Software
Houzz Logo Print
old_home_lover

Saving 142 Year Old Entry Doors

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

Madera Mansion · More Info

Madera Mansion · More Info

Madera Mansion · More Info

Madera Mansion · More Info

Madera Mansion · More Info

Madera Mansion · More Info

Madera Mansion · More Info

Madera Mansion · More Info

Madera Mansion · More Info

Madera Mansion · More Info

I am posting a lot of pics here. These are the entry doors on our 1875 home. They have a wood veneer that is warping and peeling away from the solid core. A significant amount of decorative wood filigree has fallen off in pieces (many saved). Panels have shrunken and there are significant gaps that we had to cover with plastic and painters tape for winter.

Our hope is to save not just the doors but the veneer as well. I'm confident we can get the panels out and reglue then reset them. It appears they are held in with trim. I am wondering if anyone has any advice on the veneer. I was hoping perhaps considering its thinness, it could be thoroughly rehydrated with boiled linseed oil, slowly flattened back out, gently sanded, treated with penetrating epoxy, and put back on the door. As for the filigree, similar steps? Or is there somewhere I could go to get it replaced based on what I have of it still?

To be clear, I am not interested in perfect doors, just doors that are brought back as best we can and treated so as to not deteriorate further.

Comments (21)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I hate to say it, but those are 1900-1915 doors. If that makes any difference in your decision-making process.

    That said, they can be completely repaired for more or less money. If you want everything to be recreated in wood, it will be to the "more" side.

    Casey


    old_home_lover thanked Sombreuil
  • 10 years ago

    Also, the oval panes are held in with trim, but it's become "gappy" and there is some debris in the frame of them. Should the panes be removed and the frames cleaned up to set them in better? Is there any kind of glazing process for this or is it normally just the pane in wood trim? It looks to me like there was something inside holding it in place.


  • 10 years ago

    Strange. They match all of the woodwork and doors throughout the house. Would someone really have replaced solid wood doors and mantles 25 years after building?

  • 10 years ago

    The only thing I would look to outsource would be the filigree. But I'm not sure what kind of place to even ask about such a task.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    "Would someone really have replaced solid wood doors and mantles 25 years after building?"

    It's possible. The 2nd owners, who were also very wealthy, decided to remodel.

    After you have those doors all cleaned up they need a drink of resin. Smith's CPES is my vote. Then six or so coats of Le Tonkinois # 1 marine varnish on the exteriors.

    How big is this house?

    old_home_lover thanked sambah006
  • 10 years ago

    It's 3600 sq ft. The way we're utilizing the rooms it will have 7 bed/2 ½ bath. There's an original house then what was a servants quarters built on the back. The main house has a couple of finished attic rooms as well but we aren't considering that as part of it. May make one a sewing room and the other an art room at some point. The builder was a founder of the area and his daughter stayed here with her husband until the fifties when she passed. Next owners were weekenders who extensively remuddled. We've peeled a lot of that away and this year our goal is to weatherize before another winter hits. So doors and windows restored are a high priority as the wind just pours through them now.

  • 10 years ago

    Thank you for the appliqué links!

  • 10 years ago

    " and treated so as to not deteriorate further." That will be a real challange. I would strongly consider having new doors built while putting diy energy into other areas of home.

    old_home_lover thanked klem1
  • 10 years ago

    I tend to agree, I feel like it is a really huge job to restore those doors properly and while it can be done, it would take a considerable amount of time. It's possible it is worth doing, but only you can decide compared to the rest of the work to be done.


    My suggestion would see if you could order a pair to fit as a temporary measure. It depends on the opening size, but maybe there's a chance a 'stock' set of fiberglass entry door would work in the existing opening and not look too terrible and not cost too much while you work on restoring the doors.

    old_home_lover thanked kats737
  • 10 years ago

    So we have several projects that are on hold because they are dependent on some third party scheduling. I am feeling the days of good weather slipping away and I want to do the door however difficult. Worst case scenario, I wind up having to pay to have them redone any way. took to a small patch of the veneer with sandpaper just to see how bad it was and the blackish grime (old stain bubbling out?) comes away like butter. I'll post pics ;)

  • 10 years ago

    It will be interesting to see how this transpires. I think I've seen projects like this on This Old House. Any local historical societies to ask for references?

