Software
Houzz Logo Print
littleprince2

cancelled couch order - what to do now?

11 years ago

Hello - I just couldn't go through with my couch order (for a rolled arm sofa with 6 detachable cushions from sears). The fabrics weren't quite right, and I really didn't want the roll arm. The comfort was excellent, however.

I'm wondering if you have any advice about the quality level of the couch for use with kids who are 8 and 10 years old. I would like to buy a couch in the $2-3K range--for better looks, the ability to select exactly the fabric I want, and durability --- BUT, will the couches get 'trashed' by the kids anyway?

Should I bother getting a more expensive couch? Should I stick with mid-range from sears?

At this point, I feel I know myself a little, I know what i like, and i know that a navy couch would be best for me.

My kids are 8 and 10. They don't eat on the couch, but they might have dirty hands and feet sometimes, and tend to 'horse around' on the couch.

Thanks.

Comments (35)

  • 11 years ago

    I don't have kids, only cats, so take my suggestion for what it's worth: Teach your kids not to horse around on the couch and not to sit on it when they're dirty. Buy one in the fabric that you want, and make its arrival an opportunity for your kids to start thinking differently about things in the home. My parents never let us "play" on the furniture, and my brothers and I grew up respecting the items that our parents worked hard for, which translated into a respect for the items in our own homes and wanting to care for them so they'd last. Of course, I know that sometimes accidents happen, but that was very rare in the home I grew up in because we kids KNEW that mom and dad meant business when it came to respecting THEIR furniture.

    I hope you'll take my words in the good spirit in which they are intended. Not trying to tell you how to raise kids - just really sharing what worked well in my parents' home.

    Now, don't get me started on CATS. Can't teach them much of anything, as evidenced by the claw marks one of them inflicted on our brand new sofa yesterday afternoon.

  • 11 years ago

    You could get a mid range sofa with slipcovers until the kids are older...win win....you're not breaking the bank and can easily wash away any mishaps. Many folks also look for older, better made sofas on Craigslist and thrift stores and have them reupholstered or slip covered.

    littleprince2 thanked joaniepoanie
  • 11 years ago

    I echo Auntjen's sentiments. My grandkids are 9 and 11, which is just a bit older than your two, and they don't roughhouse on my sofa. I have leather, but that's because of my two Aussies, who aren't allowed on the furniture, but whose fur deposits dirt on the sides as they walk by. I would suggest leather for you as well. You can get a Bradington Young sofa, made in the U.S., for under $3000. I would look for one with 3 straight cushions so you can distribute wear, and either an attached cushion or tight back. Be careful buying leather because cheap furniture stores can lure you into buying a bonded leather that looks great now and is ready for the curb in 6 months.

    Is there some reason you're only looking at Sears? I don't think they're known for quality furniture.

  • 11 years ago

    I have a 4 year old and a 1 year old, a little nonshedding but sometimes barfing dog who is allowed on the furniture, and a husband who is about as trainable as a cat ;) So I feel your pain!

    I couldn't find a leather or dark colored couch that I was happy with, so I ended up ordering a cream slipcovered sofa in a "performance" fabric. It's supposedly washable and bleachable and scrubable and all that. I got a sample and smushed a blackberry into it and I was able to get the stain out with a wet rag. But I don't have it yet so I can't really tell you how it will hold up. I do believe I've seen these type of fabrics in navy though.

  • 11 years ago

    My cats do so much more damage than kids do. I do have high expectations of not only my kids but also guests and I gently remind children of these expectations if they are not being met. I think children who are expected to respect and appreciate nice things grow up to be thoughtful, responsible and respectable adults.

    It is your house and it should be comfortable to you as well as the rest of your family so I second getting a nice pretty yet comfortable sofa and the children can be told to respect the new pieces and still be children who enjoy their house.

    i like lee sofas and thomasville has some lovely midrange sofas and lots of options for upholstery.

