Software
Houzz Logo Print
bielski

Shower Tiles Deteriorating

10 years ago



We remodeled our shower about 7 months ago. Glass tile on the walls and honed 2" limestone mosaic on the floor. I noticed after a month or 2 that the edges of the tile in parts of the shower were coding and detriorating. I then started to notice it more and then started seeing pits and chips in some of the tile. It is happening only in a portion of the shower. What is going on? My contractor says he doesn't have any idea, but he's also not rushing to replace it. What could be the problem??

I started noticing it after about month 2. We only clean with products designed for stone.

Comments (12)

  • 10 years ago

    Limestone is a very soft stone. It's basically compacted sand. I would think it would hold up a little better than that after 2 months, but looks like a redo. Next time puck a porcelain.

  • 10 years ago

    was the limestone sealed. Acidity in soaps, and water can damage limestone, and eat through the sealer.

  • 10 years ago
    They used 511 impregnator, but I'm
    Not sure how much. Seemed like the just wiped it on with a rag.
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Sealer isn't armour. The choice of the limestone in combination with your water quality and showering rituals lead to the spalling. If this was a traditional shower pan with a vinyl liner, you can remove the floor tiles and supporting drypack bed and replace without damaging the shower. When the upper layers are removed, be sure to check the liner is sloped towards the drain (has a pre-slope under it) and that there was pea gravel (or similar) around the drain to help the weep holes stay open. If any of those steps were missed, the upper layer of drypack will hold water from the very first shower, hastening the deterioration of the limestone.

  • 10 years ago

    Poor design. Maybe poor execution. After you gut it all, you can tell.

    Jason Bielski thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    Questions? What stone is good for shower floors? Should my designer have known this? Should the tile store that she works with have known this? Should my contractor have done anything differently? It's only been 7 months since the install.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    1- IMHO there are no good natural stones for floors as they are far more porous than porcelain

    2- Yes

    3- Yes

    4- Besides advised you not to do it ? See my post above on the numerous possible mistakes. The 7 month time span is about right if any of the above mistakes were made. We will not know for sure unless there is destructive demolition

  • 10 years ago

    you could do marble, or real stones.

  • 10 years ago
    How much does having hard water factor in to this. The guy at the tile shop told me that if I installed a water softener (which ain't cheap) I wouldn't have this problem.
  • 10 years ago

    Hard water usually doesn't break things down. It usually just adds buildup to the surface.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Without knowing if the shower was properly constructed, we don't know. I highly doubt the salesman is correct though.