I really like the last one. It has the colors you want plus some depth with the Dark brown. It looks so cozy!

Me too (although I think all 3 work, I'm more drawn to the last one). In fact, could you post a link to where you found it?

3 or 1 (Ikat fan here).

Probably #3 as long as it isn't too dark for the room. Agree it looks cozy. I like 2 but think I would tire of the circles. Quickly. And the first one works, but it isn't someting I would buy. You also don't need the added purple.

3 hits all the buttons for me. Lovely!

I need more information before I give an answer. I like #2 but I think the rug has the potential to dominate the room or be the focal point. I think rug #3 reads more solid than the other two and would allow for something else to be the focal point.

They all are pretty. Is the scale similar on all of them? Does that help with the decision?

Either one or three, would have to see it in the room. No. 2, there is just too many circles.

I think they all work well. I personally like the first one, but that is because I don't care for the the orangish tones in the third. And the second seems a tad too light. But it's splitting hairs.

Aren't you drawn to one? None would be a mistake.

I'm with Red. I like 1 and 3, but am a bit concerned with the orange tones in 3. What color are the walls and ceilings? Do you have wood work nearby that would look too orange with 3 in place?

I prefer #1.

FWIW, I think ikat (#1) and suzani-esque (#2) have peaked (though I have those styles and like them and would buy them myself). The last one is vaguely tribal i suppose and less trend-specific so may not look "out" as quickly?

#3. It's so rich and gorgeous.

I'm drawn to # 2 because it has a more contemporary vibe, but I agree it would dominate the room more than the other two. I guess it just depends on the look you're going for. The purple in the first rug could be another accent color used around the room. The third rug seems a little too dark and gloomy to me in comparison to the other two.

To answer your questions:

Here is my space...NOTE: I would NOT keep the painting if I chose rug #3. I have an espresso-colored recliner and entertainment center. No end tables yet, as i am limited on space. My coffee table is a muted gold frame (which I LOVE) and I have a white garden stool for inbetween the accent chairs, but that can be painted a different color. I do fear that #3 is too dark or too southwestern for my space. (Ignore kitchen color...will be changing).

They are all pretty, but I love #1.

@ sjhockeyfan325:

http://www.rugs-direct.com/Details/LoloiRugs-Xavier-XV07/112402/179287

:)

I like #3! I have a similiar color scheme in my living/dining room so I'm interested to see what you are doing. I like what you have done so far.

Here are all three used in real life."

A.

B:

C:

Hmmmm. # 3 was my only choice, but now seeing the rug as it would appear IRL, I'm not so sure.

I think rugs are really hard to choose on line because colors often aren't the quite same and color tones are so important to me!

I like #1 in the blue color better!! I would be concerned with the primarily light #1 being light and the beige/creams of the rug and carpet not complementing each other... your beige carpet looks like it might have either a grayish tone or even a pinkish/taupey tone and I would be concerned that such a light rug might not look the best... but, maybe it will... that is my favorite out of the 3.

I would choose #3 over #2... tho not sure I love the color combo... I would order rug samples if you can to be sure you like the colors in 'real life'...

I like them all for different reasons but the second one has the best pop to me. I like one because it's different and unexpected. I like three because it seems cozier and more to my style.

1.

1. If you have dogs 1. In the teal.

Number 1. The example you posted seems to be a very large rug and I think the scale in the smaller size you will likely have, will look better. I like #3, too. #2 is too much like your pillows and think would look theme-y. It also is such a strong pattern that it's all your eye would focus on. Love your coffee table!

in seeing the first samples I would have picked #3.

In seeing them on the floor,

#1 is a BIG print and I would skip

#2 is iffy, kind of a vertigo moment but that might not bother you

#3 from that angle would also be an issue, but might look better from a different angle as well

Since you move around a lot, I would pick between the second two the first one will have just too much mauve I think

Hmmm...#2 matches your pillows too much and the scale on the other two look like they will overwhelm your furniture/room.

Here is area rug #1 in the other color offered:

I first preferred 2 but after thinking and reading the comments, I am drawn to 1. i like that it does have another color besides the teal cream and brown. If you chose to embrace the red?purple?brown? for accents that is a nice option. I do think they all are great and would work, but I think I am liking the very first one best.

#3.

I first liked 3 best, but after looking at more photos I prefer 1. I don't care for 2, but I think it's more of a my preference/style thing that I think it won't look right.

I like 3 best. I'm not crazy about 2 in part because I keep seeing a face in it! In the last pic you posted, there are the beige eyes and nose and the dark mouth. Sorry! It's probably a kind of Rorschach, and I just flunked. Love your furniture.

Indygo: you had me cracking up over flunking Rorschach!

I have changed my mind #! for sure.

I like no. 1! I cant tell the difference between the two colors for no. 1. Maybe it's my monitor?

I really flunked! It's #1 that has the face! I really do love #3.

Whew! I thought I had a problem but you see it, too!

They're all nice, but frankly I would go for something with less visual impact. I love the artwork and I would want to make that the focal point. But I do like #3. I have a couch with a similar pattern on it, I get a lot of compliments on it.

Don't like 1 at all, number 2 is my preference but number 3 is also acceptable but it is dark. Number 2 would help lighten up the room.

Easy! Number 1

I like number one in the picture that has more blue in it. It looks nice with your other furniture.

#1

I prefer one for a few reasons. The unexpected purple seems cheerful to me. The purple looks good with the wall color. The other two just seem so bold for your room. I like number one in the second color also but you are right about the blues not matching. That would not be good.