Software
Houzz Logo Print
travelerok

Building home questions

10 years ago

Hello all. I'm going through a custom builder that is going to create their own hoa. I would really love some help with deciding. To add to the fun, it's such a new area, nothing is marked yet and no digging had started yet on any home or road.


The land the builder chose has a few ponds with fish, not a retention pond. Will resell be an issue if I backed up to one of the ponds.


Are there any issues to expect living next to a pond? There is a walking trail behind the house so there would be a little space before too much rain.


I read some stuff about seeing if the builder is going to maintain the ponds but that applied to water Run off ponds. Is there anything I should ask if the builder should be responsible for? I'm not sure they can maintain a pond with live fish but I'm not sure either way.


Many thanks! !

Comments (16)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    A more important question I would ask is: What are the bylaws of the HOA? After hearing about the experiences of other people and friends belonging to these groups, I vowed to never buy a property that was subject to the whims of my neighbors....and I haven't. I'm not one of those people who are insistent that I can do anything I want on my property, but I don't need people limiting my choices on what color I can paint my house,or telling me how tall my grass can get, or whether and where I can plant a particular plant on my property.

    I think I am able to be a good neighbor without having some busybodies meddling. I know some folks like HOAs because they prefer the houses to all look pretty similar or because it protects them from people who could be a problem for the neighborhood, but I prefer to take my chances. Unfortunately, too often, some people who get elected to an HOA are those with too much time on their hands and who spend it trying to wield power over others. No thanks.

    As for the pond, I would not go into this with the expectation that the builder will have any responsibility after the homes are sold. And, even if it were so, you can't be sure the builder will be in business next year. As for resale of a home backing up to a pond, it would be a mixed blessing. Some people would like the feature, while others, particularly those with young children, would see it as a hazard and look elsewhere.

  • 10 years ago

    The pond - find out if the property is within the 100 year flood zone.

    If not, a nearby pond is sellable to many, but as kudzu notes, not usually to families with small children.

    I agree with kudzu about HOAs - find out the bylaws now. If this is all very new, there may not be many, yet -- I'd seriously hesitate. My brother lived in one that regulated how many hours a single car could be parked in the driveway - making it difficult for out of state relatives or friends to stay and visit. Bleah.

  • 10 years ago

    That would be my concern as well; mosquitos.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    We're building on water so before we bought the property, we looked at a few things. As others have posted, find a 100 year flood plain map from your state DEQ to see if you're in the flood plain. Check trees close to the pond to try to determine high water marks. Get a soil survey performed. They'll come in with an excavator and dig down until they hit water. You'll be able to see how deep you can dig a basement, what kind of drainage the substrate will provide, and some times, what to expect from excessive rain. Also the DEQ will tell you what the building setbacks (minimum distance to water line) are so you know where you can put your house in proximity to the water. It's a wetland, so there will be restrictions. They'll also tell you about shoreline improvements and what permitting is required. If it's a big enough pond, look to see where the property line is. If it ends in the water, you'll have what's called "riparian rights" but the HOA might have deed restrictions on how many docks can be built per number of lots on the shore.

    About the HOA, find out what the deed restrictions are like. They can be a huge pain in the butt, so see if it's worth it to you. Also see if they HOA will be maintaining the pond with respect to aquatic plant control and mosquito control. Pay special attention to fencing deed restrictions, street setbacks, since you might be sandwiched between the wetland and the street setbacks, garage facing limitations, exterior building limitations, and vehicle parking limitations,

  • 10 years ago

    My son's house is in a 100 year flood plain. He pays 3 times more for his homeowner's insurance, plus by federal law, he has to have flood insurance provided by FEMA to the tune of an additional $78.00 per month on top of his regular insurance. All that for a 700 square foot house on a 25 x 75 lot. Something to think about.

  • 10 years ago

    Wow, I appreciate all the help. I was glad to hear input on where to start. The 100 year flood plan may be common knowledge and now it will be for me, but I didn't know that it existed on the web so easily accessible. I found that it is in the .2% annual chance flood zone. The other one on the map is 1% flood chance which is not near the property.

    I talked with the builder who said he was going to invest 500k alone in the water run off system and curbing. Though established ponds, he is going to use them as water retention ponds from the rains.

    Suru11, do you know what zone he falls under? Was he in the 1% annual flood zone? Is it a higher percent? Just curious.

  • 10 years ago

    "I talked with the builder who said he was going to invest 500k alone in the water run off system and curbing. Though established ponds, he is going to use them as water retention ponds from the rains."


    Is he willing to put that into writing and within a certain time frame? Even if he does put it in writing there is still no guarantee it will happen.


    "Though established ponds, he is going to use them as water retention ponds from the rains."


    Then they will not be ponds but essentially sumps?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    If it were me, I would check with the local water and sewer department to see what they have to say about this development. What the builder is touting as an "investment" may simply be nothing more than what he is being required to do by local and environmental officials to make marginal land buildable.

  • 10 years ago

    Well, it was an old 9 hole golf course that's been around since the 50s recently going out of business in the past few years. And that could be true about having to do this work in order to make it to code.

    And after he mentioned it was going to be runoffs to the ponds, it did take away being an ideal location by a little. As millworkman said, potentially a sump in the long run.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I would do absolutely nothing until I saw: 1) the plat map for the project showing all improvements; 2) the type of ownership--fee simple, condo, etc., 3) the design for all houses, especially the one you are interested in. I would also talk to the local building authority to find out what sorts of approvals will be required, anticipated schedule, requirements for bond postings for needed improvements. Builders come and go, frequently with little or no warning. All that's required is a filing of bankruptcy. This is not a project nor the time to jump blindly into something. Do your due diligence!

  • 10 years ago

    TravelerOK - my son's house is in a Zone A - 1% zone. When he bought the house 6 years ago, he was told that FEMA was reevaluating the flood zone because of flood control improvements made by the city he lives in. 6 years later and FEMA has still not got around to this and he still has to pay for the extra flood insurance. What's ironic is he lives in California and his area is in a severe drought. :-)

  • 10 years ago

    I know someone has to go first but I am not sure it would. be me.. does the builder have funding or just a dream? Good luck

  • 10 years ago

    Wow crazy Suru11.


    Builder has funding and said plots would be marked in 30-60 days. Though I want a specific plot, I won't be the first because of trying to sell house first. He's also willing to hold a plot without money until he marks the land so I could back out or choose another one.

  • 10 years ago

    I'm on Nextdoor and as such and privy to the problems a lot of other neighborhoods have. One of the neighborhoods has some homes built on canals stocked with fish. The neighborhood isn't gated. Some of the people who back up to the canals are complaining about youth trespassing on their property to go fishing even if they have a fence. Before you purchase land backing up to the pond look up the legal term "attractive nuisance" and find out how it applies in your jurisdiction. Once you read that you may reconsider altogether.

  • 10 years ago

    Tcufrog, that makes a lot of sense and I learned a new law term but this property doesn't back up on the pond. It's divided by a walking trail right behind. So, that would cut my liability since I couldn't control who would be on that trail. Now, taking this term in consideration, good to know as I look at other properties. Thank you for that!