At first I was going to say Cocoplum, Chrysobalanus icaco, but the branches don't seem to match up with images I am pulling up. It seems to more closely resemble Pigeon Plum, Coccoloba diversifolia.

Thanks for the help, but unfortunately I think it's something else yet. This tree is about 20 feet tall and even wider. Here in Sarasota we have only a couple of Pigeon plums and they have smaller leaves and are a more compact tree. Could it be a type of Calophyllum that someone brought to the Fort Myers area from South Florida or is it something else yet?

Pigeon Plum can get up to 25 ft tall and 30 ft wide according to IFAS. Specifically looking at Pigeon Plum's fruit though, this definitely is not it. I do feel like I have seen this tree before though, and I feel I saw it in my Florida Natives book. I just seem to have misplaced it and so I am fishing through my spotty memory.

I tried another forum, they said it is a terminalia muelleri. I'm not sure if it's exactly

that, but it could be related to it.

wild almond

Terminalia catappa

I could see why you think it could be a Tropical Almond (teminalia catappa), but they are different. These trees have branches that go horizontal and the leaves are much larger, In fact i'm looking at the one I have in my yard right now and when I go to south florida tropical almonds are everywhere. I think Terminalia muelleri is probably right. Thanks anyway