do understand earthworms and their needs as well as you do, and when I created a lasagna bed at the edge of this area a couple years ago I included lots earthworm-attractive elements. The soil is nice now - still a little clumpy, but good. Lots of biological activity- still no worms. But really not my big concern.

    Still, while I'm pretty much with you, I'd love to hear some responses to my underlying questions, which was more scientific curiosity: does anyone know if there's *data* showing that this is a good or bad idea in terms of the environment? These sales can be useful to people just starting worm bins, etc., but has it been shown to bad environmental impacts? Do those cocoons survive to become worms?


  • 11 years ago

    I am not sure how this situation is any different from purchasing/importing other beneficial organisms to assist with one's garden. Folks purchase lady beetles and beneficial nematodes, praying mantis and lacewings and aphid parasites with no concerns and with typically some success from their efforts. Why should bringing in worms - if current populations are low - be any different?

    As long as they are composting worms - Eisenia foetida or Lumbricus rebellus - and not night crawlers or bait worms, I would have no concerns about environmental impacts. And shipping the worms as encapsulated eggs is apparently a lot less stressful on the worms than shipping live adults. And if directions are followed the cocoons do survive to produce worms.

  • 11 years ago

    Purchasing beneficial insects is a big business that does little real good. Many people that have purchased beneficial insects have seen them leave their garden. If a gardener makes the environment one that is suitable for the beneficial insects they will move in on their own and purchasing them will not be necessary.

    If earthworms are going to live in the soil they should not be "composting worms" but instead should be one of the many earth dwelling species. "Composting worms" need an environment that is higher in organic material than even the earth dwelling earthworms need.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 11 years ago

    Well, now that we've heard from our resident 'Professor of Entomology' on the fallacies of this practice, I guess we can all rest easier.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    mkirkwag, you might feel better if you remember that earthworms are not essential to a good soil. Yes, they are beneficial (in most environments), hugely so....but not essential. They aren't even native, having been inadvertently introduced to North America by European settlers.

    You can even have a healthy vigorous garden without these fine little animals. I spent over twenty years growing in deep sandy soil, where earthworms were few and far between. The soil was like a bottomless pit; huge volumes of organic matter soon disappeared.

    But it didn't prevent that area from becoming home to some of the finest and oldest gardens in the country.

    I'm supremely confident that you can build a worm friendly environment in a relatively short period of time, and I advise you to do so without importing earthworms. "If you build it, they will come", as they say. ;-)

  • 11 years ago

    It is possible that your yard may not have many worms. Pick up some of your neighbors bagged leaves this fall. Those leaves will have on them worm eggs. Use them as compost or mulch. The worms eggs will hatch, and they will get on with life in your yard.

    If you want an enduring population of worms keep feeding them.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks gardengal48. I agree in theory, but it didn't quite sit right. I was thinking in terms of the discovery that purchased ladybugs are usually wild harvested and sometimes bring diseases and parasites along with them that didn't exist in the are before. I wondered if that could happen with worms, but really, we move so much stuff around, probably worms are the least of our worries. You're the only one who talked about my question! :-)

    What rhizo says is interesting. I've been gardening for long enough for my hair to turn white and I've never had a good garden that wasn't wormy, so I'm surprised, but glad to hear it. I've never had the worms not show up within a few months, even on a sandbar, so it was very surprising not to see any. Other parts of my garden are reasonably wormy. The soil is, indeed, pretty sandy (that was a surprise, too. I live in the Pacific Northwest).

    For the person who seems fairly distressed by my question, please try not to worry so much. I'm not planning on ordering worms cocoons and will only do so if I really think there will be a benefit, but I was very curious about studies done on the the practice. Clearly there have been none.

  • 11 years ago

    3 years and hundreds of cubic yards of manure, leaves, woodchips and grass clippings later, my garden soil is starting to change from barren sand and just enough clay to turn to concrete to looking doggone good. I've only seen 3 or 4 earthworms in the wild during that time. Even out in the woods when I'm digging and playing around, I just don't see them.

  • 11 years ago

    Huh. And HUNDREDS? That must be a big yard! Three years seems about right. My lasagna beds are functional in the first year, but don't become really good for about that long. I did a small one last year trying to take advantage of fungal activity based on someone's diagram. I won't do it that way again - all those wood chips take too long to break down! Plus, the bark mulch kept the rain out. Sheesh. We get plenty of fungal activity in the Pacific Northwest, so it's back to the old-style (chip less) beds for me!

  • 11 years ago

    Yep, I am playing on 10 acres, so I have a lot of room to try different things.

  • 11 years ago

    OK, I've found what was niggling at me, and the answer is yes, it *might* be a bad idea. http://www.redwormcomposting.com/general-commentary/do-composting-worms-pose-a-threat-as-invasive-species/

    some excepts:

    "Concern over the potential for non-native earthworms to become invasive, and have a negative impact on ecosystems in various parts of North America has gained considerable attention in recent years. The full scope of the problem has yet to be determined, but there is substantial academic research evidence to suggest that various species of earthworms have been significantly altering native ecosystems in regions where they’ve been introduced – particular in areas where no earthworms have been previously found. (Callaham et al. 2006)."

    "

    • Much of the concern seems focused on northern deciduous and boreal forest ecosystems – particularly those with no native species of earthworms. It is believed that glaciation – which affected much of northern North America – wiped out all native earthworms, and thus all species found in this part of the continent are thought to be introduced (mainly from Europe). Some of the areas where research has been conducted include the northern states (particularly Minnesota), Alberta Canada, New York State and the Great Lakes Region (Larson et al. 2010).
      **This is NOT to suggest that there is no potential for concerns in other areas, however**

    • One of the main issues is the resulting loss of the “O Horizon” – the uppermost layer in the soil profile (consisting primarily of fallen leaves and other organic matter in forest environments) and mixing of organic matter into the “A Horizon” (next layer down) once certain invasive species become established. When no earthworms are present, this organic matter breakdown generally takes place over the course of years – whereas the process is often greatly accelerated when earthworms are present.

    • This rapid breakdown of O Horizon can greatly impact nutrient cycling – some evidence to suggest that certain key nutrients such as nitrogen (N) and phosphorus (P) become less available, or end up lost via leaching as a result (Hale et al. 2005; Frelich et al. 2006). It has been found to reduce understory vegetation and result in the loss of certain plant species altogether (namely those dependent on the habitat, and other benefits provided by the O Horizon).

    • Full grasp of the potential long-term impact this could have has not yet been determined. As per usual in the world of scientific research – much more work is needed.

    • There seems to be some debate among researchers regarding the importance of the natural spread of established earth worm populations VS human-assisted introduction/spread (Hale 2008b) – the latter certainly being the one that gets the most attention.

    • Different invasive earthworms species have different habitat/feeding preferences (belong to different “functional groups”) and thus different impacts on the ecosystems into which they spread or are introduced. Different combinations of species can result in different impacts as well (Hale et al. 2008).
      Bottom-line, it’s important not to make generalizations."

    • The focus of this article is composting worms, not other earthworms, with a conclusion that our E. fetida are probably not a problem. Nightcrawlers and blue worms, however, may be. My conclusion the sellers of encapsulated worm cocoons should be very certain about what they're selling, and that they should probably not be selling them for use in the soil. Certainly there's nothing conclusive out there, but it seems obvious to me that we don't sufficiently understanding the impact to messing about.