Software
Houzz Logo Print
lisamann

best varieties for container citrus?

11 years ago

I'd love to have a dwarf lemon, lime, and orange. What are your favorite (edible) dwarf varieties?

Comments (54)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Even "dwarf" citrus are not dwarf anymore. There are only 2 true dwarf rootstocks. Flying dragon which isn't really used anymore due to it liking to over grow the scion and us897 a flying g dragon hybrid that's only availabile in Florida as far as I know.

    people like four winds advertise "true dwarf" but really sell semi dwarf trees. They get away with it because semi dwarfs in containers act like dwarfs.


    i have 2 trees on us897 from briteleaf citrus.

  • 11 years ago

    I love my Satsumas!

  • 11 years ago

    Any indoor lighting for overwintering citrus is important but your real issue is where on the latitude line your at. I'm in Minnesota and so consequently, the only citrus that are suited for 45 NORTH are those cultivars that don't require more heat than our summers can provide. If your intention is to pollinate any flowers whether it's indoors or outside and you want to develop fruit so that it is mature and you can eat it and it does taste the way it should, make sure your Citrus are compatible with the summer heat that you can expect. A lot of Citrus it seems won't be able to develop in the way that it should if they are in climates that don't produce enough heat for them., the sugars need a lot of heat to go through some type of a acidification process, whereby the sugars convert the way they are supposed to. The process which I'm not too familiar with at this point, is dependent upon a be certain degree of heat that Minnesota would never be able to supply. Otherwise I can't think of another condition that must be met besides the heat. You can tweek the soil and you can tweak the lighting to just merely get your Citrus through the winter months or to have scorching growth rates.

  • 11 years ago

    Karlos you make a good point. I am also a northern grower and am already addicted to citrus am already mentally shopping for next summer's trees.

    Which varieties should I stay away from because of your above point? We do get hot temps but not for prolonged periods.

  • 11 years ago

    Trovita orange will work wonders in cool climates

  • 11 years ago

    Trovita is good. OroBlanco is one of a very few grapefruit that fruit can be fully developed to taste without more heat than Minnesota provides. Most of the Mandarins can be grown to fully bear fruit without the excessive heat a lot of Citrus require. Wash navel is appropriate for northern climates. A lot of the limes and lemons in general. I'm not fully understanding that chemical process whereby sugar undergoes chemical reactions that often depend on high temps to even occur. Plant science is not my strength in horticulture. There are a lot of varieties that are suitable to grow in the north. In pots of course. I believe more citrus cultivars than not won't produce fruit correctly where I live. Outr summers do vary as for average in temp.. One summer out of forty might have that requisite heat for the heat loving citrus to produce. The last summer we had in that category was 1988.

  • 11 years ago

    Thanks guys, now to find these types in Canada will be the challenge.

  • 11 years ago

    I'll order next in may from four winds. Have them fly it to you.

  • 11 years ago

    It doesn't look like four winds will ship to Canada. According to the website they say they cannot ship to other countries. Tropic to Tropics is from BC and has a good selection, I have also ordered from Mori Essex in Ont. and another one is Flora Exotica ( I haven't ordered from them yet).

  • 11 years ago

    Harris Citrus and there is another that pip knows about well worth looking at

  • 11 years ago

    Very few nurseries find it cost effective to ship to other countries. Inspections and all.

  • 11 years ago

    I doubt anyone ships internationally, probably due to international quarantine.

  • 11 years ago

    Actually I have had plants shipped from the USA. As long as the phytosanitary certificates are with the order there is no quarantine.

    The costs are on the buyer not the company but I imagine the logistics of getting the inspector to come and issue these may not be worth it. Some companies will ship without the certificate and then it is a "crap shoot" whether you get your pant in live condition after the delays, or at all.

    Personally, I would not place an order with a company that did not issue a phyto. certificate, and I do not mind paying for one. I too would like to know my plant was disease free before entering the country.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Nice to know


    pretty sure photo sanitary is done by the state of origin not destination.

  • 11 years ago

    You should contact Canada's give and see what you need for paperwork.

  • 11 years ago

    I have ordered from tropic to tropic and flora exotica and have been impressed with them, all the plants arrived in excellent condition, packed really well, and are all thriving. I'm excited about the other one you suggested ubro. The Canadian vendors seem light on orange varieties though but I will keep looking.

    I would definitely pay for a certificate to get a cool variety. So many citrus to buy so little time! I'll have to dig a bit more.

    Where is zone 2a? I didn't think it got worse than my zone!

    Thanks all!

  • 11 years ago

    Pip you are right the state of origin has to issue the certificate.

    hobby artisan, :) I am in north central Saskatchewan, and some winters I think we are actually a zone 1-- at least that is what it feels like.I have included a link to the Canadian food inspection site. I have never used it to import plants, but apparently it can be done, and some say it is not much of a problem. Canadian Food Inspection agency. It might take some time to figure out where to go on this site, I have only used it for patent information.

