Software
Houzz Logo Print
lone_elm_z6

Grafted Hickory vs Seedling

11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago

My seedling shagbark pathetically limped through its first season. I know patience is required with the hickories and I will leave it alone; good chance I will have to replace it though in a year or two the way it looked. Does grafted stock have a taproot -- what is used as rootstock, non taproot type? And does a grafted take better than a Seedling usually. I am assuming larger sizes are available with graft if it is non taproot type.

Comments (4)

  • 11 years ago

    is it a named variety ... are there named varieties ...


    no grower would spend the cost.. to graft a species tree ... they would simply grow out the nuts ...


    it would seem a very cursory review of how and why plants are grafted ... thru google.. would get you up to speed on the basic issues.. so you could get some more specific info here ... else .. we would need to write a treatise to get where you might want to be ...


    try the third link here: https://www.google.com/search?q=why+are+plants+grafted&ie=utf-8&oe=utf-8


    you really dont tell us anything about your tree.. other than you planted it this year ... [like how big it is.. how you planted it.. etc] ..... frankly.. i dont expect much beyond it living thru the first season and winter ... what more were you expecting... it did almost ALL of its work underground growing roots .. which can take 2 to 3 years.. before it is fully established ...


    the biggest problem with tree newbs.... is what i call.. the need for instant gratification ... when you are dealing with a plant.. that can live a hundred years ... having much of any expectation for the first 5 years of its life.. might be a bit much ...


    just keep it properly watered.. mulched.. and realize it is growing roots.. to store the energy ... to start growing like a tree


    if it lives... starting over in 2 or 3 years... simply puts you back at step one ...


    relax.. relish that it is alive ....


    ken


    ps: there is a current post arguing about the fact.. that the tap root is just another root ... such should not really even be in your head ... in your learning process... IMHO .. it really has no relevance... to what you need to learn ...



  • 11 years ago

    A seedling with a taproot cut off and planted will form a new taproot.

    On the other hand if a person is planting a lot of trees and doesn't have time/access to water these seedlings, a direct sown seed will produce a taproot from the get-go and the chances of survival are tenfold.

    As for grafted trees or for that matter a seedling being sold, it really all depends upon the grower. Some growers may grow their seedlings in tall pots designed to keep a taproot while others may grow in shorter containers and/or "root-making" containers that are designed to produce a very fibrous root-system.

    Since your Shag seedling is doing fine, you will simply need to hold on/have patience. There is no fast way to grow a Shagbark other than to plant a larger tree in the 4-5+ feet tall range wherein the slow years have already passed. And even when a larger seedling in that range is planted there will be a 3-5 year acclimating time for the roots to grab in until the full-growing-potential is reached.

    Dax

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    https://www.grimonut.com/index.php?p=Products&category=hickory-hican

    What is meant by graft here? I thought this would be a graft like in fruit tree production. My original question is a little muddled. What is meant by grafted tree on the Grimo site is what I'm interested in -- how it is practically different.

    Whoops found the answer. Top of a seedling is cut off and a cut from a selected specimen is grafted on. Ok.

  • 11 years ago

    lone elm,

    We graft nut trees, like hickories, for the same reason that most fruit trees are grafted. It's a form of cloning - albeit one that's been practiced for thousands of years. A grafted specimen will produce nuts/fruits identical to that of the 'named' selection it was propagated from... nuts/fruits from seedling trees will be a genetic crapshoot - some may be better/worse/bigger/smaller than that of the tree producing the nut or fruit they were grown from. And... since the scion grafted onto the rootstock is usually taken from a tree that has already grown through its juvenile phase... time to fruiting/bearing will usually be cut in half.... so... instead of waiting 20 years or more for that hickory seedling to reach bearing age, a grafted specimen may begin producing nuts in 10 or less.