Software
Houzz Logo Print
leslie_lala

Is this how it should look?

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

We are adding tile around our bathtub and this is what the corners look like. On the left side of the alcove bathtub, the tile goes all the way to the corner and a small piece of tile was stuck in to meet it (1st picture). On the right side, the tile doesn't go all the way to the wall, a small piece was used to try to fill it in but the corner is just filled with grout (2nd picture). When I said that I didn't like it, they said my walls were crooked and this was what I get. They went ahead and grouted. Is this what it's supposed to look like? I haven't seen any pictures that look like this.

Comments (29)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Not what it should like like.They did a poor job with the layout.Also,the changes in plane should not have been grouted but caulked.

    Leslie Lala thanked Precision Carpentry
  • 10 years ago

    Amateur hour. (So much for the vaunted "hire a professional" advice!)

    They should have started the layout at the other end with a cut tile so that both ends would have been symmetrical with equal cut pieces a little bigger than half a tile. There's usually a way to avoid these little scraps.

    Leslie Lala thanked rwiegand
  • 10 years ago

    It is hard to comment on layout without seeing a wider picture that shows both sides simultaneously, as well as knowing the pattern. So step back and take a bigger picture.

    I agree with PC though - I would be very concerned that they grouted the corner.

    Leslie Lala thanked bry911
  • 10 years ago

  • 10 years ago

    Thats no good, poor layout. They should have done as rwiegand states above. In additon to the no grout at changes of plane as also mentioned above. Is this a tub only, no shower, as I see noting giving the indication of waterproofing?

    Leslie Lala thanked millworkman
  • 10 years ago

    Big tile like that makes it kind of hard, but if I did it, I might choose a different spacing pattern; e.g., a full one in the middle, than a half on either side, then the remainder, which would get rid of the sliver.

    Leslie Lala thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    Are they finished? Are they going to leave the top edge unfinished like that?

    Leslie Lala thanked jellytoast
  • 10 years ago

    Tub only. Brand new with scratches and grout all stuck to it now. They picked out the decorative piece to go on top of the big tiles but said they can't cut it for the corners. They said it isn't bullnose (?) but chair rail. They picked it out!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    What do you guys think about the grout on the plane change between the tub and wall? I feel it will crack eventually, but I am not sure about caulking it either as it currently allows water in the grout to dry. Perhaps caulk just the plane change between the grout and tub where an eventual crack will form. Of course the wall corners should be caulked instead of grouted. Was any waterproofing done behind this tile job?

    Leslie Lala thanked Vith
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Nope. They had to cut out all of the drywall around tub to get it to fit. It is the same size as previous but harder to get in now with everything in there. It is just drywall and tiles above the tub.

  • 10 years ago

    It is time to fire them.

    Leslie Lala thanked bry911
  • 10 years ago

    Every time I ask about it, I'm met with excuses that my walls aren't straight and that I don't know construction. It's like I have to hire someone just to tell them they are doing it wrong. I had a flood from a cracked bathtub. Insurance hired these guys. I'm paying for tile additions around tub and on floor. They've redone the floor 4 times. The new shower door is crooked and then these bathtub surround tiles aren't right. I'm more stressed out about this than I was when I saw a waterfall out of my light fixture.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Talk to your insurance company and tell them that the work is not acceptable.You are paying insurance to be made "whole" after an occurance.This means you do not have to accept anything less than what you had before. There is more to it than that but that is the down and dirty version.

    You should be able to pick your own contractor within certain limits.

    Leslie Lala thanked Precision Carpentry
  • 10 years ago

    Agree with Precision Carpentry. Call your insurance company. There is no reason you have to accept substandard work on your home.


    Leslie Lala thanked jellytoast
  • 10 years ago

    Wall flatness has no bearing on tile layout with a single row. A wall being not flat would result in end tiles getting smaller and smaller (or bigger and bigger) as they went up the wall.

    This is a completely different issue. Instead of centering a tile on the center of the tub, they should have centered a grout line there. Then you'd have 2 full tiles (on either side of that center line) and 2 "just over 1/2 tile" tiles on the ends, butting into the corners. Voila, no slivers! Have them tear out the back wall tiles and install 4 new tiles.