  • 11 years ago

    My approach to child-rearing differs. We allowed rough-housing and eating on the family room sofa. Since my kids are grown now, I can safely say that they have still turned out to be thoughtful, responsible and respectable adults.

    littleprince2 thanked sjhockeyfan325
  • 11 years ago

    I'm still trying to train my 3 and 5 year old grandchildren how to use furniture correctly since their parents don't seem up to the task. In FR, Me: No jumping on the sofa. DGC: Uh, OK. One hour later in bedroom, Me: No jumping on the furniture. DGC: Uh, OK. What's furniture?

    , get slip covers and train the children. Win/win: The children get trained and "accidents" can be cleaned more easily.

    littleprince2 thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Guess I am a mom who would be mortified if my child jumped on someone else's furniture or treated school property inappropriately so it is easier to set universal rules and expectations for my little ones.

  • 11 years ago

    It's beyond the scope of the OP's question, which wasn't really whether or not she should let her kids jump on the sofa, but what she should be looking for in a sofa that would stand up to the real possibility that at some point, someone in her house may jump on the sofa.

    I can tell my 4 year old a gazillion times a day not to jump on the sofa, to wipe his face off after eating blackberries, to not open his play doh cans on the couch. I could tell him things all day long not to do. But fact is, he has to do it before I can correct him. And if I can teach him not to wipe chocolate on the couch while NOT being stressed out about ruining thousands of dollars worth of furniture, I'll be more able to do it in a calm and controlled manner. And he'll be a happier boy when I remind him gently instead of screaming :)

    littleprince2 thanked Butternut
  • 11 years ago

    I think the comments about how children are taught to regard furniture are germane to the OP's question, in that she asked for advice as to the quality level she should purchase and asked if we thought the kids would trash the couch. I certainly hope she doesn't take offense to my statements (or anyone else's), but I do think the observations made are viable and constructive.

  • 11 years ago

    Also taught my kids to respect our things. The other day DH was at one of our arm chairs (small scale) that has its back to the kitchen and he was talking to DS1 in the kitchen. DH put his hands on the arms and his knee into the seat ... I gave him the "look" and he quickly removed his knee from the seat!! Obviously, a continuous process ;-) . A quick way to stretch out a sofa seat cushion is to place all your weight on one knee and into the fabric. I've also taught the kids not to sit on the top of a sofa back or on the arms. I had no problem telling visiting kids that they could not stand or jump on our sofas, something my kids were taught not to do.


    I would also choose leather if this is your primary seating area or find a sofa brand that can be ordered in a sunbrella fabric or similar indoor/outdoor fabric.

    littleprince2 thanked chispa
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Chispa, I "caught" my DH sitting down the other day on our new sofa just as you describe - knee-first, then settling down on top of his leg. He's a big dude, and I was not pleased. Someone should have taught him years ago not to do that. It's a little awkward now, as I'm not his mommy and I fear coming across as a nag. (Although I'll correct him anyway. I certainly don't want our new stuff mistreated.)

    ;-)

    littleprince2 thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    OP, I have similarly aged kids (6 and 11yo), just bought new sofas in the spring, and I agree with @butternut & @sjhockeyfan. About a thousand percent. Now, I have a 1900 sq ft house and my kids are both gigantic boys. And our living/family room has a door to the backyard. I work FT and can't/won't spend my life policing where their dirty knees might land. So YMMV.

    Lectures from people who don't have kids, or who have rules that apply to occasionally visiting grandchildren, are all surely well intended. But they are not realistic points of reference for someone who actually has to live FT with kids. My boys would never jump on the sofas in a relative's home. Still, daily life with kids is messy, and it doesn't get un-messy simply because you buy new furniture. I wanted my home to be a comfortable and appealing place for my kids and their friends to hang out. And I didn't want to become a screaming banshee everytime they made a mess or smooshed a cushion (as @butternut said, easier to correct them gently when it's not an investment piece.)

    If you have the luxury of more space, more time, more docile children, thank your lucky stars and go with whatever suits your own preferences and budget. But if your kids spend much time in the room where the sofa is going, take their habits into consideration, for your own sanity.

