Software
Houzz Logo Print
dandylioness

Fire and Ice VS Little Quick Fire

Tell me about your experience with these! How do these two look throughout the season? I've read that Quick Fire gets great foliage color in the fall, does the compact version do the same? Does Fire and Ice get any fall foliage change? Would love to see pictures!

Comments (14)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Perhaps it is the differences in our climate, but I wouldn't describe regular QF's foliage as great here. Most years it goes straight from green to brown, but even in the one year I had some color, it was a muddy yellow that didn't look like much compared to other types of plants in the same bed which had much nicer foliage color. The only other H. paniculata variety that I have had for enough time to judge, Pinky Winky, gets some yellow most years, but also doesn't ever develop fall foliage as nicely colored as most of the other plants nearby. I love my H. paniculatas, but their fall pink/red blooms are more spectacular than their foliage.

    Here is the best my QF has ever looked as far as fall foliage; it's just to the left of the blue spruce.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Well, over here, the leaves of Little Quick Fire turn a nice bright yellow (while on the shrub, they start green of course, turn medium yellow, then they fall to the ground yellow, stay yellow a litlle longer and then turn brown on the ground just AFTER a few more orangey and-or brown-red color changes on the floor. Wish I could post a picture but my digital camera went bust and I have yet to replace it. Want to make LQF look even better? Place it near a smoke tree whose leaves turn orangey.

    I thought I had some pictures of Fire and Ice somewhere ??? but F&I's leaves were different, more orange than Little QF's yellow and from orange they turn reddish/wine purple.

    Hard to choose between the two as I like different colors... like middle yellows, bright yellows, orangeys, purples/wine and all kinds of reds. Thus, I think you may like both of them.

  • 10 years ago
    Thanks for the info! How about as far as blooms go? How is the color? Bloom quality/quantity/size?
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    LQF blooms quite early. LQFs have blooms similar to your standard QF just smaller: early blooms that start white then pinkish and -eventually- brown. I am trying LQF because it is an early bloomer. "Regular" paniculata bloomers sometimes end blooming here in the hot summer months so some of them will skip the pinkish bloom stage and go directly from white to green-pink and then brown.

    I assume QF would be similar, time wise, for the blooms (ie, it blooms early). You basically just get one bloom at the end of the most stems in all paniculatas. The LQF blooms are not as big as Phantom or Mt. Everest. Just a tad smaller than regular QF.

  • 10 years ago

    IME QF has lacier and rounder bloom panicles than most of the other H. paniculatas, something I really like. It also means that between the stiff branches and the lighter weight blooms, it never droops at all. I don't know if this is also the case in LQF. My QF blooms a full month earlier than my Pinky Winky and keeps its blooms about 5 months. Again, in your different climate, your mileage may vary.

  • 10 years ago
    Wonderful info about LQF. thank you!

    How about Fire and Ice? Does it really get that dark reddish pink color that photos show online?
  • 10 years ago

    Here's my LQF this past fall. We had an exceptionally long fall without a hard freeze. All the other Hyd. pan. varieties in the same general area all looked like this, thoughtI think this one and Quickfire had more purple tones to the leaves.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I too would like to know about the flowers of Fire and Ice. Are they pointy mounds or more rounded? I bought Quickfire because the mounds of florets appeared more rounded, but I don't know if they really do turn out that way and am considering buying Fire and Ice. Does the color advance to pink nicely? Does it really gets the beautiful deep flower color in the fall. Anyone have experience with it or any other comments on Fire and Ice as a plant?

  • 9 years ago

    Definitely more rounded than pointy. I'll add a pic later because it's dark out right now. Bloom time for my F&I was only a couple weeks behind my mature QF. I would venture to say F&I isn't a whole lot different than LQF, though I forget what the Fall foliage looks like. I don't have much of a thing for Fall foliage of any sort. You get one nice sunny day where you can appreciate everything changing colors, but most days are just gloomy.

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you. I don't really care about fall color personally. The long cones of things like strawberry sundae I don't find attractive as I rather prefer the domed shape of Annabelle if she just wasn't so aggressive to take over real estate even after I thought I removed her. I also saw one photo that had a row of fire and ice and they looked a very blah shade of pink/beige and the florets were spaced far apart to make the scene all the worse.. Perhaps it was just a moment between two attractive colors, but it made me wonder what others have experienced. I look forward to any photos.

  • 4 years ago

    Cearbhaill, how is your Fire and Ice hydrangea doing? I am really curious to see how it does long term!


    Also, how early does it bloom, when comparing to Quick Fire? Thanks!

  • 4 years ago

    In MN, Fire and Ice blooms about the same time as QF.

  • 4 years ago

    I determined last fall to give them a chance to show themselves so I whacked them all back to about a foot and have been concentrating on keeping them better watered and looked after. They really are in the farthest back corner I have and awfully easy to forget. But a tree removal nearby has opened up a bit more light for them and I am hopeful that they do something lovely soon, so wanted to give them their best chance before I write them off.