Software
Houzz Logo Print
sj_1028

Need help combining a climbing rose with clematis

10 years ago

I am new to flower gardening and am hoping to do quite a bit of perennial planting this spring. I'm located in South Minneapolis, zone 4. I have a "mostly sunny" east-facing wall of my garage that I'm hoping to cover with a combination of clematis and rose. The clematis variety I have in mind is Clematis Franziska Maria. The rose variety is New Dawn, a climber.

My question is how do I manage the two plants - which will likely intertwine and grow together over the summer - come fall? I'm guessing I will have to detach the New Dawn canes and bury them. But, the Clematis Franziska Maria is Prune type 2, meaning it'll bloom on old growth. How do I protect the rose, without damaging the old growth of the cleamtis?

Is there a "Pro tip" for this, or should I just plant my Clematis Franziska Maria elsewhere in my yard and choose a different clematis variety?

Comments (10)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    If you have to regularly maintain a climbing rose -- such as bringing canes down to be covered every Winter -- then you don't want a Type-2 clematis growing into it. A Type-2 climbing into a rose would work best when the rose provides a relatively permanent trellis-structure, such as if you were growing a climber in a warmer zone and didn't need to bury canes for Winter. You want a Type-3 clematis -- they are traditionally cut back hard every Spring, blooming on new wood. Among the Type-3s you'll find large-flowered kinds that look similar to the one you wanted with 'New Dawn'. You'll also find small-flowered Type-3s.

    I don't know where you're shopping for clematis, but do check out Brushwood Nursery. When you do an advanced search through their inventory for Type-3 clematis, click to show sold-out items as well. Even if you can't get what you want from them, their online inventory is extensive, and something they have sold-out could be found elsewhere.

    :-)

    ~Christopher

    Shaun Johnson thanked AquaEyes 7a NJ
  • 10 years ago

    I have a type III with a very big climber that doesn't get pruned every year. Other type IIIs with climbing roses I cut to the ground and pull out. The performance between the two situations is about the same quality.

    I would think with a type II you can just tip-and-nip what you can reach, and every third or fourth year or when performance declines, cut the Clematis to the ground and pull out all the clem-stems from the bottom. Performance won't be as spectacular as if you could thoroughly and precisely do type II pruning, but it will still be pretty great.

    Shaun Johnson thanked hoovb zone 9 sunset 23
  • 10 years ago

    Thank you Christopher for the recommendation on where to buy. So far, I've been buying most of my perennials from Bluestone, but Brushwood sounds like an excellent resource as well. Thanks to Hoovb too, I'm thinking as a new flower gardener, I might be better off taking it easy on myself the first couple years and finding a clematis that I can cut back entirely.

  • 10 years ago

    Shaun, I live in zone 4 as well and have been searching for the perfect combination as you are... :)

    New Dawn's thorns or hearing about them, has kept me away from her over the years. I remember someone said that they took her canes off the trellis, and layed them on the ground, placed some sticks of unwrapped Juicy Fruit gum on the ground to kill the mice, placed some straw over them, then a blanket, then cardboard then rocks to weight it all down. I think it would be easier than burying the canes, but don't know if it will work. Whatever you choose for clematis, you could cut it off at 2 feet BEFORE you take the canes down and then pull it out from the bottom, cutting it off as you go.

    I am still on the seach for a rose that will be cane hardy and bloom gorgeously all season!! :)

    Rebecca

    Shaun Johnson thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    Quadra is very hardy and could work beautifully.

  • 10 years ago

    There is an old Groucho Marx line, 'I refuse to join any club that would have me as a member'. There are a lot of northern rose growers that seem to buy a variation 'I refuse to grow any rose that would actually grow for me.' Forget New Dawn, and look at the Explorers. Either those or hardy once bloomers. Grow Quadra,

  • 10 years ago

    You picked out a lovely clematis, but if you want a type 3 that you can cut back, I would reccomend Warsaw Nike to go with New Dawn. I think they would make a lovely contrast, and you can cut it right back at the end of the season. I usually get 2 flushes and it was flowerIng for me into December. A really great plant.


  • 10 years ago

    I wonder if one of the old Albas might work better as a climber for this zone. You'd need one of the taller ones, like 'Alba Maxima' or one of similar habit. If you don't have to pull it down and cover it for Winter, you can keep a Type-2 clematis in there.

    Here, I notice that the clematis get kinda brittle by the end of Autumn, and moving them around will likely end up in snapping them. By Spring, parts that look dead will surprise me and leaf out, and I don't snip off dead tips until I KNOW they're dead -- by snipping off anything above the highest set of leaves that develop. With the Type-3s, you wouldn't have to worry about snapped stems if you're pulling down the rose to cover it for Winter -- you just snip them down low and let them start all over again. Of course, you don't HAVE to do that, if you want it going up a tree or something. But if you do this to a Type-2, you'll lose the early wave of blooms in Spring, which come on growth that went through Winter.

    I've ordered many plants from Bluestone Perennials and have yet to be disappointed. As long as you understand that they come small, you'll likely feel the same. But they're bursting out of their pots when they arrive, and really take off well for me. I try to take advantage of their frequent sales, including their 50-50 Fridays through Winter. Another source for perennials I've frequented is Joy Creek Nursery. They don't seem to have sales, but their normal prices are pretty good -- higher than Bluestone's sale prices, but lower than their regular prices. So when I'm shopping for perennials, I usually start with Bluestone sales, then go to Joy Creek for anything else I wanted but didn't get. Brushwood Nursery is my go-to for clematis -- and honeysuckle and passion flowers, whenever I get around to getting some.

    :-)

    ~Christopher

  • 10 years ago

    If you follow Christopher's advice to plant an alba instead of New Dawn I think Chloris would fit the bill. The pale pink color is very similar and Chloris grows tall enough, at least in my zone 5b in Sweden. It blooms only once, though.

    I've had bad luck with New Dawn but my present plant, my third attempt, is from an old garden that was planted in the 40'ies. So far this ND seems to be the best but doesn't grow very tall in my climate, to about 7 or 8 ft.