Software
Houzz Logo Print
jeff_al

a different approach - pruning oak trees (photos)

10 years ago

stopped the other day to take a few photos of these trees in auburn, al. i don't think i have ever seen oak trees manicured like this. i watched the crew prune them with motorized pole saw pruners (before they leafed out) and speculated that they will have to keep this up in perpetuity in order to keep them within range of the pruners, unless they bring in a bucket truck in the future. just thought it was interesting but not something i would do. in fact, i don't really care for it. i was having thoughts about walking around in stepford or something akin to that where everything must be perfect.

i asked a forester about it and he said he would not recommend this approach, voicing concern that the many wounds on the branches could increase opportunities for a vector to transmit a disease. he described them as looking "unnatural and a bit too urban" (even though everything else on the grounds except for the birches are tightly pruned in this urban setting).
do you like them? do you see this technique used often, or at all, on large tree species?








Comments (7)

  • 10 years ago

    I agree with that forester that it does look "unnatural and a bit too urban". But I guess A lot of people like that look.

  • 10 years ago

    are they under the power lines??? .. ken

  • 10 years ago

    Kind of weird, and completely unnecessary of course. Mostly agree with the forester-many, many entry points for oak wilt or what have you. And like you (OP) say, this will have to be carried forward indefinitely. Not something I would want to take on.....and for so limited a payoff.

  • 10 years ago

    Since they are leaving stubs, and because this non-targeted pruning will result in many new dormant buds a-breaking, in time there will be a shell of green surrounding a maze of dead sticks on the interior. No different really than when shrubs get sheared year after year-the types of shrubs that should never be sheared-and in time, the interior is all dead stuff and all the life is on a thin layer on the outside. This is just more man-controls nature BS in my book, should anyone care to read. And yes, there may be power lines above, but I bet everybody here knows what the proper solution to that would have been. Don't plant oak trees-or other tall-growers-in that location!

  • 10 years ago

    Ugh.

    Twenty years ago it was fairly easy to find a good tree trimmer- I had a guy in Florida who was a true artist and made some of the most beautifully shaped trees I have ever seen.

    Now this.

    Health aside, I am not a fan of cookie cutter shapes and rows of soldiers- IMO it robs the trees of all their character.

  • 10 years ago

    For me, it's not any rows-of-soldiers thing; These trees follow a straight stretch of road and a non-linear pattern might actually look less "natural" and more contrived IMO. It's just such an unnecessary treatment of "the wrong plants in the wrong place". Nor do I really see the role of the arborist as "shaping" trees. I think trees tend to do a very good job of that all by themselves. There are however some important structural things that can be done with young trees to make them last longer in the landscape (leader training, subordination pruning), and there are safety and just general crown-cleaning activities that can be justified later in the trees' lives. This isn't Europe and we don't tend to do some of the rather bizarre things to trees they do over there, but this harkens to that mindset just a bit.