Software
Houzz Logo Print
aboutdabass

Double sink/disposal with two separate traps?

10 years ago

We often have drainage problems and smell problems in our double sink. We were told that it might be because our plumbing is wrong. I've researched this, and while it is definitely different than a typical installation around here (AZ), I can't find any evidence that it is actually wrong or against code. I've seen recommendations for both methods on the Internet.

We have a double sink with a disposal. It seems the standard method is to tee the two lines together first then to a single trap into the waste arm. In ours, each side of the sink has a trap. The two traps go into a 3-way tee at the drain arm. I think it may be the wrong kind of tee, but aside from that can anyone tell me if there is anything wrong with this double trap method?


We’re doing some other work in the kitchen, and if there is any reason to re-plumb this, now is the time. Looking for opinions on whether we should try a different configuration. Any advice is appreciated.

Comments (8)

  • 10 years ago

    It is contrary to code and causes two potential problems: syphoning of the trap not in use, or plugging of the trap that is not under the disposal, either of which would result in odors.

    aboutdabass thanked User
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    The connecting tee isn't good, the drainage will go straight from one side to the other instead of turning the corner. That is probably why it isn't siphoning currently... but it probably doesn't drain well either. I agree that there will probably be a siphon problem and resultant sewer gas if you changed the current tee into a double sweep tee.

    In any case, it is better to have it redone into one trap. If you can bring the pipes together to meet then have the trap after that, it should work. Unfortunately, what appears to be available for double sinks meeting in the middle is the tee that you currently have. I would recommend one of these instead, followed the trap.

    aboutdabass thanked Vith
  • 10 years ago

    It may just be the photo, but it looks like the pipe leading into the wall goes uphill? and that the wall pipe is actually higher than the disposal discharge? This would not be good.

    aboutdabass thanked weedmeister
  • 10 years ago

    I suspect aliceinwonderland's comment might be what is happening. I think that one side (especially the pressure from the disposal) may be siphoning the other side leaving a dry trap sometimes.

    We've tried everything else- enzymes and citrus to clean out disposal odor, etc. Also, I can confirm that the wall pipe is level and below the disposal discharge, so that may have just been an optical illusion from the camera angle.

    I will try re-plumbing with a single trap. But that still leaves me puzzled about one thing-

    When researching this, it seems the correct type of tee has an interior baffle to direct water towards the waste line, and not up the other side. I'm certainly not an expert, but this seems like a terrible design to me. It restricts flow, and seems like it would be a major opportunity for clogs. But all of the reputable information I can find shows that this is required by code and is how everyone seems to do it.

    I appreciate the comments and feedback.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I am thinking that clogs in that area are not a large concern due to the fact that it is accessible and designed to be taken apart. If you get the fitting I linked and use trap adapters on the two ends of them that should solve your worries about clogs.

  • 10 years ago

    The preferred method would be to have the pipe running straight out of the wall and turning down to go into a P-trap. Then put a T in the vertical pipe coming out of the other end of the P-trap and connect each side to a sink. However, since the drain from the disposal body points down, it might make the T too low.

    Bruce

  • 10 years ago

    What people put through a disposal can cause problems even on properly plumbed sinks. Most people put things in their disposal that should go in garbage can. If you can put it in the garbage can instead of flushing down disposal,do it and save yourself problems. When I installed my dish washer I removed the disposal and ran dw directly to wall. The origional intent of disposals was to handle food from hand washing dishes,not to replace the garbage can.

    If you replumb,look behind that tan bowl on wall to see if that's a clean-out plug. The drain would work much better connected there and having clean-out where drain presently go's. That configuration would have water flowing at higher volocity carrying waste with it.