  • 11 years ago

    If you figure out the legal aspect I can help with getting from suppliers that don't ship internationally.


    i want some stuff from Canada that I can't get shipped international either. We can start small, develop trust, and help each other.

  • 11 years ago

    Ubro Wow what a coincidence, I'm in Saskatoon, hello! We certainly have the sun for citrus right? What trees do you have? What's your set up?

    Pip I'm curious what you would be interested in from up from here? Sure I would be open looking into assisting each other with some reshipping, I'll have to wait for warmer weather here now but what are you after?

  • 11 years ago

    Bilberry, low bush blueberry.

  • 11 years ago

    So summer stuff too then, sure that would be fine. I know of those wild though are they sold commercially? Well it's nice to know I have an option, thank you!

  • 11 years ago

    Not to discourage any of you; but let me tell you my experience. The first 500 Meyer lemon trees I brought from California to Guatemala went like this:..The Minister of Agriculture of Guatemala will not issue an import license for live plants without a USDA phytosanitation inspection; but the USDA will not do a phytosanitation inspection without an import license!!! And it got worse from there. Luckily I had some friends in high places (US and Guate) who helped me; but in general moving live plants (legally) from one country to another is a nightmare. If you are an established importer/exporter it gets easier; but someone still has to suffer the pain in the beginning.

  • 11 years ago

    Phyrosanitary certificates should be able to be gotten from the state of origin. They need them just to ship interstate.

  • 11 years ago

    My govt has a new automated import reference database online I just checked, it says citrus imported to my province for home growing and propagation is allowed with a phyto cert, both bare root and with dirt. You have to select state of origin and province of destination, so there may be more restrictions for provinces where citrus actually grow, like BC.

    Fun! John I am sure it is infinitely more complicated for you commercially, and because it's warm climate to warm climate. More risk.

  • 11 years ago

    Pip,


    "Phyrosanitary certificates should be able to be gotten from the state of origin". The operative word here is SHOULD... in the real world, that is often a fantasy... unless you have some friends in high places.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    No. In order to ship interstate they need them.

    ALL of my 20 trees had them.

    four winds, briteleaf, And Harris ALL have them. they are required to be on the box and in plain sight.

    Not sure why you had a problem. Maybe you got yours before intrastate quarrentine was the norm? What year did you get yours shipped?

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Pip by low bush blue berry I assume you mean the wild ones we have up here? I haven't seen any place that sells them as a mature plant, but I do know Gardens North sells two varieties of the seed and they ship internationally. How long it takes from seed to mature plant is something I don't know.

    hobbyartisan, I am north of you near Christopher Lake and yes we have tons of sun for citrus. I just started into citrus and have a meyers lemon and a cocktail grapefruit, which buy the way is starting to bloom again. I just found a few new citrus sources for Canada but the weather is cold so I have to wait till spring and content myself with dreams of an orange tree.

    I have a greenhouse that is hooked up to the outdoor wood boiler we use for the house. We start the greenhouse in March so the trees will get an early start, in the summer they definitely get a lot of heat. In the winter I keep them in a south window with two grow lights I turn on when the sun goes down, and early in the morning before it rises. They seem to be doing very well, but we have not hit January yet.

  • 11 years ago

    Oro Blanco Grapefruit, Dwarf Oranges & Lemons are sold all the time to

  • 11 years ago

    Ubro Well howdy neighbor, what a coincidence! We have been talking about a greenhouse with wood fire attached, how often do you have to stoke it to keep an even temperature?

    Container grapefruit would be amazing! I always wonder about pummelos can they actually be grown in containers successfully?

  • 11 years ago

    hobby artisan, howdy back. The greenhouse is a very small commercial one, they are actually more affordable than the hobby greenhouses. The minute they call them hobby the price goes up. I am in love with it, we got double poly with air inflation and roll up sides to vent it in the summer. I find the heat kills more plants than the cold, cold is controllable, heat is harder to manage.

    We put a used radiator in it and mounted a fan behind to circulate the heat. Usually we close it down for the winter and wrap the radiator in a box with insulation just to keep it from losing too much heat. That said, I have four tomato plants in the ground in it and they are still growing, but as I have no supplemental light they do not produce fruit any more.

    We usually start it up in late March when the sun has some strength. As far as how much wood, that I don't know as the water circulates to the house and the line to the greenhouse is just an extension of that.

    Are you talking a wood stove, or a boiler??

  • 11 years ago

    Oh a boiler right that makes sense. We have an acreage so would love a better greenhouse set up, I just have 2 small hobby ones (yes a rip off), 2 tents and a grow room but the power is a big problem, a boiler would be much more efficient.

