Software
Houzz Logo Print
eric426

1100 Sq Ft Addition

11 years ago

Hi there!

We just had an offer accepted in the competitive SF Mid Peninsula market (Millbrae to San Carlos). We love the commute, neighborhood, school districts, and house, but because it’s only a 2bed/1bath we recognize it won’t be large enough once we have kids.

Because of that we’re strongly considering a 1000 square foot home addition in the next 2 years (before we start trying to have kids). Reading a bit online, I haven’t been able to find many posts about an addition this large, so I wanted to ask here about ballpark costs and whether or not this is a good idea.

Some important facts:

  1. We have 6 more days left before we have to waive our inspection contingency.
  2. The house is a 2:1 with just under 1000 square feet.
  3. The house is the cheapest on the block (in the bottom 15%), according to zillow and our agent. Of the ~30 other homes on the block, the most expensive homes are about $400K more than our offer and median is about $200K over our offer.
  4. We’ve verified with the city that our lot permitting allows for up to 2100 sqft
  5. Our agent took a look at the house and says our nextdoor neighbor originally was a 2:1 or 3:2 and expanded to a 4:2.5, 2000-2300 sqft. The permits on the city website say this expansion was in the last 5 years. Their lot is identical to ours and we’re hoping the fact they’ve been through the public hearing process already will set a precedent that will make it easier for us to go through it.
  6. The expansion we have in mind is:
  7. Add 1100 sqft, 2 beds, 1.5 baths, and 1 additional parking spot in the garage to create a 4 bed, 2.5 bath, 2-car garage, 2100sqft home.
  8. Expansion will be on top of their garage to make it a two-level home, and then pushing back 10 feet into our backyard as well.
  9. This expansion is very similar to our neighbor’s expansion.
  10. If we are able to build up over the garage, we will get a view over the house across the street into a nice valley. We’re on a hill elevated above them already, so the extra story would allow a mostly unobstructed view over their house.
  11. My parents live in the area so it would be reasonably easy to relocate to their house for 3-6 months during construction.
  12. We trust our agent: Although he has a vested interest in selling us the home, he has been very honest so far and helped us negotiate hard to lower the price of the offer even though he knew we were willing to pay more.


Ok so here are my key questions, and thank you so much in advance for sharing your knowledge:

  1. Given we live in an expensive mid-peninsula neighborhood, what would you expect the ballpark cost per square foot for this significant addition? This would include working with an architect, engineer, and the actual builder.
  2. Our agent says ballpark would be $200K, or $100/sqft. This seems low to me.
  3. Can we take advantage of our flexibility on timing to get a lower price? We have a roughly 2 year window in which we’re mostly indifferent to when the addition happens.
  4. Does the scale of this home addition create any special complications/issues that I should think about? I’ve googled “things to consider when planning a home addition” but these articles mostly apply to small ~200sqft additions.


Thank you!Eric

Comments (23)

  • 11 years ago

    "Our agent says ballpark would be $200K, or $100/sqft. This seems low to me."

    $100 is low but $200k is closer to $200 sq/ft and sound's possible if you keep it simple.

    eric426 thanked klem1
  • 11 years ago

    200k would be low for that area. Double that. Easily.

    eric426 thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    I would not consider 2 year window to have great flexibility with timing. We did something similar in the Boston area and it took a full 11 months from groundbreaking to when we could use the addition. (still working on the punch list) This doesn't count the weeks it working with the Architect and getting city approval, which moved quickly in our case.

    We waved to deadlines as they sped by and the savings from our completion clauses were nice, but I would have preferred my house back.

    I agree on doubling the 200k - perhaps more depending upon your finishes.

    But given all this, I would do it again in a heartbeat! Make your house functional for you -- good luck and keep us posted.

    eric426 thanked mfb237
  • 11 years ago

    $200 a square remodeling costs in that location would be for garage. New construction is $350-$400. Remodeling is 1.5-3x the cost of new construction.

    eric426 thanked User
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks for the replies!

    chisue - the kitchen was recently renovated by the previous owners, so we're really happy with it. The current bathroom would need to get redone and we might need to change some of the existing walls. This is a good point though and we'll definitely need to consider it.

