Software
Houzz Logo Print
jolene_klassen

Architect's custom plans for us - Need your input

11 years ago

My original post is here,


previous house plan

showing the plan that we spent 6 months getting to. Then I realized that the rear garage was not going to work for us, and a side entry garage/L-shaped house is seeming to be the best option.


We are on an acreage, three young kids. Master bedroom and kids rooms will be upstairs. I do not want too much open concept. I know that to give a proper review you would prefer more info such as a site plan, and exterior drawings but I don't have those at this point. I'm just needing some feedback to see if this floorplan has major flaws.


Inspiration for the exterior will come from this photo:

Hampton Hall - Farnsleigh · More Info


Here is my drawing of the main floor. It's around 1700 sq feet, each square is 1'. The foundation has a lot of jogs, my architect seems to have a penchant for them, but I'm trusting he has a vision for the exterior! Also I should note that I changed the office, bath, laundry and mud room from what he sent us.



Comments (6)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Eh, I'd call it just okay:

    I don't like the jutting-forward garage; it seems to overwhelm the exterior, even covering a portion of the front. With acreage, why build something that seems designed for a small city lot?

    The jigs and jogs do create nice rooms with lovely windows -- but they're going to be very expensive. The bump-outs are about as extreme as we ever see on this site: Note that the sides of the house don't "match up", meaning these aren't just bump-outs ... again, this will be expensive to build.

    On the positive side, you've created a house that is open ... yet not TOO open.

    So much space is devoted to hallways. Again, this is raising your price without increasing your actual live-ability.

    You don't want your pantry door to swing in like this: It'll block some of your shelves, meaning that you'd have to enter the pantry and closet the door to reach those shelves.

    With no bedrooms downstairs, do you need a shower in the bathroom? I know, people throw around the idea of "What if someone can't manage the stairs?" pretty often, but in this case you don't have a room downstairs that could be a bedroom.

    I think I'd like the office to be another foot wider. A 4' walkway into the office is do-able ... but minimal.

    I'd put a large, floor-to-ceiling bookshelf across the back side of the large staircase /facing the living room. Of course, I have never, ever had enough bookshelves.

    I think the living room is a comfortable width, but it could stand to be another couple feet deeper. You only have 3' of walking space behind the chairs.

    Is that a buffet on the wall behind the table? I'd consider a banquette against that wall.

  • 11 years ago

    How is the office going to be used? It is very isolated and private, but not very spacious. I can't imagine wanting to spend much time in there working, but I'm a tad claustrophobic, even with a window there.

  • 11 years ago

    The main house is very nice but the new plan with the sewing room shortens the porch and ruins the effect.

  • PRO
    11 years ago

    You're right, more information is needed.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Idea: Our garage abuts our house at a 120-degree angle. Within the angle is the long rectangle of our 'back hall' -- with laundry area at one end and half-bath and huge closet (and back door) at the other end. This could give you back the front porch and shorten the walk garage-kitchen.

  • 11 years ago

    I like the inspiration photo, but very much agree with JDS' comment about the effect on the front of yours being ruined by the sewing room. I wouldn't have noticed that myself; it's a very insightful comment.

    If you stick with this plan, maybe detach the garage and move it to the left of the home or even behind it (then flip the office and mudroom)? You have acreage so you can avoid having a garage in front of your home.

    My only other comment is a very small point. Your kitchen island is 8.5x4--are you leaving 2' for an overhang or putting in two rows of 2' cabinets and leaving no overhang? If no overhang, those stools drawn in there won't work.