Software
Houzz Logo Print
ingrid_vc

Please Help Me Pick a Purple Rose

My country garden in the hills has been deliberately kept soft in color so as not to clash with the natural landscape. At the same time, there are certain areas that seem mainly pink where I'd like to introduce a stronger color. Since I want to add to an order at Chamblee's I'm considering Purple Rain, Plum Perfect and Blue for You. My place has lots of radiant heat in the summer from the steep hill that is part of the front garden area, huge boulders and a large expanse of concrete. Are any of the three more suitable to this environment, and which one would be less liable to turn totally pink in the summer heat? Thanks in advance for your help.

Comments (45)

  • 10 years ago

    I received Blue for You from Chamblee's last spring. It has been a great rose for me here in South Florida. I do not know how it will do in the long haul for me, since it is not or Fortuania root stock. But for an own root here in the hot tropics of Florida it is a blooming machine. I have not had any black spot on her either. I am hoping to add a couple more purples as well, so I am anxious on hearing how Purple Rain and Plum Perfect does. However, I am sure you would be happy with Blue for you.

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked sharon2079
  • 10 years ago

    Sharon, some people have commented that the roses are somewhat shapeless after they open, and in the summer especially some will turn pink or almost white, which is then mixed in with the purple roses and that gives a rather hodge-podge effect. Have you found that to be the case? It's good to know that in your hot climate it's doing well and blooming profusely. I have Fragrant Plum and mentioned it on another thread and was told it's healthy and blooms a lot. It is also quite fragrant, which I gather is not always the case with purple or lavender roses.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    The only one that I can comment on is Purple Rain. I'm in a seriously different climate but even here PR is anything but purple toned. More of a pink color which I did not care for. It was very healthy but was shovel pruned.

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
  • 10 years ago

    Ingrid, I have a friend who is going to post a picture of my Blue for you. The cluster has been on the bush for several days. I thought it held up quite well, considering that we have had very gusty wind alternating with rain. ... I have not noticed it turning ping. I have Outta the Blue which sometimes has a hint of the magenta. However, to be fair, I had it in a pot most of the summer sitting in a shady area. I just recently moved it to the ground and it took off blooming. the blooms are a dark purple right now in 80 plus degree weather. I hope this helps.

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked sharon2079
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ingrid, Here is Sharon's Blue for You.

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked mbz10b
  • 10 years ago

    Thank you Marybeth!!!!!

  • 10 years ago

    Patty, if Purple Rain isn't purple in your zone I shudder to think what it would be like in the heat here. The last thing I need is another pinkish rose; I've got that covered. I can totally understand your shovel pruning a healthy rose because I'm seriously considering that with Rina Hugo, which was supposed to have magenta to purple tones but mine is more like fire engine red most of the time. It's not a good look.

    Thank you Sharon, and Marybeth, for that lovely picture. Your Blue for You is really darling, and I like the informal shape of the flowers since mine is a country garden and anything too stiff and formal just doesn't look right. Since you say it's been blooming for a few days I can see there's no pink, and I wonder if it only does that when it's really hot. I imagine the new buds at least would look purple even if the flowers turn more pink later when it's summer.

  • 10 years ago

    Ingrid, It has been an unseasonably warm December here, in the 80's every day and some rain almost every day. It was a little cooler in November. Some others Sharon suggested were Intrigue and Twilight Zone. She said they are both fragrant.

    Intrigue

    Twilight Zone

    She also said they are both darker than they appear in the photos.

  • 10 years ago

    It's not on your list bur if I had to recommend a purple rose it would be Love Song. It's beautiful in all stages and it smells really nice.


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    A purple rose is indeed nearly impossible in your heat. Add too that a soft natural blending shape. I believe purple blooming perennials fit the bill. Even here I have had problems with all purple roses I've tried. In the heat of summer, which many years barely reaches the low nineties. I decided long ago to go with a variety of veronica does well in moist soils and high humidity. They bloom all season in nice purple tones.