    I went with midrange from Macys, in a dark durable fabric. I also spent a lot of time testing (and reading reviews) on the durability of the cushions. SO far (since Feb or March) they have held up beautifully.

    littleprince2 thanked smalloldhouse_gw
  • 11 years ago

    To the OP, find a Norwalk Furniture dealer. 1000s of fabric choices, pretty fast delivery, made in the USA.


    littleprince2 thanked maddielee
  • 11 years ago

    Not to belabor the point, but I am one who said I don't have children; however, I WAS a child and I remember clearly what I and my brothers were taught in regard to the way that we treated our family's possessions. I did not "lecture." I stated my experience and my opinion, which is what we ALL do here.

    littleprince2 thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    We are in a similar position. We have a five year old and a twelve year old. Our kids aren't allowed to jump on furniture. We don't usually allow them to eat in the living room and so on. But they are kids. They make mistakes. They forget the rules. Oh and dh spills soda and our dog puts his paws up on stuff even through that's not allowed either. I don't want any thing to be so precious that these mistakes and mishaps stress me out.


    I have posted here a few different times on topics like this over the last few months as we look to replace our current sofa and I contemplate a couple of new chairs and a new rug as well. My conclusion is that we are buying middle of the road stuff that I hope will last ten years or so. I think thats the best value for us right now. For me that's a price point where I won't freak out if something gets damaged, but also where it's not disposable junk.


    I just ordered a leather sleeper sofa from club furniture. It's right around $2,400 including delivery. It's replacing the one we have from them which lasted about seven years. We did not take good care of the leather so I'm hoping we can extend the life of this new piece with better attention to cleaning and conditioning the leather.


    For chairs, we will be waiting until we have saved some money. I'm thinking I will look for sunbrella or equivalent fabric and target chairs in the same price bracket.


    For the rug, first I'm going to try to clean what we have to see if we can get another year or two out of it. But if that doesn't work, I'm planning to look for a polypropylene indoor-outdoor type rug because they are supposed to be virtually impervious to stains. And that's what will make my life easier at this point.



    littleprince2 thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 11 years ago

    I have the Milan leather sofa from Macy's. It's held up so well to kids, grandkids and dogs that my daughter bought one as well. Very comfy, durable and on sale now.

    littleprince2 thanked k9arlene
  • 11 years ago

    Ethan Allen. My DD just bought the Bennett, and so did my cousin. On sale, starting price $1500. Then depending on fabric, add up from there.


    littleprince2 thanked eld61
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I have a young family in addition to watching two nieces, under three, in my home every weekday during the school year in less than 1900sf and I do not have to police or raise my voice and all of these children I am helping to raise are happy, fun loving children and yet they can eat off of China, drink with out sippy cups and not destroy my home. For many families life need not be messy and chaotic but for others it works but I do not need to be made to feel wrong for expecting more from my own children and others.

    littleprince2 thanked roarah
  • 11 years ago

    I just bought cheap sofa frames from world market and spent as much making nice slip covers for everything


    I told my adult son "hey no sitting on the arms". Next week thing I know my 92 year old mom is sitting on the arms.... Should I meantion the cat claw marks? I am making a new cat tree and am thankful mom is light. :)

    littleprince2 thanked Kippy
  • 11 years ago

    I think it's good that you cancelled the order from Sears because you weren't on board 100%. When in doubt, always follow your gut.

    As far as what you should buy, as you can see by the wide variety of comments above, every family has a different dynamic and only you are going to know what is right for you and yours. $3000.00 is a decent budget for a sofa so you'll have a lot of options to choose from but that can be overwhelming. Rather than approach it as one big project, I would break it down into steps. First: figure out what your priorities or preferences are regarding style, wear and color. Second: shop around to narrow your options down to a few alternatives. Third: do a little research about the ones you like and then buy which ever is the best fit.

    littleprince2 thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Get a good leather sofa. Mine is a Flexsteel about 23 years old. I paid around $3K. If I get out the saddle conditioner it looks new. It is a hide-a-bed. It will live in my study in the new house. It has made it through my two kids, all their friends, several generations of dogs and cats. Pet birds.