    I agree with kats, how about a good enough door replacement while they old doors find their path of rehab? Then you'd have some weather proofing and they won't deteriorate more.


  • 10 years ago

    These look too far gone for proper rehab. I would salvage and use inside as a decorative element or repurpose. Ther is some amazing architectural salvage to be found out there that will work for your entrance and be in better condition. A solid wood door might be worth the effort but for veneer with missing appliqué this will be an expensive restore that ultimately may not be worth the $$.

  • 10 years ago

    My thoughts exactly. Maybe if it were origional on a famous home it would make sense to restore.

  • 10 years ago

    I've sanded one door and treated with linseed oil/mineral spirits mix. I removed the remaining appliqué since it will be easy enough to replace.

    The veneer has become more pliable and is no longer brittle feeling. It can be pressed flat against the core now. The wood grain has swelled a bit after a couple of coats but I had planned to sand again after it dries anyway.

    Once the BLO is completely dry, I'll remove the door, use some Ultra-Cat veneer glue under the lower veneer, clamp a couple of 2X10 chunks down over it, and let it dry. Meanwhile I'll use Abatron epoxy to fill the gaps where necessary. Then sand the whole thing, add new appliqué, prime, paint, cure, rehang.

    Am I missing something essential in this list? Because I can't see how that is going to be more time consuming and/or expensive than locating salvaged replacement doors that happen to fit this opening as well as the top and bottom slide bolt settings in the frame, and do not need any refinishing of their own.

  • 10 years ago

    It sound's like we should be taking notes and learning from you rather than offering you opinions and advice. Are you useing this piticular glue because of it's ability to work with oil saturated material? Will you be useing same glue to adheare the decorative appliques? The process you are useing sound's interesting but filling and glueing material saturated in blo is what I'm most curous about.

  • 10 years ago

    This particular glue is for exterior thick veneers and is rated to hold when there is high tension as in sharp curves. A frequent user suggested that he has had success with oiled wood by brushing the surface to be glued with Acetone prior to bonding.

    Since I asked specifically about using BLO on the veneer in the OP and no one answered - instead opining that the doors weren't worth saving - I sought advice elsewhere. I am sure many folks here know more about the process than I do, but since those folks weren't answering the questions asked I'll just do my best and post the pics.

  • 10 years ago

    Well once you spends countless hours on rehabbing your doors consider Waterlox Marine (both sealer and oil finish) it's top shelf. Or look at Epiphanes Marine finish. The UV damage is apparent in the photos and these products will do the work to withstand it next time around.

  • 10 years ago

    old_home,you might not realize what you threw on the table for discussion when you said ,"To be clear, I am not interested in perfect doors, just doors that are brought back as best we can and treated so as to not deteriorate further." If you tell me your field of expertise,I'll give you a similar challange but as an example,try this. After laying out circumstances of running afoul of the law compariable in degree of seriousness to your door,someone say's, I'm not interested in a perfect defense,just one i can put on as best I can so as I don't have any farthur problems. There are few if any responses to that might make that op happy. Baking cookies,fishing,cutting your own hair or you name it,questions can be composed that leave people shaking their head or advising to change plans.

  • 10 years ago

    "I'm not interested in a perfect defense,just one i can put on as best I can so as I don't have any farthur problems. There are few if any responses to that might make that op happy."

    Are you suggesting that there are not different degrees of security assurance? That there is just "leave your doors wide open day and night" or "sitting in your fortress surrounded by armed guards?"

    One of my 'fields of expertise' would be research and I promise you there are many levels of intensity that can be reached in a research capacity. Were you to say for instance, "I need to know who owned this property in 1850, but I don't need to know everyone who lived on the premises, just the title holder" I could do that. Or if you wanted to know everyone who had held any title to any of the land or subsurface, who held easements, what court disputes had involved ownership, what banks had held mortgages, and who freed the slaves that previously worked the land, I could do that too. But if you asked "who owned it in 1850" I wouldn't respond that the land wasn't worth what the owner was asking and tell you not to bother buying it, because although it might showcase my extensive knowledge in my field of expertise, it wouldn't be addressing your question.

  • 10 years ago

    I am looking forward to seeing how the doors come out.

    old_home_lover thanked Kippy