    If you haven't fired them yet.

    Leslie Lala thanked weedyacres
  • 10 years ago

    Seeing how they couldn't install a single row of tile properly, it's no surprise that they don't know how to cut the trim pieces to fit in the corners.

    Leslie Lala thanked jellytoast
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    It is just drywall and tiles above the tub.

    Whole tile surround job needs to be ripped out considering zero waterproofing has been done behind the tile and it is a tub surround.

    Leslie Lala thanked Vith
  • 10 years ago

    "...walls aren't straight..."

    a) has nothing to do with anything in this instance

    b) walls are rarely straight; professionals have ways of dealing with this

    Leslie Lala thanked suzanne_sl
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Hire a contractor from the National Tile Contractors Asso. They have a 'find a contractor' link on their website. None of this is to the manufacturers' instructions, the TCNA guidelines, or the plumbing code. This is a complete re-do to the studs. Hope you can get your money back.

    Leslie Lala thanked Cabot & Rowe
  • 10 years ago

    Insurance hired these guys.

    Call the insurance company and tell them the work is unacceptable and you want an adjuster there within 48 hours. Point out that they work for you: that's what you paid for.

    Leslie Lala thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    I showed the manager this. She said that they put grout in and then caulk over the grout. Everything is perfect...the walls are bowed in the corner supposedly making it impossible for good tile placement. I told her I didn't like it and to fix it. They took out the small sliver on the right side and replaced it with a slightly larger sliver. They left the left side as is. It is much more noticeable now but a-ok to them. This is someone who received contractor of the year in this state. I don't get it. I have a meeting with her and the project manager in the morning.

  • 10 years ago

    There has to be enough caulk in the joint so that the caulk can flex. A thin layer over a grout joint seems a bit silly to me.

    I drew a picture for your contractor. Feel free to give it to them.

    Leslie Lala thanked bry911
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    EJ171 requires a non grouted , caulk filled joint at ALL changes of plane. These guys are blowing smoke up your....

    Time to stop fooling around with these guys. Write to the insurance company. Tell them the installation has fatal flaws which fly in the face of manufacturer instructions, TCNA guidelines and the plumbing code. They are legally obliged to install a properly built shower. You should accept nothing less.

    Leslie Lala thanked Cabot & Rowe
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I suspect that the real answer from the manager is - "We just do crappy work until homeowners call us on it and then we make up some B.S. about how we were going to do it in a better way because we understand exactly how it should be done since we are professionals".

    This is someone who received contractor of the year in this state. -

    Here we have a perfect example of what is wrong with both awards and reviews. Industry awards are typically given for size, name recognition and participation in associations, rarely are industry awards given for the quality of the work itself. Also, customers are probably the people who are least qualified to really give a referral. When customers refer or review a contractor they are very often basing them on things like communication, timeliness, cleanliness, and cost. Most customers simply aren't knowledgeable enough to evaluate quality (that is why they hired someone to do it in the first place).

    Take yourself for an example - a cosmetic issue led you here, but the cosmetic issue, as tragic as it is, is the least of your worries. There are a lot of other problems. Grout is porous and will absorb water and you have a grout line around the tub where water will be standing, once the grout becomes saturated for every drop of water that is absorbed from the front another drop will drip from the back of the grout line. Also, I don't see evidence of water proofing behind the tile, and while less important in a tub than a shower still should be there. Finally, I am not a huge fan of letting masking tape dry under grout. Grout is cement, it is not paint. You are not simply going to be able to pull up the masking tape when the grout dries, they will have to take a tool and chisel it out. If you are going to tape around a tub to grout you must remove the tape immediately after you are done.

    Once again - fire them. Don't give them a chance to explain, they had that. These guys are not capable of doing good work. They may be good and well meaning people, but they lack the knowledge to do a proper job.

    Leslie Lala thanked bry911
  • 10 years ago

    Who exactly awarded these people "Contractor of the Year"?

    Leslie Lala thanked jellytoast
  • 10 years ago

    I have no idea Jelly. No idea.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    "They've redone the floor 4 times." That says it all right there.

  • 10 years ago

    How's it going over there, Leslie? Did anything get resolved?