Software
Houzz Logo Print
cindy_reynolds1676995

Tile/Hardwood in kitchen

11 years ago

I currently have about 350 square feet of ceramic tile in the kitchen, dining room, powder room and the hallway leading into kitchen from the garage. Then my living room has carpet. This is an open floor plan. I would love to remove all of this (carpet and tile) and replace it with hardwood, but #1, I am terrified of using wood in the kitchen. #2, There is nothing structurally wrong with the tile and I actually feel guilty tearing out something that there isn't anything wrong with (other than being ugly). I have attached a picture of the kitchen and eating area looking from the living room and a picture of the wood I think would look nice. Opinions, advice? Thanks for your help :)

Comments (10)

  • 11 years ago

    I suggest laminate flooring / floating floor instead of the hard wood floor..

    Just rip the carpet and add floating floor i think it is cheaper and much less work.

    and if some of the panels got damaged u can replace it(i think)


    I say go for it i am going to do the same but i need to level up the floor because some idiot made the kitchen floor slop to the living :) like seriously!

    Cindy Holcomb thanked Roaa Q
  • 11 years ago

    Where are the other rooms in relation to the kitchen and the hall to the garage? I think your tile looks fine and I would be inclined to keep it in the kitchen and that hallway leading to the garage (but I live in WI, where we drag in all sorts of wet and dirty stuff when coming in from the garage). You could put the hardwood in the dining and living rooms....not sure about the powder room. I have had a bad experience with discolored hardwood floors in a powder room around the toilet base due to urine.


    That said, I have a wood floor in my kitchen and share the same fears as you. If my dishwasher or refrigerator ice system decides to take a dump someday, I will be very unhappy. We did go with an engineered wood, at the recommendation of several flooring companies, as this type of wood floor is supposed to be more stable and better for high moisture areas (like kitchens and baths). I also have had reassurance from friends who had plumbing disasters and wood floors who said the floors did eventually shrink back down and be ok.


  • 10 years ago

    Roaa Q, how will you level the floor? We have a crowned joist in our kitchen causing a noticeable (1/4") slope. When a flooring guy came out to measure for hardwood he said they'd just fill the dip with cardboard. Seriously?

  • 10 years ago

    If there is a noticeable hump in the floor, it should be belt sanded down to flat

  • 10 years ago

    I had tile in one kitchen and hated it, it was hard on the feet and everything broke when dropped, usually into 10 million pieces. I currently have vinyl which I've been really happy with -- it has a lovely pattern, but newer faux stone or faux wood vinyl is not for me. I've had hardwood in my kitchen before, and loved it. I had thin rugs in front of the range and sink, spot cleaned spills, and damp mopped when needed. No problems in 9 years. We did have an icemaker, but we were careful to use a copper T connector and copper water line to avoid problems. Based on that experience, I just installed hardwood in a new home. Again, a copper water line and T-connection to the waterline for the fridge. We also installed a shutoff in the basement for when we are away. Myself, I'd choose good quality vinyl or hardwood every time.

    Cindy Holcomb thanked mabeldingeldine
  • 10 years ago

    Water leak will destroy hardwood -- the laminates too (boy do I know this!). Had a pinhole leak in the water feed to the fridge and the entire kitchen's laminate floor warped over the course of one weekend. Tile or vinyl is better.

  • 10 years ago

    janetl57 i have tile so i will rip it out and chip the floor down, then level the 5cm slope with self levelling cement or something and then lay the laminate/wood flooring. The drainage is on top of the slope lool, now imagine that we have to live in the house while they work god be with us.

  • 10 years ago

    janetl57 or i'll pour the self levelling cement down on top of the tile ,but than i will lose a couple of cm. this is the easy way if you don't mind go ahead.

  • 10 years ago

    Good luck and thanks. I hope the leveling compound will work in our case, too.