I think if you read through you'll find that no one likes any of the them. Are you sure you have to put the range in the island? Maybe post your floor plan on the kitchen forum and they can help you create a better plan where the range is not on the island and they'll explain why it's probably the worst place for a range. :)

Most can't be installed with a range. The Faber family is an exception but that requires some special planning cabinet and counter wise. The Faber units are ok...but never as good as an overhead hood.