Software
Houzz Logo Print
jackiew12345

need help picking a kitchen floor

11 years ago

I am lucky enough to be re-doing my kitchen with beautiful antique white raised panel with alot of detail cabinets (no glaze). I am stuck picking a floor....I see so much that I like about both, but they are opposites. The kitchen floor will also run into the dining room. I like french country and cottage looks with a twist of traditional. Here are the 2 floors with the color of the cabinets and also the accent color which will be used in small amounts along with the hardware for the cabinets. My dining room walls are a lighter shade of the green. I love these floors because they both have that distressed look. Any thoughts?

Comments (25)

  • 11 years ago
    I like the darker floor. Not my style at all, but looks like a great start. Shiny copper pots.... Thick, creamy china bowls.
    jackiew12345 thanked gustaviatex
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks gustaviatex...I smiled at your comment about creamy china bowls..I have creamy crate and barrel chunky bowls and will be getting all the plates to match. Truly appreciate as many comments as I can get..I want to make a decision and move on to countertops and backsplash !

  • 11 years ago

    Cancork Floor Inc. ...Thanks for your input ! The lighter floor is actually cream and tan/brown...it did look gray after I posted the pic. But Im going to assume you still vote for the darker floor. I have seen alot less "all cream/light kitchens"...so I was wondering if that means it would be more "trendy" than "timeless". Just a thought. You make a great point about the 100 + year old look...thanks!

  • 11 years ago

    I like the lighter floor between those two.

  • 11 years ago
    I love both your choices of flooring and your kitchen is looking like it is going to be fabulous. Good job so far. I like your style! It's hard for me to choose but I think I would eventually choose the darker to play it safe. But the lighter would haunt me forever. Good luck.
    jackiew12345 thanked texasboykin
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    The darker one goes better with your choices and the look you're after. Good luck!

    jackiew12345 thanked Alicia Paley Home Interiors
  • 11 years ago

    I like the darker one, it's richer.

    jackiew12345 thanked happyleg
  • 11 years ago

    Oohh...like both choices too, I can see why you are stuck! Here's a tip my builder gave me--floor/cabinet/counter--one is light, one is dark, one is medium. That combo compliments each other with one dominating. If you're doing variation, pick the darker. If you're going for a white or more monochromatic, go with the lighter wood. Either way, once it's down & done you'll love it.

    jackiew12345 thanked mbsan63
  • 11 years ago
    I like the darker floor. I like the rich tone contrasted against the white cabinets.
    jackiew12345 thanked D DN
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks texasboykin.....had a good laugh with the comment about the light floor haunting me...thats what I was thinking lol....but maybe long term the darker floor is something I wont get tired of. Just want to decide...this kitchen has to last !

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    We installed CA Classics distressed oak floor and love it but one thing is the wire brushing or grooves collect everything. If you spill something you need a brush to get it out of the wire brush grooves. Sounds trivial but had son drop cupcake and white icing was dried in the grooves and it took a bit to get it all out.

    Worth it to us though we just don't serve cupcakes.

  • 11 years ago
    Thanks for the comments wannabath...I figured that will be an issue but it makes the floor look so real! Which color do you like better or didn't you have a preference?
  • 11 years ago
    I really like both. I think the darker color will highlight the other colors more dramatically.
  • 11 years ago
    I like the darker.
  • 11 years ago

    darker

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I like darker more.

  • 11 years ago
    jlorie...I have a very similar pic pinned for the lantern pendants which is very French country in my opinion ....that kitchen is beautiful and I do like the contrast. Wish I had room for a beautiful island. Thanks for your help!
  • 11 years ago
    How large are your rooms and the amount of light. If you are undecided between the two, it might make a difference.
  • 11 years ago
    darker.but sure love the lighter. anytime a pro answers u shud go with that, I think
  • PRO
    11 years ago

    How big is the room ? do you have an island ? what is the countertop made of ? what is the backsplash made of ? what is the color of your dining room furniture ? all these have to be taken in consideration. Maybe you should post photos and we could help with a well thought decision...not what the look is with only samples.

  • 11 years ago

    There is no island. The kitchen is about 12 x12 and the dining room is about 13 x 14 . Right now it is a walk thru but the in the new plans their will be a peninsula so that the 2 rooms will be visually open to each other..I know that will open the space up dramatically. There is one window with afteroon sun coming in to the kitchen. My dining room is attached to a family room that has a slider with light. My counter top will be granite or quartz (havent picked it yet) I was thinking of a classic subway tile in a very faint green for the backsplash..I have also seen the Walker Zanger morrocan tile which is beautiful..but am open to ideas. fyi I am not afraid to paint the hutch in the dining room...I refinished the top of my dining room table which was very dark and then painted & distressed the bottom section.

  • 11 years ago

    Your hutch is beautiful! Don't paint it. I would remove flowers in picture. Let it be natural. Put a table runner down.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Definitely the one on the left (the darker). It's more of neutral and will transition better and also gives a nice contrast.

  • 10 years ago

    Please show us the update! We really like to see!