    Thanks great ideas for me to consider. The thing I am most afraid of is having to erect a commercial greenhouse. The small ones were trying enough! I'm surprised my relationship survived!

  • 11 years ago

    The boiler is awesome, another bonus with it was that it is about 100 feet from the house, the line is situated so that I built a raised bed over it. The water lines are well insulated, but some heat still escapes and I can grow plants that would not be root hardy in our area, in the raised bed. The choice of plants to grow has to be something that dies back to the ground as the cold winter air would kill the tops. I seem to be able to push our zone one or two higher than it is.

    I tried putting bulbs in an mulching the whole bed, a definite mistake as the poor things had warm soil and grew up to poke their heads out in late Feb. only to reach the cold air and freeze. A better idea was a low hoop structure, attached to the board sides, and frost cloth then plastic. Not warm enough for Feb. but definitely warm enough for earlier spring transplants.

  • 11 years ago

    Grapefruit-Sweetie (Oro Blanco)

    Oranges-I guess Satsumas

    Lemon-I think Meyer can be dwarfed

    Lime-Dwarf Key Lime

  • 11 years ago

    Why not kaffir lime? The leaves are edible and the fruit is good for cooking. Mine does fine on flying dragon roots and it's a manageable dwarf that doesn't have crazy heat requirements.

  • 11 years ago

    oh Yeah

  • 11 years ago

    Everything's four winds sells is dwarf. Briteleaf have some dwarfs. Harris has dwarf hirado buntan and I mean real dwarf, mine came on flying dragon.

  • 11 years ago

    O.p. You would be better off not considering what is better as a dwarf as all dwarf still give the same fruit as the full size version.


    your biggest concern is what varieties do well in your region. And even more importantly what do you like?

  • 11 years ago

    That lemonade tree you are always talking about sounds adorable.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Four winds should have some in spring. Find out what paperwork you need and if you can get sent fruit. I haven't had any but I'm fascinated and excited by it and am buying some fruit in December. I'll send you one if its legal.


    to me it's the rarest and most unique of all citrus, I mean can you name another lemon you can eat out of hand that isn't extremely sour or bland?

  • 11 years ago

    I know I researched it a bit after you guys were talking about it- sounds amazing! I'm always very interested in rarities! I would be very interested in working out a trade for something you are interested in. Thanks I will look into it!

    Also check this out a breeder right in my city has been working on this low light high production lemon. I'm desperate for one or a couple! I have the guy's phone number but have been too nervous to call and look like a stalker!

    http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/saskatoon/saskatoon-couple-breed-lemon-trees-for-prairie-windowsills-1.2776453

  • 11 years ago

    @ Pip- Pomona sweet lemon, I have one in my yard, it's similar to a millsweet.

    Evan

  • 11 years ago

    Try it. He might not want you to get it yet because he's patenting it but at the same time he might want to have others enjoy it. It looks weird with that protusion but that just makes it more unique.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I always thought those two were supposed to be sub par in one way or another. Isn't millsweet a lime?


    is that incorrect? Are they very good lemons that you can eat like an orange?

  • 11 years ago

    Evan Your Pomona sweet lemon is hardy to 16F. That beats the Meyer for hardiness

  • 11 years ago

    Yes they're sweet and you can eat them like an orange. I've never had a millsweet only read about them. The cvc in riverside has them categorized as a lime but it looks more like a lemon. They're supposed to be hardy to 16f like steve said but I would think that's only for a very short period of time.

    Evan

  • 11 years ago

    Kumquat is one of the smallest citrus tree.....and it's even cold-hardy !!! I think it's a great plant to be kept in pot....one of the best choice :)

  • 11 years ago

    Stick with Meiwa, Fukushou, or sunquat for out of hand eating

  • 11 years ago

    I second kumquat. They are small, hardy, ornamental, and less common. I haven't tasted a Fukushu yet, so it's great to see Steve's recommendation. Meiwa taste fantastic, but it's seedy. The first photo is Fukushu planted 8 months ago. Both Meiwa are in ground as shown in the second and third. In Southern California we have it easy, my hat's off to you northern growers.

  • 11 years ago

    Kumquat is so different though that it's almost hard to recommend unless the person plans on having many trees. What if they only have the one and don't like it? I'd hate to be responsible for someone growing a plant for years and being mad about it being a waste.



  • 11 years ago

    When I started citrus 3.75 years ago I came to the conclusion that the Meiwa kumquat was the only citrus that I was interested in and started seeds. Now that I have heard of sweet lemons and Fukushu kumquats I have decided that I want sweet-lemon and Fukushu-kumquat trees as well as th Meiwa. I did inherit 2 Meyer lemon trees. We will see what come from them