  • 11 years ago

    More than double that in my podunk east bay town which is cheaper, and we were not building UP which will likely be more.


    Also check the zoning and any HOA--you might not even be permitted to build up.


    It's worth doing, but don't expect it to be cheap! :)

    eric426 thanked Fori
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Fori - I'm wondering how much it makes sense to even think of cost on a per-square-foot basis. There's a huge difference between the cost per square foot of the kitchen and the garage, of building up vs out and so on.

    Would it make more sense to just look at the total cost? I've heard numbers from $200-400K all in. Does that range sound reasonable?

  • 11 years ago

    Like Fori, I'm in a cheaper East Bay burb than mid-Peninsula. We're adding 1300 sq ft, mostly in a second story because setback limitations and building/lot ratio requirements wouldn't allow us to stay on one level and add enough space to justify the cost. Frankly, $400K sounds too low for what you're looking to do. I'd figure $600K, and hope like heck the trades aren't so busy two years from now. Costs have gone up considerably in the seven months since we went to contract.

    Building up isn't necessarily hugely more expensive, but if you need a new foundation to support a second story, it's not insignificant. In our case, we could have added 300 sq feet on one level for $150K less than adding the new foundation and 1,000 sq feet on a second floor. For us, having a home with the flexibility to accommodate a large extended family makes the cost worth it.

    If you love the neighborhood you're looking at, know it's where you want to raise your family, you might end up spending more to remodel the house than seems reasonable to folks in Texas or Arizona. If you don't know that yet, maybe think about living there a year or two before you decide on the addition. You never know. You could have mean neighbors who hate kids or pets, or crazy neighbors who surround their homes with old bleach bottles filled with water to deter skunks and evil spirits. Some weirdness is charming, some isn't. All in all, Bay Area housing costs are nuts. Assume it's going to cost way more than it should. If we live here, we have to learn to accept that--and do all the research so we aren't surprised.

    eric426 thanked algeasea
  • 11 years ago

    This house seems ideal for you as a couple -- and as a couple with one young child. It will be ideal for future couples *as it is*.

    There are several options for later. You could move. You could add on. You could tear down and build new. We did the latter, leaving a garage and fireplace to qualify as 'remodeling'. We did this after listening to an appraiser friend. His advice was to consider the value of a remodeled house with some additions v. what we'd have if we built all new. (There is high land value here. Also important, our home is still one of the smaller houses in the neighborhood.)

    I'd be surprised if a buyer with a family that requires four bedrooms would want a kitchen sized for a two-bedroom house. There would be better houses for them -- and for you.

    eric426 thanked chisue
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thanks AlgeaSea & Chisue - both very helpful comments. This is giving me second thoughts on the house. At a minimum we will rethink buying more points on the mortgage!

    If anyone else has experience doing a 2nd-story ~1000sqft addition in the bay area I would love to hear about it!

  • 11 years ago

    Our friends (same county as you) considered something similar to what you are planning, but after talking with a number of professionals are now going to do a teardown/new build.

    Based on what I have seen recently, I think your agent's guesses on numbers are very low, but he/she at least has more information about your specific situation than we do. Why not get some contractor guesstimates?

    Congratulations on getting an offer accepted with a contingency. Good luck!

    eric426 thanked Oaktown
  • 11 years ago

    I don't know how old the original home is - but it sounds like a tear down.

    eric426 thanked geoffrey_b
  • 11 years ago
    Yes a tear down is definitely an option. The house was built in the early fifties.
  • 11 years ago

    Ok one thing I forgot to add was that our inspector (a contractor) said a $250K budget would be realistic for the 1100 sqft, 2nd story addition I've described. He said we could find architects/GCs that could design to that budget.

