Software
Houzz Logo Print
josko021

How much OM can soil take?

10 years ago

I've been amending eelgrass, decomposed wood chips, leaf mulch, compost, etc., and my last UMASS soil test came back with 9.8% OM, which got me wondering if I'm perhaps overdoing the amending. Realistically, what %OM should I shoot for, and once I get there , how much OM do I need to add (per square foot0 to keep it there)

Garden's doing great except for my potato puzzler: 3'-4' greens, almost no tubers ( maybe 2:1 ratio of harvested:seeded spuds.)

Comments (12)

  • 10 years ago

    If you are growing edibles/harvestable crops, I'd say that was right about on target. Ideally, 5-10% is the recommended level but as OM doesn't stay as OM for long, I'd not be at all concerned about approaching the upper levels.

    Are you talking about this year's potatoes? Where are you that they are already 3-4' tall? And what kind of potatoes? Generally, pots are ready to harvest after the plants' bloom cycle and when the top growth starts to die back. Too much leafy growth and no tubers would perhaps indicate excess N in the soil.

  • 10 years ago

    10% is typical of prairie loam, so you are good. What you need now is some biology, which you will get by not tilling and making sure there are fungi (I am sure worms have moved in).

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Sorry - I'm on Cape Cod, MA and was referring to last year's potato crop. (They were Russian bananas.) Veggie garden soil started out pretty much sand, but I've been building it up for ~10 yrs now, and seem to have no nutrient deficiencies and almost 10% OM. Principal soil amendment has been eelgrass. The sand-silt-clay soil test still comes up 85% sand, 10% silt and 5% clay.

  • 10 years ago

    Trade you a truckload of MO clay for some of that! haha

  • 10 years ago

    In fact they don't mix. I had extremely sandy soil, took a number of wheelbarrows of grey clay from a neighbor, and buried them in the garden. Years after they had not mixed with the sand. I would drop tons of OM on top, and the worms would skirt around the clay and go to the surface to eat. Archuleta says that really stable forest sandy soil will have myc. eventually wrapping around every grain of sand, but I don't think I had that.

  • 10 years ago

    Yes, it does sound like the OM is doing pretty good in that soil.

    I'm surprised to hear that clay wouldn't help. Of course the clay will wash out of the sand soon enough, but I would be inclined to keep trying to add good clay to the garden. If the OP is making their own compost, I would suggest adding some clay to the compost pile. When the finished compost is added to the garden beds, the clay will be infused with humic and fulvic acids and will instantly improve fertility.

  • 10 years ago

    On growing potatoes on a sandy peninsula or barrier island -- on the OBX of North Carolina they say you can't grow Irish potatoes. Thanks Giving dinner used to be Red Drum and sweet potatoes -- no white potatoes. That's what the old timers say -- maybe there is something to that? Maybe your soil is just fine but potatoes don't like the beach :)

  • 10 years ago

    Most all publications about soils I have seen, and most of the soil scientists
    I have talked with state that 5 percent organic matter in soil is adequate. My experience is that 6 to 8 percent is optimal.

    Organic matter in soil is the residual of the organic material put into the soil, the undigested portion of what has been put into the soil. The terms "organic matter" and organic material" are often used interchangeably which only leads to confusion. Organic material is what is added to soils, compost, shredded leaves, and other vegetative waste that feeds the Soil Food Web that creates the organic matter that then stays put in the soil.

    Too much organic matter in soil can create other problems just as too little will.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    "Too much organic matter in soil can create other problems just as too little will."

    That addresses my original question. What happens to the soil when OM starts getting too high, whatever that percentage is?

  • 10 years ago

    If it's in an area that doesn't drain well and also gets a lot of rain, high organic soil can get boggy and anaerobic, leading to things like fungus and root rot. I doubt you'd have those particular problems in sand though, which drains like a mofo.

    I would not expect clay and sand to mix themselves or worms to do it either. They will move organic matter around (they eat it and poop it) where it is abundant. High organic clay, maybe, but most of the clay I see is brown and very low in OM. I'd be tilling those together along with some compost if I was going to try and change the soil texture.

  • 10 years ago

    I guess in a wet enough climate too much organic stuff can go anaerobic.

    Otherwise, excessive organic material is about 153 on my list of garden worries. Better to err on the side of too much rather than too little ( within reason.)

  • 10 years ago

    Too much organic matter in soils can cause that soil to hold too much water which will exclude air and make the soil anaerobic. Understand that while many use the terms "organic material" and "organic matter" interchangeably they are not. Organic material is what you add to soil, the vegetative waste (shredded leaves, compost, etc.) that becomes the organic matter, the residual, undigested organic material, in soil. Organic matter is what the Soil Food Web does not readily digest.

    A good healthy soil is one that is in balance.

    kimmq is kimmsr

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting