Software
Houzz Logo Print
paul_jenkins40

Soil or sand for dragon trees?

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

I use coir for most of my plants, but recently realised that coir doesn't drain off very well and holds on to too much moisture for too long. So, I added sand to it to help with the drainage.

Is it okay to grow dragon trees almost exclusively in sand (gritty, of course)? All the pictures I have looked at online shows the dragon trees growing almost exclusively in sand in the wild, but online 'plant experts' say 'a well draining potting soil'.

Thank you

Comments (4)

  • 11 years ago

    The soil in situ plants are found growing in would almost always be a death sentence if you tried growing the plant in the same soil in a container, so forget using 'what plants usually grow in in the wild' as any sort of reasonable yardstick for determining what they prefer in a pot. Heck - because of being outcompeted by more vigorous species for their favored spots, it's not unusual to find plants growing (in the wild) in soils they don't like at all.

    When you think about soils, think about their structure and how long they are able to retain it. Forget about a container soil's ability to feed the plant; you can learn to do that very well in 5 minutes. If you learn how to build a soil that holds enough water and air to satisfy the plants needs w/o one stepping on the toes of the other (IOW - avoiding too much water or too much air - but generally the focus is on avoiding too much water and not enough air) you're golden. Understanding and overcoming the impact a poor soil has on your ability to keep your plants healthy is a roadblock that virtually every container grower faces, yet few ever move beyond because they don't even recognize the limitations imposed by their soils. As long as you're growing in a commercially prepared medium based on peat, compost, coir, composted forest products, sand, topsoil, or a combination of these and other fine ingredients, it's a pretty solid bet that you're not getting even close to what the growing experience can offer out of your plants.

    Al

    Paul Jenkins thanked tapla (mid-Michigan, USDA z5b-6a)
  • 11 years ago

    In five words or less ....... it isn't going to work

  • 11 years ago

    I can't tell you how many times I've read an "expert's"/ author's advice to use a potting soil that drains well, and then have them completely destroy their credibility by offering a list of potential soils that DON'T drain well. A soil that drains well is one you can water to beyond saturation w/o the need to worry it's going to stay soggy so long it rots roots or seriously inhibits root function. As far as I'm concerned, a soil doesn't deserve to be called good or appropriate unless it allows you to water correctly w/o significant sacrifice in the way of vitality and potential. In most cases, the only way you'll ever SEE the lost potential is when you change to an appropriate soil so you have that basis for comparison. Being able to water correctly w/o sacrifice is no small thing; in fact, it's a game changer.

    Al

    Paul Jenkins thanked tapla (mid-Michigan, USDA z5b-6a)
  • 11 years ago

    With words like that I'm happy to be an amateur :)