    Be careful though. It is out of style in all its burgundy trimmed with green splendor; I just cant seem to part with it. Sometime things don't have to last forever.

    littleprince2 thanked missymoo12
  • 11 years ago

    I just recently replaced my old leather sofa that had a rip in the seat, springs wearing through the frame, and the back cushions sagging so horrificly that it looked sad. It was 10 years old and I was ready to ditch it for a new look--a decade with one sofa and I'm ready for a change. I spent about as much as your budget and bought a stylish Ethan Allen Chesterfield and it makes me soooo happy! It's fabric and I have littles, but fabrics today are so much easier to clean up. I caught my one-yr-old taking an orange crayon to it and it came up easily. My advice: get what you LOVE; life is too short.

  • 11 years ago

    I think whether your kids will get the furniture dirty depends a lot on the kids play lifestyle. where you live, what type of "mess" your kids get into. My kids at that age didn't get super dirty but we live in a condo with mostly grassy play areas. If you live where the kids would get dirty outside, muddy in wet months, that type of thing that may be something to consider. I know for myself when considering new LR furniture, I opted for brown leather to hide as much as possible knowing our habits. I have a leather sectional from Macys going on 2.5 yrs with no issues and still happy with it. I believe I got it on sale for about $1800.

    littleprince2 thanked always1stepbehind
  • 11 years ago

    Navy would be a good dirt hider too. I just reread you post saying Navy would work best for you. I hope you can find another comfortable sofa in a style you prefer and navy. $2-$3K sounds like a pretty decent budget IMO.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for all your feedback.

    The couch is my only couch, subject to constant use, and visible from the kitchen and dining room in my open-concept, small, home.

    I really like the idea of a dark fabric couch. Love the sunbrella idea! Not as keen on the slipcovered look, although love it in other people's house. Leather is too masculine for me, although I understand how amazingly durable it is, and if I were slightly more practical, I would choose it.

    I'll try to find an Ethan Allen dealer locally and see their offerings. The price is right.

    Below are pictures of my current sofas, and the house. I think they've held up extremely well, (pattern hides dirt well) but the couches are quite uncomfortable with their low backs, so recovering is not really what I want to do (too bad though).

    I've also attached a picture of a sofa that I like from a looks, quality, and colour perspective. It is $2900 for the three seater (this is smaller than what I'd get). I'd get it in the navy. It doesn't come in sunbrella, unfortunately, so I'm going to look into a few other options before deciding.

    Thanks again for your input!

  • 11 years ago

    Another place to look is Bassett, particularly when they have a sale - friends (who can definitely afford more) got a Bassett sofa for their TV room and are very pleased with it. You can customize a bunch of features.

    littleprince2 thanked sjhockeyfan325
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    LP2...oh, what a great space. What's on the other side of living room where the tv is? Would you be able to move the tv to the other corner by the window or in front of window and possibly get a small scale sectional in there? Love the navy swatch for that sofa btw.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    A1SB - I'll show you a pic of that corner tonight. I do think I could squeeze a sectional in here.

    Thanks SJHockeyfan. I'll look into Bassett.

  • 11 years ago

    I love the navy and it's a nice looking couch. I do think you could probably find something similar in navy sunbrella somewhere in your price range, though!

    littleprince2 thanked Butternut
  • 11 years ago

    Some places will let you bring your own fabric (COM=customer's own material). So you might be able to supply sunbrella or equivalent fabric for a sofa you like even if they don't offer it as an option of their own.

    littleprince2 thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 11 years ago

    crl_ : I just checked the manufacturer's site, and they have a COM option. 28 yrd. So yay! I'll bring this up with the sales agent and see what she says.

  • 11 years ago

    Let us know how that works out. I have been wondering how it effects pricing.

    littleprince2 thanked Nothing Left to Say
  • 11 years ago

    What a lovely space! The navy looks great.

    littleprince2 thanked smalloldhouse_gw