    This may not sound good to you. But some nice cream roses could give more life too the light pink area. Mix in purple perennials. I have odd ideas I know but I like blends more than contrasts too make colors more lively.

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked Patty W. zone 5a Illinois
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ingrid, I grow Eyes for You, which I believe is related to Blue for You, and it has performed well in the heat. Maybe they have that commonality too. Twilight Zone is very heat tolerant, but more hot pinkish/fuchsia than purple during the summer. I left seven behind when we moved, but still grow one because it is so healthy and for the months that it is good, it is really good. Ebb Tide has a smokey purple color that blends so nicely with pink, and in terms of fragrance, it is one of my favorites. Ebb Tide has a "softness" that I do not find Twilight Zone to have. Ebb Tide definitely has to be in a prime, morning sun only location. In my garden, Love Song is in the lavender realm of purple. I love it and actually have 5 growing in my garden.

    Mzb10b, Your friend's Blue for You is very pretty. I think it will be going on my wish list.

    This is the only image of Ebb Tide I can find... but have seen better... It has the soft, powdery, smokey coloring that I prefer, and... it is so much better now that it is closer to maturity.

    Lynn

  • 10 years ago

    I've not found any purple or lavender to be a heat lover.

  • 10 years ago

    Love Song is always consistently lavender for me and takes our dry heat very well. Check the thread about lavender roses that Sara started. I've got some photos taken at different times during the season that show this. I think Twilight Zone is excellent in holding its blooms' dark purple coloration, but it might be too upright for you. I find it fits in quite well with all the plantings around it. Diane

    New Love Song in June.

    Love Song, July 22. This is a brand new rose.

    Diane

  • 10 years ago

    I have a "mini" lavender (it gets to be about 2--3 feet by 2 feet or so) that seems to love the heat. It is a great rose, easy to grow on its own root. It is one of my favorites. It stays lavender. No pink. Lavender Crystal. It is a little workhorse of a rose.



    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked mustbnuts zone 9 sunset 9
  • 10 years ago

    Mustbenuts, I've thought for some time when I see your Lavender Chrystal photo, that it looks like Love Song's little sister. So very pretty. I'd love to grow LC myself. Diane

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    This is a two day old bloom of Love Song during July when the high temperature was 111 degrees. It looked like this.....

    An unfurling bloom from the same Love Song rose bush..... October... . I love the lavender coloring...

    Lynn

  • 10 years ago

    Wow, Lynn. that's great, and she looks so fresh and lovely. What a wonderful rose. I'm glad to see she likes Las Vegas. Diane

  • 10 years ago

    Ingrid, I'm in a totally different climate, but I've often read Jeri touting 'International Herald Tribune' as doing well in California.

    :-)

    ~Christopher

  • 10 years ago

    What a beautiful assortment of purples and lavenders! I have grown Intrigue and International Herald Tribune in the past and have purchased another IHT band since the two I had some years ago did not make it through the drought in its hot location. This one and any lavender or purple rose I buy will definitely have afternoon shade and will be on a drip system. Chamblee's actually carries Love Song and in the pictures here it's exquisite. Lynn, even in the summer heat this is a beautiful rose, one I really would consider. I did have Ebb Tide early on and it was fragrant and beautiful, but was unfortunately not suitable for my climate, crisping very quickly. Intrigue had pretty flowers but it was a very awkward-looking bush.

    Lavender Crystal is really adorable. I'll have to check whether Chamblee's carries it. seil, your Love Song is really exquisite. Ah, the agony of decision! Thank you all so much for your assistance.

  • 10 years ago

    I know HTs are not your thing-- but this is Angel Face in San Diego's Balboa Park. Lavender can do some heat, and while this is more coastal than where you are, they held up pretty well.
    A shot of the beautiful Lagerfeld in my old neighborhood of Mission Hills, San Diego. So gorgeous. Of course, not the shape you are going for, but it is too pretty not to share!

