Software
Houzz Logo Print
kbigelo

Base molding question-please advise ASAP!

10 years ago
Hi folks. I am about three weeks out from moving into my brand new place in a new construction planned community in Southern CA. I went to check progress today and I am concerned about this molding job. I really think quarter round is a last resort to cover a bad job- and that really shouldn't be the case here especially in NEW CONSTRUCTION. I've spent a lot of money already and expected this to be a clean, quality job. I want to let the construction superintendent know, but I would like to know your opinions, and what would you suggest I ask them to do. Thanks so much!!
Acceptable
Unacceptable- if so, what would you do?

Comments (12)

  • 10 years ago
    I would not tolerate that moulding job on a new home. Imo it looks like cheap builder grade slap together with a weird end cut on the end of the quarter round. all our layered mouldings have clean returns even if they are tiny which make everything look finished. I'd have a chat with the builder. Did the model home look like this? Or if you are having a custom build, did you discuss finish work with your builder?
    kbigelo thanked sabra900
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I would ask them why they put the additional trim piece on there in the first place and request that they take it off all together in order to have a clean, finished look. Request that they also repair any damage or poor craftsmanship on the flooring that they might be trying to conceal and cover up.

    kbigelo thanked Inspired Interiors Studio
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    You say it is new construction? I absolutely think you have an issue (or two) here. From your pictures it looks like a rehab. Are those the finished walls? What is under the paper on the floor?

    kbigelo thanked JudyG Designs
  • 10 years ago

    The response I received was the following:

    '¼ round is standard installation practice on wood or vinyl floors. What you may be looking at on the models is ceramic tile/simulated wood which receives grout not ¼ round or wide base which is an upgrade/option shown in the 3 plan model.'


    Then after I told him about the response I've been receiving here (I have it under design dilemmas as well) about it NOT being acceptable installation:


    'I have been in the homebuilding industry since 1965 and worked with 6 different builders and flooring companies. Without exception, this is how it has always been done on wood floors and vinyl floors. In fact, I have never even received a request to do it any other way. Jim – Your thoughts?' (FYI: Jim is from the Design Center where I ordered my flooring -Bernini from the Studio Moderno Line from Provenza).


  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Tell them to fix it ASAP!

    kbigelo thanked Raegan Ford Interior Design
  • 10 years ago

    OK, but what would a 'fix' look like to you? I have builders commenting that there is no other way. I don't get it!

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Here is an article which explains your situation...you can read and decide.

    My personal complaint about your molding is the mix...the bottom 1/4" round looks like an after thought. What would the molding look like with out it? Too much stuff going on, IMO, and it is going to be hard to keep clean.


    http://remodelingguy.net/2009/03/baseboards-and-shoe-moldings-and-quarter-rounds-oh-my/

    kbigelo thanked JudyG Designs
  • 10 years ago

    That final piece is not quarter round it's shoe molding. It IS common to use it on hardwood and vinyl because long runs of base will reveal gaps between the base and floor. Floors aren't always perfectly level and even if they are after install, they will not remain perfectly level due to settling. Shoe molding conforms to the floor better and hides that gap along with keeping out dirt, crumbs, lint, etc. Also, it protects the base from damage and is much cheaper to replace due to damage than the base itself. The shoe is usually installed the other direction (taller side to the base), however trim is also heavily influenced by opinion. You've taken the correct step by discussing it with the builder. Being that it's standard practice, and it may have been necessary for covering gaps, it is something that you will need to find a compromise on with the builder. It's your house and you have final say, but keep in mind that contracts and how they are written dictate what it will cost to have it done differently if that is the route you choose. Hope this is more helpful than "Tell them to fix it ASAP".

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    It's possible you have floating wood floor. Which means you must leave more space against wall as they need to breath/move. Not sure if you are questioning qtr round shud be there at all ? or the quality? Or proportions? But qtr end shud be there

  • 10 years ago
    NO!
  • 10 years ago

    kbigelo- what was the outcome of this dilemma?