Software
Houzz Logo Print
mountainy_man_z8_ireland

"Name that Hosta"

Today I went grocery shopping and in Aldi (don't know if you have Aldi that side of the pond, its a German supermarket chain) I found a shelf of hostas. and had a good rummage and picked out 6 plants 2 each of 3 varieties, the labels made me laugh they were a mess not one correct.

I think I know what they are but I'd like your opinion on them please.

Ok no.1 Both labeled Hyacinthina.

Very shiny above and below.

Some red on her legs.

5 vein pairs, rippled leaf.


No.2 Both labeled Francee

10 vein pairs.


No.3. one labeled sieboldiana the other Aureomarginata

Cream edge turning white, leaves tending to cup slightly.

10 vein pairs




I know these could be harboring HVX and will remain in potted isolation wards ect. ect.


I don't want to say yet what my guesses are in case it influences what you are thinking.

Thanks for playing Name that Hosta.

Denis

Comments (20)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    We have Aldi stores all over the states. I saw hostas in the ad this week. Haha!

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked mybrownthumbz6
  • 10 years ago

    Denis, is the first one a young Irish Luck? I don't own one - yet, so it's just a guess. Something about one of the others seem familiar but I can't put my finger on it. Maybe a young Liberty?

    They would have come home with me too had I that opportunity! Nice plants and nice leaf shots. :-)


    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked josephines167 z5 ON Canada
  • 10 years ago

    The first could be Invincible? The 2nd possibly Sagae?

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked peren.all Zone 5a Ontario Canada
  • 10 years ago

    1 is not Invincible or Irish Luck - see the red on the petioles? Neither has red petioles. Also both Invinclible and Irish Luck have thin leaves. That one appears to be thick.

    Number 2 reminds me of Pizzazz.

    bk


    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked bkay2000
  • 10 years ago

    Number 3 reminds me of a Wide Brim leaf. Here is mine a couple of years ago. As you can see the margin width was quite variable.

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked Barb Ure Drouillard 6b Canada
  • 10 years ago

    Interesting suggestions everyone, thanks.

    My own guesses are:

    1 Raspberry Sorbet. Yes leaves are thick and rubbery, I had discounted Irish Luck just on the basis of it being still quite expensive here in Euroland. I am not familiar with Invincible so I did not know it had red on the pets, I seem to remember reading that Invincible was a slug magnet, this suggests thin leaves, yes/no?

    2 First Frost. I am 80% certain of this one, I got one in the same shop last year, It is not unfurled as yet so will compare later on.

    3 Wide Brim, Barb is on the same wavelength as myself.

    Guesses based on commonly available cheap hostas and gut instinct.

  • 10 years ago

    Here is my First Frost in May.

    And here it is in August

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked hostas_for_barb
  • 10 years ago

    Both Raspberry Sorbet and Invincible have leaves of average substance. Both are shiny on the surface and underside but RS would be whitish shiny on the underside. The leaves of RS at maturity would be 7" x 3 3/4" and the mound would be 12"x 34" Invincible would have leaves 8" x 6" with a mound size of 20" x 48". I have no slug damage but it is considered moderately susceptible. This info is from the Hostapedia.

    The scapes and flowers of each would be very different so you will certainly know then if it is either. All three are very nice!

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked peren.all Zone 5a Ontario Canada
  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for that info, This one is not whitish on the underside, does that change with age/maturity? RS and I have the same substance, so now I'm with you leaning towards Invincible but I'm just gonna have to wait until it flowers arn't I.

    Thanks again, I'll come back here when it flowers and bring this full circle.

  • 10 years ago

    They're both nice. I hope they wind up being HVX free and can't wait to see them all grown up.

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked stephanie_h12
  • 10 years ago

    Hopefully someone that has RS will be able to say if the whitish back is present on a young plant. They are both great plants so either way you will have another beauty. I really look forward to updates! Thank you!

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked peren.all Zone 5a Ontario Canada
  • 10 years ago

    I'm with bk on No. 2. I thought of Pizzazz too. Looks like my NOID which I was coming to the conclusion is a Pizzazz. Here's a photo from last year. Yours and mine both have that wavy edge.

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked newhostalady Z6 ON, Canada
  • 10 years ago

    Newhostalady, I never even thought about Pizzazz and I missed the suggestion in Bkay's post, sorry Bkay I must need new glasses, it does look very similar, First Frost kinda undulates but not rippled like Pizzazz. ye have put the cat among the pigeons lol, I will scour the net for pics of a young Pizzazz, thanks.

  • 10 years ago

    Nice looking plants, Denis! Hope they all do well for you. Plant I'd is not one of my strong points, I'm still learning in that area.

    Sherry

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked sherrygirl zone5 N il
  • 10 years ago

    Thanks Sherry, as you can see from this thread its not one of mine either lol.

  • 10 years ago

    The first hosta looks too thick to be Invincible, too thick and not ruffled enough for Irish Luck. Raspberry Sorbet is a good guess. The leaves look the exact shape of mine.

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked Eleven
  • 10 years ago

    I'll post some updated pics tomorrow, it has got a bit more ruffled but not a lot bigger, I would be interested to hear what you think of it as it is now, thanks.

  • 10 years ago

    Here's a Raspberry Sorbet for comparison. A small hosta, maybe 10 inches across for me (about 25.5 cm for you European folk).

    mountainy man z8 Ireland thanked Eleven
  • 10 years ago

    Eleven, some of us rebels still keep the old ways and still use imperial measurements lol.

    So here is the NOID I have two of them. They have been in full sun so a little lighter in colour than yours, they have not flowered yet and that will seal it but looks like a pretty good match to me.