  • 10 years ago

    Charles de Gaulle is one of my favorite. Even in desert heat it retains nice color. Neptune is below, also.

  • 10 years ago

    Yes, Angel Face is great in dry heat here, lousy in the cold, but I love her. I thought she was a floribunda. Diane

    Angel Face


    Diane

  • 10 years ago

    I'm happily drowning in more beautiful roses! Thank you, ninkasi, Jim and Diane for the added delight. I just never tire of lavender/purple roses; they're definitely a passion of mine.

  • 10 years ago

    Ingrid, I have an own root Blue for You, which doesn't go pink in the heat. It gets reflected heat from pavers and full afternoon sun. It fades to a soft smoky blue from consistently mid purple petals at opening, however my soil is not alkaline, which might make a difference. It is very floriferous, though and has had no fungal problems at all. I can say the same for Eyes for You. They are both very pretty roses which mix well with OGRs. Plum Perfect is on order for next year because I have heard very good reports and it has always looked good in the nurseries as it fades to lavender. Purple Rain, when I have seen it, is more pinkish magenta so it never appealed to me. Melodye

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked ozmelodye
  • 10 years ago

    Angel Face is a floribunda and she is a beauty and smells divine, however, if you have black spot in your area she WILL get it, first and hardest of any rose in your garden. Along with any and every other disease known to roses! As far as I know she is pretty much a disease magnet in every part of the country that has disease pressures.

    Love Song does spot some here but never extensively and never goes naked of leaves from it. It's also a very vigorous grower and a heavy bloomer. It can be a little bit winter tender but if it survives, even if it's just one short stick, it comes back very strong and quickly.

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked seil zone 6b MI
  • 10 years ago

    No diseases whatsoever on my Angel Face in my dry climate with alkaline soil. My problem with AF is that I could not bury the graft where I planted her due to a rock hard layer of caliche. I really should find another spot for her. So I protect her, but sometimes it hasn't gotten done, and then she really died back from the cold. Luckily, Ingrid doesn't have the cold problem. Do you have any black spot in your area, Ingrid? I know it's dry there. I've always thought of Angel Face as a hot weather, California loving rose in the state's dry zones. Diane


    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked nanadollZ7 SWIdaho
  • 10 years ago

    Blue for You has retained a blueish-lav. here, a couple hundred miles north of you Ingrid. Our nights are cooler than yours I think but daytime Sept. and Oct. are up in the high 90's off and on. Blue For You is definitely on my radar.

    Ebb Tide, Love Song. Plum Perfect and Twilight Zone all have "pinked" here. Everyone's eyes may perceive color differently but after observing these roses here and in San Jose I decided to keep searching for a better "blue". I have Angel Face (mauve), Lagerfeld (stays quite lavender but wacky growth) and Intrigue (magenta purple). I was wondering about a "harsh" yellow to go with my pastel pinks. Molineux looked great in a bouquet photo with Sharifa and Lagerfeld. Hmm, in person?

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    Here Lagerfeld thinks it is a climber, so no matter how far I cut it back, I get those long canes with huge candelabras of flowers at the ends. Lovely soft colour that never gets a chance to fade because the blooms blow so quickly. Lovely scent though and pretty buds for indoors.

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked ozmelodye
  • 10 years ago

    I never had blackspot before but now to my surprise I do, so I suppose Angel Face is out. I can't believe how many beautiful mauves and purples there are, to the point where I'm confused! A part of me is definitely leaning toward Blue for You, but too many of these roses look good to me. Purple Rain is out I think because it tends to turn pink. I'm fascinated by the pictures of Twilight Zone, Diane, because I can't imagine that rose turning pink or even the dreaded red that I've encountered with some crimson/purplish roses.

    I'm overwhelmed by the response I've gotten, with so many beautiful pictures, thank you all so much. You're the best!

