That amount of seating at either of those prices IS cheap. If you''re buying for looks alone I suppose fine........just don't expect long term comfort or good looks with daily use. Because good is rarely cheap, and cheap is rarely good.

If you are actually going to use this furniture I would go shopping and find something that is both stylish and comfortable I love low backed sofas with an adjustable head rest so you get the look but also the comfort

take the dog, he seems to know exactly what you need! dogs are always trustworthy

Thanks guys. This is not going to be a couch that I'm going to be using on a daily basis, so it'll be mostly just for looks. Which of the two links would be more appropriate? Also trying to go with the more contemporary look.

they are so close in color and form, that noone will even notice the difference. I do believe you are mistaken though. If this is for impressing others, they will not be impressed if not comfortable. Seats that squeak, pull, sag, are like sitting on cement immediately override the look nice aspect, unless you are just trying to impress passers by who look in the windows.

I'm definitely not getting the one from eBay. In regards to the first link, I think they may actually be quite comfortable. I hear they are pretty durable and have decent reviews.

Here is another that I'm currently considering. They are actually comfy. http://www.zgallerie.com/p-14392-pierce-3-pc-sectional-charcoal.aspx

Had something like this before http://www.natuzzisacramento.com/sites/default/files/imagecache/large/collections/natuzzi-2375-diagonal-sectional-1.jpg that was returned because it was custom, but the light fabric and bulkiness of the sectional (I have low ceilings, and a puppy) definitely did not do it for me.

Well the last one seems more bulky to me. other than the very most obvious difference in the back, I really don't think we can help you any further. Patricia and Jan are both experts, I give a more general home owners opinion. So, you kinda have to choose your favorite. If there are other things you need help with-colors, rugs, curtains, pillows tables, lighting, just call.

my question will be - what do you expect?

Have you used painter's tape to tape out the footprint of your favorite of the 4 sofas on the actual floor where it will sit? That may offer you a choice if these vary in size in any considerable way. I'm not crazy about any of them, but getting too large a sofa for the space is a complaint we hear all too often here at Houzz. Measure once, tape out once and make no mistake on the right size. Style and quality are other questions, and only you can determine that.

Check out the Radley model sectional from Macy's. They have a pretty grey called "chrome". January always holds great furniture sales. Good luck!

Thanks @havingfun that's exactly what I plan on doing. I'm choosing one sectional (I think I'll stick with the Karl sectional from Home Design) and have multiple seating options.

Style wise, what would go with that sectional I'm picking (and style wise)? Two chairs, etc.

ok, i will play along, of course we have no idea how big this room is, so we will just assume you have a galaxy in there?

we will keep the simple charcoal base going, shall we? I would prefer a different rug, but i presume you wish to work with this one? so, once again, you have answered zero regarding color preference, so you get mine.

I always like a set of sheers on a window

I love the drapes below, they are latest in style, they are different and they encompass the brick fp, tile, and gray couch.

I like these for end tables, they give shininess and brightness to the room and are not so solid heavy. Also since the room is heavy on angles, this will provide 3 round things.
if you do an overhead, these always appeal to me, modern yet a chandy.

if no overhead chandy, what about this.
otherwise

be back later with art and pillows

I forgot 2 other choices, one sticks with angular theme

this one brings in the fireplace and walls more.

All are original art way under $1000, i like each, because they help to marry the walls/fp/grays and more importantly, i just like them, which is why you should buy art. many more on line, i was not given a price point.

etsy and saatchi.

there are many more, these just keep in the black gray a little tan. if you like some we can add.

I like the minimalism of your room, but it's getting a little sterile. I also think the fireplace shelves diminish the impact of the stone and you have a lot of big black boxes in the room. How about a bit of natural color? (And lower all your hanging things.)

Actually, how about moving the TV to the wall with a wood cabinet underneath to warm it up a bit?

California-sectional-sofa@Cressina.com

yes, what is that thing on the right wall?

Thank you everyone, all of this is amazing!

Been thinking about painting that limestone as well to more neutral colors: I do like greys, whites, black, etc. The traditional minimalism colors, with a pop of accent color here and there (green, red, blue).

What colors would go amazing on the limestone? The ceilings aren't high, so I don't want it too dark, I do want the same to seem more open and spacious as well.

you should never paint stone.

Here is our Ethan Allen - Conway sofa and Sectional. Great look, comfortable and quality pieces that will last you. You can place the fabric of your choice on the piece and the ability to adjust the comfort of the cushion to your liking.

I bought the most perfect beautiful sectional in the world! It is good quality perfect color too leather. I’d never seen this shape, as if you cut a do-nut in half, no corners & has nailhead ...... plenty but not too many. Very pricey plus the matching ottoman is an extra $Grand. Luckily a friend we went to high school with owns a high-end furniture store in Visalia & we saved $$$$$ ! The store is Janeen’s Furniture in Visalia CA. 93277. The sectional is FLEXSTEEL which means it will be passed down to another generation or two at least. If you are interested tell her Christy & Danny sent you & you are interested in the semi-circle leather sectional like the one we bought from her. You can also go to Fashion Furniture in Fresno, CA & sit on the one in their huge showroom but after you see THEIR PRICE, tell Janeen & she WILL BEAT IT. Also, just my opinion but I would not have bought the ottoman; it’s just TOO MUCH LEATHER. I saw one I wish I’d have gotten instead, made of distressed wood & hammered copper. I believe the one priced at Fashion Furniture was $10 K without the ottoman. Yikes!