Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardev

Help - brown slime is winning

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

I'm having no luck fighting off this slime and fish tank smell.

My food grade buckets are almost completely light proof.

Every change out I wipe out the res with a papertowel and bleach. I also soak the air stone in a strong bleach solution. The roots get rinsed to remove as much slime as possible then soak in a bleach solution for 30 mins or so then thoroughly rinse again. I add some subculture b to the res and let that bubble for a while before adding nutes. Things are ok for a few days then they go to hell again. Am I missing something? Clearly the brown slime is finding its way back in. I'm using rockwool and Growstone in my net cups.


I have lettuce and chard growing in kratky. It's working great.

Comments (17)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    So you have slime in your dwc but not kratky?

    If that's the case what are the differences between them? Other than the air stone. Same temp, same water and nutes, etc? You using RO or tap water?

    Can you post a pic?

  • 10 years ago

    Kratky is starting to get a little bit of brown on the roots but it has been almost 6 weeks since I started it so that's more tolerable.

    Same brand of nutes, different concentrations. I use tap water.

    I just dumped the res and realized my initial post doesn't exactly describe the situation with this particular res. In this one the roots aren't even submerged in the solution yet and they still look healthy and white. However the res smells like an old sock and has brown "globs" (scientific nomenclature). This was inoculated with Subculture B.

  • 10 years ago

    Tough to say. It shouldn't smell bad. My reservoirs used to get that earthy kind of smell when I used Fox Farm's Microbe Brew and get a smell when I use sea kelp. My wife can tell when I dose my buckets with sea kelp, she hates the smell. I don't think it's bad so smelling "bad" is definitely subjective.

    Anyway, was the res bubbling good? My first thought is that maybe the water isn't oxygenated enough for the subculture b bacteria to survive. If they die it will smell. I made the mistake of turning off an air stone, actually forgetting to turn it back on from the manifold, once and in a couple days the bucket smelled rotten. Dead bacteria.

    Second thought is that if you're using tap water your chlorine levels in it may be high enough to kill the bennies you're adding. I always used a dechlorinater that I had for my fish tanks when I used to use tap water. It might not even be chlorine in the water supply but chloramine which takes a long time to gas off.

    How high was the EC or ppm? The higher the salts the less O2 the water can hold. And the higher the temperature of the solution the less O2 it can hold as well.

    I assume you mixed up the sub b really well until it dissolved? If I remember correctly it's kind of coarse granular.

  • 10 years ago

    I think it was bubbling really good. I will make short video of it later just to verify.

    I recently asked my city office for info on what is in the water. I couldn't find anything to suggest they use chloramine but I won't know for sure until they respond.

    Sadly I don't have an ec meter. In this case though I only had 1/5 of the recommended nute dosage.

    I didn't pre-mix the Subculture B I just toss it in the bucket. I assumed the bubbles did enough to mix it. Also, don't the bacteria die off after a while anyway?


    Thanks for all your help.

  • 10 years ago

    But doesn't aeration offgas all the chlorine? So if your tap water's chlorine is killing the bacteria, I think you can aerate it for a while before using it.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Chlorine vapes quickly. Chloramine can take weeks. I usually bubble for a few hours before I put my plants in. However I was adding a bit of subculture right away so even if most of it died at least it had the same chance as any competing microbes. Maybe that was a bad idea. Curious though as I understand they die off in a few days anyway due to lack of food and environmental conditions.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Here is a few clips of my bubbles.

    https://goo.gl/photos/byuqgEuj6CL5t2eN9

    I also had my air pumps on an old wooden bench that might have been slightly rotting due to spending several seasons outside.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Typing on my phone so this will be short. Bubbles look good. The bennies don't die off in a couple days. Some might due to competition or pH or temperature but they get food from the plant in the form of carbohydrates and some feed on carbon from dead organic matter that the roots slough off.

    Good chance your pump was pumping in tons of mold spores.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for responding hvg, I definitely slept better with that information. The second I read it I all but dropped my phone and ran to my grow area to move the rotten bench.

    If bennies get food from the plant roots won't adding them before roots are in the solution leave them to starve? Seems like this would cause problems particularly if a large quantity of microbes are added. Lots of guys starving - my res would be a tomb for bacillus subtilis.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I remember reading a story on another forum about a guy who was battling slime for over 6 months. He cleaned and sanitized and tried damn near everything and nothing worked until he finally realized he should check his water pump that had a filter. The filter and pump had tons of slime so it didn't matter what he did every time he fired his system back up he was pumping bad bacteria throughout it and no product he used could overcome that.

    I don't know if that caused the issue for you with your air pump but rotting wood that has been outside surely has tons of mold spores on it even if you can't see them and this is basically a process of elimination.

    Check the sub b package. It probably has something like molasses or sugar or kelp or humic acid or a combination of those. Some food is usually included with beneficials. Typically some type of sugar and/or carbon source. You're right though that they will die eventually once the food runs out it if they can't anything from the plant but most people are either adding more weekly or doing frequent water changes. Some will die, some will go dormant and even some cannibalization.

    As you know I don't do water changes and have some buckets that have been running for 6 months now with weekly additions of Hydroguard. If that's dying off on a regular basis it's not causing any issues. It's a single strain of bacteria and while I have done tons of research on that type stuff and read scientific articles and research that contain a lot of words I can't even pronounce all the inner working of that stuff is far above my head. Phosphorus based and sulfur based and even nitrogen based bacteria I imagine if they die can be broken down by others into usable elements for the plants or even other bacteria. I've read some stuff that indicates that but it's so complicated I just go with what works. Every time I learn something new it pushes something else out ; )

  • 10 years ago

    " I don't do water changes"

    I love that phrase. :)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Should be a bumper sticker to let people know you're not to be fkd with.

    *puts cigar out on arm* "I don't do water changes"

  • 10 years ago

    Subculture b contains a tiny fraction of npk sources and 1% sugar from glucose

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I was just thinking... What about the pump? It is probably tainted from sucking in all those evil microbes. Maybe I should spray some bleach near it so it can breath it in?

  • 10 years ago

    Nah. It probably has a little cloth filter located usually on the bottom if it's one of those aquarium pumps that you can take out and clean. I wouldn't be spraying anything that it will suck in that is corrosive....like bleach! ; )

  • 10 years ago

    It's actually a general hydroponics pump, at least my main one is.

  • 10 years ago

    i have a dwc floating raft in the greenhouse and too have root rot/slime with fishtank smell

    i put oof old roots, changes the water and now new roots are coming, lettuce and stem cabbage looks better now.. but how long :(

    im thinking to convert dwc table into flood and drain table with hydroton

Sponsored
Kuhns Contracting, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Central Ohio's Trusted Home Remodeler Specializing in Kitchens & Baths