  • 10 years ago

    In my tropical climate,

    Midnight Blue is deep purple in color.

    Bluemoon is silvery purple.

    Blue for you is blueish purple.

    I haven't seen or have other blue or purple version yet to reccomend you, but those 3 are ok in my opinion.

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked Einin Dee
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ingrid, Blackspot is rare here too, but Barbara Streisand is infected right now.... Angel Face is always clean, but my climate is more arid.... Angel Face is in my lavender bed, grouped next to Love Song adjacent to Barbara Streisand.

    In my garden, Angel Face skews toward mauve versus lavender during cooler temperatures. There is a definite difference between Angel Face versus Love Song and Neptune in coloring. My conditions are alkaline, being in the 7.6- 7.8 range.

    Here's Twilight Zone showing purple before it became hades here. Mine is on Dr. Huey and a year old. Diane's Twilight Zones are more mature than mine were/are, and, other factors may account for that gorgeous dark purple color seen on hers.

    During my hot summers, not much maintains the colors I see the rest of the year. I am also at about 2900 ft. in elevation.

    Twilight Zone ( late May 2014)... Sorry it is not the best image

    Angel Face about 3 weeks ago....the blooms on the bushes right now skew more so toward mauve

    Lynn

  • 10 years ago

    Beautiful roses, Lynn. My Twilight Zone definitely keeps improving both in color and size of blooms during the three years I have grown it. The size of the plant really kicked in and grew the third year, too.

    Oh, heck, I guess I'll mention Ebb Tide. We need to keep this thread going, right Ingrid? ET does have the most unique smoky coloration when the temps are cooler, and its scent is lovely, too. The downside is the fading the blooms undergo when those hot temps start up. To me, putting up with the fading is something I do in order to enjoy the times when Ebb Tide has its unique coloration going. Diane

    Ebb Tide

    Ebb Tide showing fading.

    Diane

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked nanadollZ7 SWIdaho
  • 10 years ago

    I think Lavender Crystal might be your rose of choice. I grow or have grown massive numbers of lavender's and that is the best one for hot/dry -- it doesn't fade out in color, ever, and has a pleasing old-fashioned layout to the petals, with lots of them, and the deeper color on the interior of the bloom. And it's a short rose workhorse, too. Can be purchased own root from Burlington Roses. If you want a giant rose, however, then maybe Singing the Blues. It can be a 7 footer, and it actually does everything that everyone wishes Angel Face would do as a plant, with blooms that look quite similar to Angel Face. Blue for You is also a good medium size rose for me, but not in heat spells. Blue for You, however, prefers cool/damp/coastal weather for best health and colors.


    Kathy

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked kstrong
  • 10 years ago

    Nice to see your comments on Lavender Crystal. I have had this rose for years and just love it. So easy to grow on its own root. I really don't know anyone else that has or has had this rose. Nice to know there is someone else out there with this rose. I have been trying to find another rose that was developed by this breeder. It goes by a couple of names. So far no luck. It doesn't seem to be in commercial production any more. It is a beautiful dark maroon with some white near the base of the rose. It is a beauty and if it is anything like Lavender Crystal, it has to be a great rose.

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked mustbnuts zone 9 sunset 9
  • 10 years ago

    Love Song in October, grown in my garden about 15 miles from you, Ingrid. I love it and it does pretty well in the heat.

  • 10 years ago

    Beautiful bouquet, Lisa. I love those daisies with Love Song, and I agree LS would be the perfect pick for Ingrid. Diane

  • 10 years ago

    The Daisy and Love Song bouquet is so pretty and feminine. Love Song is at the top of my list for this spring! I want all the lavenders and blues I can get LOL! Just about every photo I've seen of Love Song is beautiful and shows a good lavender tone so it must be a good choice.

