Software
Houzz Logo Print
vishketan

Marvin pine windows staining questions

11 years ago

Hi

I am looking to have my Marvin windows and patio doors stained before installation. I have 14 windows (3 picture, 2 picture casement, and rest casement) and 2 patio doors (one 3 panel door and one 4 panel door). I got a few quotes and they are all over the place.

- One painter said that he absolutely needs to use a pre-stain wood conditioner before he can apply the stain. Another says that the wood is stain ready from the factory and therefore stain can directly be applied.

- One estimates that the job will take 2 persons somewhere between 30 - 40 hrs. The other quotes 85 hrs for two persons.

- The stains and varnish they recommend are also different.


Needless to say I am totally confused. Can someone weigh in on the following:


- Do the Marvin windows need to be pre-conditioned before staining?

- Any guidance on which of the two time estimates is more realistic?

- Any guidance on the stains and finish coat? Water based? Oil based? Gel? Any recommended brands?


thanks


vishy

Comments (28)

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I have seen better results with conditioners. If it was me, I would take every precaution to make them as perfect as possible.

  • 11 years ago

    I agree with the use of conditioner. Pine can be a bear t o get the stain even without using a conditioner.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Pine is a soft wood. Not always, but sometimes, it will absorb a lot of stain, resulting in light / dark uneven staining. Conditioners help the stain to be even.

    I have used both solvent based polyurethane and acrylic based polyurethane on my windows (different homes).

    Solvent based varnish is the 'old fashioned' varnish - it smells, takes a day to dry. Also it will 'warm' (yellow) as it ages. It gives the grain a nice 3D look.

    Acrylic varnish has little smell, dries fairly quickly, and does not yellow. However it does not bring out the grain.

    Solvent based will 'build' (thickness of coat) with less coats than acrylic.

    Verathane and MinWax are the two I've used.

    Varnish manufacturers have sample boards, with their stains and varnish applied to pine / oak. Go to a good paint store (or maybe a big box store) and look at the samples.

    You need to get the particulars in writing to compare apples to apples:

    • Conditioner yes / no brand of conditioner
    • Color of stain / brand of stain
    • Acrylic or Solvent
    • Brand of varnish - satin?
    • Number of coats ( I do 3 )
    • Labor cost (forget the man hours)

    Get all that in a contract. Be sure to look at the product the painters are using and that they match the brand / color / sheen that's on you contract.

    If you're in the north - it's getting late to varnish.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    I prefer oil base and never condition usually use min wax, varathane, old masters, just depends on the color needed.you should use someone who is familiar with the Marvins as they should be broken down and weatherstrip removed and be properly stored. Painter should have ample room as they will take a lot of space when disassembled. Around here there are finishers who specialize in this. Talk to your dealer and see if they have someone they use. I would want them to provide a sample on Marvins own wood to sign off on. Job should be bid not quoted in hours, I would be Leary of the painters who quoted you.

  • 11 years ago

    Have you seen Marvin's factory applied stains? I think they are very nice and they run the gamut from light (honey) to very dark (espresso). Very reasonably priced as well. I would recommend that if you go with one of the lighter finishes that you choose the MGR doug fir over the standard pine. The wood shows more character. Hope this helps.

  • 11 years ago

    Hi


    Thanks for your replies. I have two more questions:

    - I read that it is better to stain windows before installation. My installer is suggesting that I should stain them after they are installed. Which is better?

    - Does anybody have recommendations for places which will bid on such a job in the SF bay area? (should I be talking to painters? woodworkers? totally confused:( )


    @East Bay 10: The windows have already been delivered to our house. So factory finishing is no longer an option. I looked at vertical grain douglas fir option but it was around 15% more expensive and therefore out of my budget.

    @toddinmn: is there any online tutorial or video that shows how the windows can be disassembled and the weatherstrip removed?

    @geoffery_b: thanks for your tips. I live in the SF bay area. Hopefully, it is not too cold to varnish.

    thanks



  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My Marvin windows were double hung - so it was easy to take them out of the frame.

    Varnish can run or sag. I think it would be better to varnish them horizontally. I used saw horses, and some old hollow core doors. You have a large job there, and they will need a lot of space. I just put 'blue tape' over the weather strip / gasket.

    I'm just a DIY'er / amateur woodworker / engineer - but I'd stain, give 3 coats on the windows, give two coats on the frames. After installation touch up any dings on the frames and apply the third coat.

  • 11 years ago

    Hi


    Thanks everybody for their insightful comments. I got two quotes for the job but both are unsatisfactory. One is outrageously high (8500 dollars to stain 14 windows and 2 patio doors) and another one is low but I am not confident of the skill level of the person who bid. So now I am back to square one.


    If any of you have recommendations for a stainer who has experience with Marvin windows in the SF bay area, please let me know. Thanks in advance for your help.


    thanks




  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Have you checked with the supplier or lumber yard they came from?

