Software
Houzz Logo Print
billr5

Gas vs. dual fuel range?

10 years ago

Hi,

We are redoing our kitchen. It currently has a 30" cooktop and 24" wall oven, both gas. There's no electric line that can handle an electric oven (240V/30A). We're thinking about including a 36" range in the new design and wondering about sticking with all-gas or going dual-fuel. Would love to hear opinions! I have heard that electric ovens heat more evenly than gas, but here are other factors that I'd love to know about:

  • Self-cleaning is a must-have. Is either fuel source inherently better at self cleaning? I notice that Wolf and Viking don't offer self-clean in their 36" all-gas ranges.

  • Preheat speed is important. Which preheats faster? Do 36-inch ovens preheat much slower than smaller ones?

  • Reliability is important too. Is either type inherently more or less reliable?

  • We don't bake that much (mostly bread) but roast and oven-braise a lot. I understand that electric heat is drier than gas. What's better for roasting and braising?

  • Figure that we will need to have our electrical service changed (new box) anyway. Is there much difference in cost to put in the 240V/30A line? We live in a NYC pre-war apartment.

  • Finally, cost is a factor. We'll spend the extra ~$1500 for dual-fuel if it's worth it but all else being equal we'd rather not.

Brands I'm seriously considering are Wolf, Miele, Viking, Thermador, and Bertazzoni. Would love to hear any experiences with those brands regarding the above criteria. I have personal experience with Thermador (cooktop - very good but star burners are hard to clean) and Bosch (range - poor reliability).