Software
Houzz Logo Print
jremold

Are there any keen eyes willing to take a look at these plans?

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

I've lurked here for years and I'm glad to finally have something to post about. A project that is long overdue is finally going to happen. Now I'm really hoping for some input on a big project.

We own a duplex. We live in a 2 bedroom unit in the back and we rent out a 1-bedroom apartment in front. We don't have nearly enough space for our family of 4 so we are working on plans to increase our space and reduce the size of the rental apartment to a small studio. We cannot make any changes to floor area. All changes have to occur within the existing envelope.

This picture shows approximately what we have now:

Two garages are shown on the left, the rental apt is in the middle, and our apartment (back unit) is on the right. There's a backyard to the right of what's shown that we use a lot.

We've worked out a concept ourselves and now hired an architect. He's going to see what improvements he can make to the concept and then develop full plans.
This picture shows our idea:


Major changes are:

  • bedroom, hall, and bath currently belonging to the rental unit become our new master suite accessed from our living room
  • Wider living room - 12" taken from adjacent bedroom with built in shelving and TV, another 12-18" taken from kitchen - so that access to the new bedroom doesn't feel too tight.
  • getting rid of the L shaped coat closet and using the space to make a laundry room off the kitchen.
  • floor to ceiling armoire instead of the coat closet.

There are some details not shown that we are considering like bay windows (that won't count as floor area here), adding a gas fireplace along the bottom wall of the living room (we happen to have a gas line there from an old wall furnace that's coming out), and using compact appliances in the rental studio. But this floor plan gives a general idea of the layout we're imagining.

Soon we'll be meeting with the architect to hear his ideas and talk though our ideas. I thought this would be a great time to ask this community if anyone has input. Looking at this, can you see anything you think we'll regret doing? (or not doing). Do you see anything we've overlooked that might work within the current footprint?

Thanks in advance for any help.

Comments (2)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    In the rental apartment I would try to avoid locating the bedroom and bathroom doors off of the kitchen. If the plumbing is not restricted to where it is shown, consider putting the new tenant bathroom in the right side of the "Other Room" and opening the kitchen up to the living space by moving the refrigerator to the outside wall and removing the wall between the kitchen and the living room creating a peninsula counter and better access to the bedroom. A better proportioned bedroom with adequate closet space could be created from the old one and the remaining portion of the Other Room. That should create a much better apartment for minimal additional cost.

    As for providing an architect with a concept drawing, in my experience initial concept design is what architects do best and it is therefore wise to begin the design process with a collaborative discussion rather than reviewing your concept design; its a distraction to a professional design process.

    The architect's first task after an initial discussion of your programatic needs and wants will be to measure and draw the existing conditions as accurately as possible; inches count in a renovation. Then he/she would probably present you with 2 or 3 alternative schemes that would be discussed and modified in an extensive collaborative design meeting meeting in the space until one or two good schemes are found to be worthy of drawing accurately.

    jremold thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for your input.

    I should clarify. My software didn't let me label the rooms as I wanted. There is no "other room". This is actually a garage that past tenants have converted to illegal extra living space. We will need to revert to the legally required garage with this project. So the rental unit is really just a studio and bathroom will have to be off the living/sleeping room or off the kitchen. We could probably reconfigure it though so it is off the living/sleeping room instead of off the kitchen. Both are bad, I can't decide which is worse.

    If we make the kitchen open to the main room in the studio, we can't have the access door to the garage anymore (sleeping can't link to garage). This might be a worthwhile compromise since an open kitchen might be nicer. Not sure though as the garage also gives access to a side garden and garbage.