  • 10 years ago

    Lisa, that bouquet is so gorgeous! You have a real talent for arrangement and the white vase is perfect. Every picture I've seen of Love Song has been so pretty, and this is a very tempting rose, but so are many of the others. If Blue for You is better in cool coastal weather I don't think it would like it here. Lavender Crystal seems like a very good bet also, and I've heard it praised as being good in my general area. I don't have room for a giant rose but wonder if I would prefer the larger blooms of LS over LC. I'm off to check out Lavender Crystal on HMF. Thanks so much for the added into and the eye candy.

  • 10 years ago

    I just planted an own-root Charles de Gaulle this past summer. It's progressing well and I hope it turns out as nice as Jim's.

    John A

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    There are several photos of Charles de Gaulle in the Roses "C" thread. Apparently it is a very photogenic rose. They are all beautiful. John, I'm sure yours will be too. I wish I had space for one.

  • 10 years ago

    I'm still pondering my choices. I'm somewhat limited since I already have an order in for Chamblee's and the more I order from there the lower the shipping costs. So far I've ordered two Charles Darwin since I thought a soft golden yellow would also provide some needed contrast, and Darcey Bussell, since it's also somewhat purplish, although it's listed as more of a crimson red. Now I'm wondering whether I should replace Darcey, which is supposedly very healthy and good in the heat, with a more truly purple rose. Does anyone here have Darcey Bussell? I've made so many mistakes in ordering roses and it's always devastating to me because I feel I should know better by now. Love Song is a strong favorite, but Chamblee's also has Plum Perfect. I've already ruled out Purple Rain since it turns pink, and am hesitant about Blue for You because it's supposedly better in a cooler coastal climate.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I do not grow Darcey Bussell, but have seen it in heat and it appeared red ( not a bright red though). I have also seen it appear purplish in cooler temperatures. You seem to be even pickier about reds than I tend to be. I passed on D.B. for my garden and heat. I selected Munstead Wood because it never appears "red", but more of a deep dark red, however in my garden it does not have the purple tones, just a deep, velvety, burgundy tone which I like.

    Lynn

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked Lynn-in-TX-Z8b- Austin Area/Hill Country
  • 10 years ago

    Go with Love song, Ingrid. Earlier in this thread, I got my 2015 summer temps mixed up when discussing Love Song's ability to withstand heat. On June 28 of last summer, it was 110 here, and I had planted my second Love Song about a week before this. That rose never missed a beat. It was blooming when I put it in the ground and continued popping out those big lavender blooms--never pink for me-- all summer. Even after a wind storm had blown the back half of the plant off. Next best for a straight dark, purple in my garden is Twilight Zone. Munstead Wood is great, but it's not truly purple, though sometimes close, but more of a very dark burgundy red with black like tones. Diane

    I think I've shown this photo before, but I want to point out that this is a pic of a brand new rose, sitting on the patio (note cement) that was planted in the heat a few days later. It wasn't cool on the patio, either. Diane

    Diane

    ingrid_vc so. CA zone 9 thanked nanadollZ7 SWIdaho
  • 10 years ago

    Dear Lynn and Dianne, I had just written you a long post in answer to yours and at the last few words my system crashed. More briefly now I have cancelled Darcey Bussell and ordered Love Song since the lady at Chamblee's confirmed that for her, in Texas, DB was always more reddish and LS always stayed purplish, although I suppose it's really more in the mauve range. She also thought that LS was prettier than Blue For You when I asked her opinion. Thanks to your last two posts I now feel quite sure that I've made the right decision. I had already ordered DB before I began this thread about purple roses and was just going to add a purple, but if DB is reddish I know I wouldn't have been happy and it would have been a waste of money. Diane, I'm really amazed at your Love Song's resistance to the heat, and that makes me even more excited about getting one, since heat I've got. Twilight Zone is beautiful and I would have considered it but Chamblee's doesn't offer it. Maybe one to consider further down the road. Thanks again for taking so much time to assist me.