Software
Houzz Logo Print
coops905

Modern kitchen cabinet sources

10 years ago

We are going to be redoing our Miami kitchen next year. Looking to do the sleek modern white lacquer slab style that works well in Florida, maybe with some walnut cabs mixed in.

We have done a similar kitchen in Ikea in the past, and while very happy with it, we plan to stay in this house for a long time and have the cash - so we'd like to go up in budget to get some of the benefits of, well, a more expensive kitchen cabinet.

Having researched Ikea cabinets, I know that the immediate next step or two up budget wise don't get me any major benefit over Ikea (Home Depot, Porcelanosa, etc).

So I'm potentially willing to spend a lot for top of the line cabinets (to get some real benefit over Ikea and ilk). But I also recognize there is probably a point where I'm spending extra money but not getting any additional value. For instance, our space is a typical Florida open concept condo so while I want the option to do some "custom" stuff, I anticipate our needs will be pretty basic. I'm thinking a 10-foot long run of only-lower cabinets abutted by a 5 foot run of fridge and pantry, then a simple island with maybe 6 feet of cabinets. So no funky molding, or custom sizing issues, or wine shelves or other open shelves, no curved walls, or problems to work around. Also, the whole point of the sleek modern look is simplicity, right?

I presume at some point, all the high end cabinet makers (let's call these the $$$ and $$$$ companies) are using the same materials and hardware and offer similar inserts, but what features are the $$$$ ones throwing in that justify their higher costs versus the $$$ ones? And do I need those extra features for the above-described space?

So of all the cabinet companies that offer modern kitchen lines, what are some of the "best" cabinets I can get where I'm not paying more than an equally good competitor? Or to put another way, what are some of the "cheaper" ($$$) modern cabinetmakers where there are no compromises on quality relative to the $$$$ makers?

Comments (11)

  • 10 years ago

    Here's a previous post that mentions a couple higher end brands..

    http://ths.gardenweb.com/discussions/2951699/help-on-cabinet-approach-selection

  • 10 years ago

    Poggenpohl, Siematic, Bulthaupt

  • 10 years ago

    Hi, We just remodeled using Kraftmaid gloss cabinets from Lowes called Merrill. Love them! However, if money was no object, I would have went to Henrybuilt cabinets and thegalley.com for a sink. I love the use of modern and function with as many drawers as possible, too!


  • 10 years ago

    Bellmont 1900 (not 1600), Durasupreme, and Brookhaven/Wood-Mode are also candidates.

  • 10 years ago

    I notice that I posted on the thread to which anitamo linked, but I also wanted to comment that I ended up with Bellmont 1900 (at a much lower price point - about half - than Pedini, Poggenpohl and Alno, which I also priced)

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks everyone. So for those who ended up with lower price point cabinets (bellmont 1900, Kraftmaid, etc) did you feel you got identical quality and craftsmanship to the higher end lines? Or did you justify some reduction in quality because the price was so much lower? What trade offs were there with the cheaper cabinets?

  • 10 years ago

    The Bellmont cabinets are nice, but they're not Pedini or Poggenpohl in quality. (If they were, why would anyone buy Pedini or Poggenpohl?). They don't feel quite as "substantial", and I don't think the hardware is as good. But again, we paid $15,000, and the initial estimate we got for Pedini (before all the tweaking), was $26,000 - and it would have been quite a bit higher to get something identical to what we did get

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I was at an open house this weekend with a beautiful modern kitchen. They had Pedini cabinets, and I must say I was impressed. There were big drawers, filled with pots and pans, that must have been 4' wide but still opened and closed perfectly smooth and straight, like butter! The lines were incredibly clean, too.

  • 10 years ago

    SJHockfan - and that gets to the heart of my question! We have the cash and plan to be in this kitchen for a long time, so I definitely want a top quality product. I just don't want to pay extra cash for the super high end product if it's technically no better than the semi-high end product. But I think I definitely want something "high end". But I have also heard that, say, Pedini is quite a bit cheaper than Poggenpohl or Balthup. Are Poggenpohll or Balthup significantly better quality than Pedini? Just trying to get to the heart of "how high do I have to go to get a top-quality product without unnecessarily throwing money away"!

  • 10 years ago

    We are not cabinet experts, but we thought Pedini were every bit as nice and high quality (in function, design, hardware, and craftsmanship) as the other high-priced [German] cabinet lines, like Poggenpohl, Alno, Bulthaup and Siematic. But we didn't get into the nitty-gritty, because we decided we weren't going in that direction. If I were staying in my home "forever", I'd go with the higher-priced, higher-quality lines.

  • 10 years ago

    My experience with Kraftmaid was awesome, however, we had to have our carpenter do modifications to the fillers and overlays to make them all flush. I think that if money is no object then you just go with the best look you want. Plywood is plywood, but door finish, drawers, inserts, etc do matter when all is said and done. We use a drawer practically for everything and it is so nice (ex. all flour/sugar is in a deep drawer...we never have to pick the canister up). Another cabinet co. I liked but was too expensive had slab doors with glass and the tinted foil under the glass, which would be really nice for clean up and if it broke, just replace glass front (I don't know the co. name). This is our kitchen and we had to work within budget and space and existing hookups: (our fridge will be flush when we get new one; kitchen is not all done):

    lighting · More Info


    lighting · More Info