    I suppose this inspector is the most educated person as he actually crawled through the crawlspace, stood on the roof and so on. Theoretically he should have no conflict of interest since we pay him a flat rate regardless of whether we buy the house. That said he was a referral from our agent.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Is the inspector a contractor who does major remodels/new construction? $250K for construction costs only, and not soft costs (design, engineering, permitting)? I think there are some Bay Area pros on the board, hopefully one of them will weigh in for you.

    Here is a discussion from redfin; a few years old.

    Another

    And another

    eric426 thanked Oaktown
  • 11 years ago

    I spoke with the city permitting office and they said generally additions run $200-400sqft. They also pointed me to a recently permitted 2nd story addition that ran 830sqft. The "Fairmarket value of the services and materials" was $300K. I'm not sure if the owners have an incentive to spin this number higher or lower, but this would imply a cost of $361/sqft.

  • 11 years ago

    I'm in your area and I have been quoted $300-$350 per sq foot for my addition/remodel. I would also budget $10K for soft fees (design, permit, title 24, etc). Construction costs here (like home prices) have gone up quite a bit in the last few years. They used to say that if you were flexible and willing to remodel in the winter that labor would be slightly less but I do not believe that's true anymore. In hindsight I wish we had taken a loan out and done our remodel 5 years ago when we initially considered it. Instead we saved the money so we wouldn't have to go so far into debt and now the cost is significantly higher. We could have been enjoying our house!

    1100 sq feet seems like a lot for 2 bedrooms and a bath? Are you expanding other areas?

    Sounds like a good block and lot for expansion. Good luck!

    eric426 thanked dominos
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Dominos. How many sqft was your addition? Also did it cover a second story addition?

  • 11 years ago

    One other thing I should add is the addition we have in mind might actually be considered 1.5 story. We would only be building on top of the garage, which is already have a story below the main part of the house. So the elevated section of the house would only 1.5 from ground, and the rest of the house would be at ground level. Hopefully this reduces the amount of stress on the foundation!

  • 11 years ago

    Our friends in the Bay Area loved their smallish house built in the fifties..as the kids became older they wanted to add a two-story addition..were told will take a year (with them to moving somewhere else during the construction time) and -I forgot a ballpark price-but a lot? They rented their place and bought a new house, three times as bigger(I won't bore you with the prices 'cause they're mind-boggling). Bottom line-forget 3-6 months, it's going to be minimum twice as long..and multiply your budget by 2 or 3. It's not going to be 200 K..and don't forget materials, plans, inspections, etc. We're currently adding 200 (two hundred) sq f (also California, but Orange County), but we had to update the whole house(found asbestos-decided on abatement=gut job)..we already blew our budget a long time ago, and it's been a year since we bought the house, 10 months since we chose contractor, 6 months since the plans were approved and construction started-and we're only past 3 inspections, 2 or 3 more to come..if we only knew we'd just tear the place down and build a new house, or, and would be wiser, buy (much) more expensive house, because in the end that's what we'll pay, and nothing and nobody will bring this year from our lives back. But if you look at it as an experience-then yes, you'll definitely experience a lot)))

  • 11 years ago

    P.S. don't listen to your agent, or at least not when it comes to construction..he might be the nicest person in the world, and a great realtor, but he's not a pro in construction. Our agent also said optimistically "Oh this idea of addition of yours is so great, so smart! It will probably cost you around X!" No, it doesn't. It costs you X multiple 4...

    If you have an option of bringing a trusted contractor to the site before buying, then you get an idea. An approximate one.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    What is the land value? I see *teardown* for sure. There is nothing good to be said for 1950's construction, and you'd have a half/half house with all new mechanicals. This gets into the realm of when to repair your old car and when to buy new -- only on a much larger scale, with much greater inconvenience and more 'surprises'.

    You could live in peace until you *need* more house, then sell and move -- or do your teardown then. I would NOT double the size of this house.

    Have you been a homeowner before this?