  • 11 years ago

    Yes. The problem is that the staining person who used to work with my window installer apparently retired recently and does not want to do such a big job :(

  • 11 years ago

    I'll put on my project managers (software) hat... just a guess ... 14 windows: Set-up space to finish windows. (4 hrs) Take windows out of frame, lightly sand, tack off, apply stain control (8 hrs) Apply stain to windows and frame (12 hrs). Apply first coat of varnish. Sand (8 hrs). Apply 2 more coats of varnish (16 hrs). Clean up varnish on glass, reassemble windows (8 hrs)..

    4 + 8 + 12 + 8 + 16 + 8 = 56 hours + 16 hrs (for 2 doors) = 72 hrs + 8 hr clean-up = 80 hrs. Rate per hour $60 / $75 ? - $4,800 - $5,600 ??

    I don't know about SF Bay area, but are there any shops like Rockler or Woodcraft? More skilled woodworkers buy finishing products at these places. Or Google SF Bay wood working shops - maybe you can get a lead from someone.

  • 11 years ago

    80 hrs or 80 man hrs? The time estimates I am getting are 170 man hrs (2 persons x 85 hrs) for the initial staining at 35 dollars/person. Then an additional 2700 dollars to come back and do touchups. That is how the 8500 dollar bid was justified.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My guess was 80 man hours. I estimate a lot of software projects, and I do woodworking as a hobby. Estimates are estimates, and each person is entitled to his own. The best way to figure is to break the job into components that are estimable - not fuzzy 'lumps'. I also didn't take into consideration the size of the windows - the larger something is, the more difficult to manage. You may need two people to move the windows - I don't know? There may be limited space, and they will need to shuffle the windows?

    I don't think you can dismantle, stain, 3 coats of varnish, and reassemble 14 windows in a week. The other problem is that if you need two people (cause of the size, weight, etc) they may not be productive for an entire 8 hrs a day. What do they do with those hours? Lastly there's travel time back and forth from the site.

    The doors need to be installed, before you remove them to stain / varnish. This could be done after the windows.

    IMO, the best deal is to find an independent guy.

  • 11 years ago

    We're pretty close on price at $5,600.

    "Then an additional 2700 dollars to come back and do touchups"

    That's 77 hrs @ $35/hr! What are they going to do for the touchups? Apply another coat of varnish to all the windows? I would think the touchups to be 8 to 16 man hrs.

    You could ask him how he arrived at 77 hrs.

  • 11 years ago

    The $5600 is for 2 persons doing 85 hrs of work (each person is 35 dollars/hr). In any case, I think it is clear that I need to get more bids. The problem seems to be that a) not all painters do staining and b) the ones who have good Yelp reviews and can stain seemed to be booked out for at least 4 - 6 weeks.

  • 11 years ago

    Quick / Good / Cheap - pick any two!

  • 11 years ago

    I am happy to wait if they really know what they are doing. I talked to a couple of them yesterday and they did not seem to have much experience. One person gave me a 15K quote! However, she was pretty honest and said that she did not have any recent experience with these windows and was giving me her worst case quote. The search continues ....

  • 11 years ago

    Ask for a recommendation or two at your local Benjamin Moore store or a good quality hardware store if you have one you trust. Either would be better than Yelp in my opinion.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    Try a different Marvin dealer and see who they use

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks millworkman for your comment. I will call the paint store tomorrow.


    @Toddinmn: I called over 10 dealers to check. Most of them did not have any recommendations. A couple gave me some information, and I am following up.


    I also called Marvin directly. Was bounced around from department to department. Friendly, but did not come up with any concrete information :(

  • 11 years ago

    This is the extent of what Marvin will provide:

    http://www.marvin.com/support/care-and-maintenance?menu=painting-staining&;

  • 11 years ago

    I got a few more refinishers who seem to have some experience with wood window staining. However, I am getting very conflicting information about whether the windows should be stained before or after they are installed. One refinisher says he has worked with them for 16 years and he always does the staining after they are installed. His reasoning is that the windows will get dirty during install, the putty color will not match the holes, and the wood trim stain will not match the windows. On the other hand, another experienced refinisher says that it is much easier to stain the windows when they can be laid flat. This way the stain will not run. Also, it is easier to tape off the weather sealing when the windows are mobile etc.


    Both viewpoints make sense to me. Can you guys please weigh in with your thoughts/experiences?


    thanks


  • 11 years ago

    " Can you guys please weigh in with your thoughts/experiences?"

    I think you are making way too much of this. Assuming the staining / varnishing people both do good work - let them work the way they like best.

    I can see both points of view.

    Myself, I had the windows installed. Removed the window sashes, and laid them flat to varnish. I varnished the frames in place.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Left is without pre-conditioner. Middle is Marvin PREFINISHED window, Right is casing with stain over pre-conditioner.

  • PRO
    9 years ago

    Left is without pre-conditioner. Right is with pre-conditioner. In sunlight. More subtle than inside in the shade maybe, but you can see the blotchiness on the left.

  • 6 years ago

    @vishketan --


    Now that this is behind you, would you mind sharing your experience? We were thinking of getting 35 Marvin windows with bare pine interior so that we can stain them to match our decor. However, after reading this thread, we're not sure if that is still a good idea. The alternative would be to get them in black interior and work around the decor.


    Thanks!

  • 3 years ago

    @Mike Smith And 3 years later, I'm wondering what choice you made and whether it worked out for you?