Full frame replacement without removing interior trim?

10 years ago

Is it common to do a full frame replacement from the outside while leaving the interior trim intact? I found the a description of this "hybrid" method as follows:
"For the remaining windows on the house, we used a hybrid method. First the outside molding, the sashes, the balance system and the jambs were removed. (The inside casing and stool were left in place.) The replacement windows (from Lowes) were dimensioned to fit fairly snugly to the window rough framing.
The jambs of the new replacement windows went in tight against the inside casing and stool. After foaming, we put the outside molding back on. The result was no loss of glass area (some windows actually showed a gain.) and the look is just as good or better than that of the old windows."
I have a 1940s cynderblock and brick home and I do not want to do an insert replacement due to the the protruding, frame-in-frame look and also do not want to do a traditional full frame frame replacement the disturbs the interior trim. Any comments on this hybrid method? Is this something a good contractor will know how to do?

Featured Answer

johnhaney

6 years ago

@goehring19, what did you end up doing for your window installation project? I have a similar situation with my 140 year old victorian house. My contractor says he can stall new windows (w/flange) without disturbing the fancy interior trim. I see this as possible but only if the jambs are exactly the right depth.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

PRO
Windows on Washington Ltd
10 years ago
I would not, personally, refer to that as a full tear out. Full tear out means just that, full tear out, to me. What you are referring to is just a modified insert in my opinion and most good installers should know how to get that done.
goehring19
Original Author
10 years ago
It's an old window with pulleys and weights behind the jambs. There is a space for the weights and then there seems to be another wood frame embedded in the blocks. The jambs frame the sashes and an outer frame frames the weight pockets and the jambs. It may be only this outer frame that is attached to the masonry. So you think it is possible to remove the brickmold and jambs while leaving the stool and interior molding in place, and use a full frame replacement (with a full depth jamb and not a 3 1/4 inch jamb)? The interior trim may be nailed to the outer frame and this is what would make this possible. But I am not sure how this could be anything other than a hack job. I have only found this one mention of it anywhere. Thanks for any comments!
Related Professionals
Dallas General Contractors · Davenport General Contractors · Kalamazoo General Contractors · Middletown General Contractors · Newport General Contractors · Dickinson General Contractors · Mountain Home Home Remodeling · Mount Vernon Home Remodeling · New Haven Home Remodeling · Las Vegas Home Remodeling · Longview Interior Designers & Decorators · Burlington Interior Designers & Decorators · Palm Desert Interior Designers & Decorators · Denver Interior Designers & Decorators · Dodge City Interior Designers & Decorators
oberon476
6 years ago
Curious why you are wanting to change the windows on a 140 year old Victorian house?
millworkman
6 years ago
The trim is more than likely attached to the window frame (or at the very least should have been), so I don't see how he figures he can accomplish that. Also I would ask the same question as oberon476....................
PRO
MGBK inc
4 years ago
This is possible. You would likely have to keep the same style window. (DH for DH, CM forCM etc). The window sizes would have to be precise and well calculated. Reason being is every window frame is a bit different. You would need to be precise to be certain the interior trim meets the new window Jambs. Odds are your reveal where the casing meets the window jamb might be slightly different on the sides compared to the head and sill. With the old windows you likely had an even reveal all the way around. You probably never would have noticed. Im interested in seeing a photo from the exterior and the interior to see how it came out. Props to your installer for accomplishing this, Assuming no issues arise.