Software
Houzz Logo Print
smeep_gw

A question about soil (or dirt)

10 years ago

Hi, we have several areas in our yard where the soil level is too low. Most are in planter beds, but one area is under part of our lawn. What can I add to fill in these areas?

In the past, at a different house, I've added "topsoil" purchased from Home Depot, but it was riddled with wood chips and other organics that broke down over time, resulting in the same low soil level again after a while. Is there any kind of just plain "dirt" I can add that won't decompose over time? Or is the solution to just repeatedly add soil with organic matter in it periodically until the base planter bed area has been raised?

I don't think I've articulated this well, but hopefully it makes some sort of sense. It just seems like if I stole soil from a different part of my yard, everything would be fine. However, when I add bagged soil purchased from a store, it seems to quickly break down and I'm back to the low soil level, where ineffective drains stick up over the soil. Is this just the nature of healthy soil? The volume decreases as organics get used, and so more organics need to be worked in each year?

Thanks!

Comments (17)

  • 10 years ago

    It just seems like if I stole soil from a different part of my yard, everything would be fine.

    That's what I do.


  • 10 years ago

    Well, but then there's not enough soil over there...

  • 10 years ago

    I usually get a 1/2 yard (all my little truck can haul) about every other year to top 6 4x8' beds then till it in with a mini tiller. It's usually a vege mix that has some compost in it. Alternate years I mix in my own compost, and find goat manure on freecycle or nextdoor. Yeah, it breaks down, but that means there's some good sh** in that soil! Nancy

    smeep thanked nancyjane_gardener
  • 10 years ago

    As tox said soil is composed of the mineral (the sand, silt, and clay) particles and organic matter, A good soil mix would be about 95 percent mineral and 5 percent organic matter. Many times people will tell you to buy some "topsoil" without telling you what hey mean by that. Perhaps this article might help some.

    http://msue.anr.msu.edu/news/the_shocking_truth_about_topsoil

    Several things happen when you plunk down soil someplace. In the process of moving that soil you entrain air into that soil and as that air is released the soil will "shrink". If the soil has organic matter mixed in as that is digested by the Soil Food Web, and no more organic matter is added, the soil will "shrink".

    If the level of soil drops to its original level you may have a sink hole there.

    kimmq is kimmsr

    smeep thanked kimmq
  • 10 years ago

    One thing my parents like to do -- they bury leaves in a certain spot, then put dirt over it. Yes the leaves will break down over time, and you might still end up with a small hole or unleveled area, but they just do it again and again. However, they are not doing it just to level up an area.

    The side advantage is that you also end up with a very nice and soft area for planting after a year or two. It basically amounts to trench composting.



  • 10 years ago

    What you do is call up your local landscapers and ask how much they charge for a yard of topsoil + delivery, To give you an idea of how much you need, a 1/2 yard is about a pickup trucks worth. Depending on your area, they might also have a mixture of soil, sand, and gravel that would sell for a lot cheaper. Anything would work, except for stuff that would decompose, so see what they have. In my area a gravely/sand mixture sells for a lot cheaper. Topsoil is 30-40$ a yard here. Horticulturaly speaking, our topsoil here is generally better then the stuff you can buy in bags, because they premix it.


    All soil will sink overtime, maybe in about a month. Sand gravel mixture wont sink as much, theoretically you would use less. In any event, you do have to build it up above the grade to allow for sinkage.


    Pro tip, buy a cheap 10$ tarp and lay it down for them to dump onto.


  • 10 years ago

    Fastink. What do you mean by "topsoil"? Define "topsoil".

    http://msue.anr.msu.edu/news/the_shocking_truth_about_topsoil

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    kimmq, what are you trying to get at? Just spit it out.

  • 10 years ago

    Fastink, My question is pretty clear.

    What do you mean by "topsoil"

    Define "topsoil".

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    People that have a problem defining "topsoil" are simply repeating bad advice they have heard from someone that really does not know what they are talking about.

    "Topsoil" is defined as the top 6 to 12 inches of soil from someplace and that might be sand, clay, or maybe (not often) loam. The soil I have to work with is sand and most of the soil along the Lake Michigan shoreline is sand. My sister has clay for soil, 6 miles west of me and in a streak of clay soil.

    There is a company here that dredges the accumulated organic matter from the bottom of one of the lakes, mixes that with sand, and sells it. One landscape company here buys this mix of sand and organic matter and sells it as "topsoil" and it is not, but they can because there is no law that prevents it.


    If you are going to advise someone to buy soil be more specific that simply saying buy "topsoil".

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    And yet that sand + organic sediment material would probably work fine for filling a low spot in a lawn. As would topsoil scraped off a nearby development site, or topsoil in a bag from the store. It's a hole in the lawn, not rocket science.

  • 10 years ago

    As long as people understand that when buying "topsoil" they are not getting anything other than any other soil.

    kimmq is kimmsr

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks everyone for all the information and an interesting discussion! It seems so obvious now, but it never occurred to me that I needed to keep replacing the organics that get used up over time.

  • 10 years ago

    Glad to be of some help. I hope our little side debates don't get in the way too much.

    Regarding 'topsoil', kimmq, when someone says they will just move some topsoil from another part of their yard, do you insist that they define what that means? Maybe you should really start doing that so there is no confusion about what it is. :-P

  • 10 years ago

    'It just seems like if I stole soil from a different part of my yard, everything would be fine.'

    I think that's what you should do.

    Bought soil is not usually soil at all, but a man-made pile of rubbish with a lot of sand in it. Then they call it sandy loam. I wouldn't waste my time or energy on it.

  • 10 years ago

    There is a difference, Tox, between someone moving some soil from one part of the yard to another and someone offering advice on a gardening forum. You frequently tell people to buy "topsoil" and I have asked you to define "topsoil". You have not done that indicating that either you do not know what "topsoil" is or just don't believe it matters. I have posted several links to articles that tell us what ":topsoil" is but you apparently have not read, and learned from, them.

    If someone is to purchase soil for a garden why on earth would one not tell them to get the best stuff they can? Why not describe just what they should be looking for rather than some meaningless term as "topsoil"? The suppliers of soil will not always provide us with what we really need unless we demand it of them.

    I learned a long time ago that what is often sold as "topsoil" is not what one would want in the garden.

    kimmq is kimmsr