Software
Houzz Logo Print
broof

Need advice on modern bath tubs

10 years ago

[Reposting per suggestion ... thanks Kelley Dockery!]

We are remodeling our bathroom and want a modern style, alcove bath tub (simple, clean angular lines, ~20" tall). We've found a few models we like but there is very little information or reviews on any of them. We'd like a good quality tub that is durable and doesn't scratch too easily - we do understand that acrylic is no cast iron. Want to make sure the tub holds up as ripping it out in a few years to replace would be extremely costly.

Does anyone have input on any of the following?

Jacuzzi Linea - LNS6032BRXXXXW - http://shop.ferguson.com/product/jacuzzi-JLNS6032BR-white-898411

We like the look of this one the best, but it seems like may not be very durable? Does Jacuzzi make good standard tubs (non whirlpool)? Will it hold up? Also, saw a review onbuild.com that said it scratched easily.

-

MTI Cameron 1 - S151-WH-RH - http://mtibaths.com/products/tubs/designer/151

Looks nice, but is twice the price of the Jacuzzi and Duravit - any noticeable difference in durability, quality, how easily would scratch?

-

Maax - Rubix - http://www.maax.com/en/products/bathtubs/rectangular/rubix-6030-6032

Also is a good look - didn't find much info on Maax.

-

Duravit Architec - http://shop.ferguson.com/product/duravit-D700353000000090-white-809471?tb=

We don't like the look of this one as much, prefer the simpler, squared off lines of these others, but I saw one in person and it seemed more durable than some others had seen.

-

Arista Pontormo 32 x 60 Front Skirted Drop-In Soaker Bathtub - Tub w/ Right Drain

Just came across this one on houzz...

-

Mirabelle - Sitka or Edenton - I believe Mirabelle is exclusive to the shop Ferguson. Also saw some reviews that indicated inconsistent quality.


...Any help or insight would be greatly appreciated!!

Thanks,

Brian

Comments (24)

  • 10 years ago

    Brian,

    We are in same situation as you in looking for a modern alcove tub. After a lot of time on the internet looking at tub reviews, Americast Cambridge (porcelin over steel) and American Standard Studio (acrylic) seem to stand out. Our installer indicated that there is big difference in quality (thickness) of acrylics. Also we are considering Maax Rubix but have seem some bad reviews on it. We would probably choose the Cambridge, but it just does not look modern. Please post and let us know what you decide. Thanks! Chris

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I use Maax a lot and my clients love them I also find the prices fair I have installed the Rubrix 2 times and have had no issues.I do not like steel tubs at all IMO they look cheap as for cleaning acrylic if you use a bit od dishsoap and a microfiber cloth that is all you need.

  • 10 years ago

    Did you buy the Jacuzzi linea tub? I just got this tub and am wondering about the quality. It is going to be delivered and installed in a couple of days. Thanks for any advice you can provide.

  • 10 years ago

    No, we haven't bought a tub yet as our bath remodel project got delayed. Let us know how the Linea works out for you. We do have a 15 year old Jacuzzi that we love. Best of luck!

  • 9 years ago
    Anyone have updates on their final selection & satisfaction?
  • 9 years ago

    Also considering Sitka, Linea, or Rubix...not many reviews on any of them. Any help??? Which is a better quality acrylic? Thanks :)

  • 8 years ago

    Me too! Considering Sitka, Linea and Rubix.

  • 8 years ago

    Ended up getting Linea. It came in perfect condition. We love the look, but we are still in the middle of reno, so haven't used it yet! We are very happy with the quality & the look.

  • 8 years ago

    wow. looks good. good to hear on first impressions. We just ordered the Linea!

  • 8 years ago

    Do you like Linea, I am considering it too

  • 8 years ago

    We decided on the Maax Rubix 60x32 alcove tub. Very modern. It seems very solid for an acrylic as it is coated with fiberglass underneath. We chose the Maax over the cast iron Bellwether and acrylic Jacuzzi Linea. No problems with installation or with tub!

  • 8 years ago

    I also looked at the kohler bellwether and memoirs for cast iron replacement. I have a 60 yr old cast iron now. Contractor recommended Maax or duravit for acrylic because the kohler tend to be narrow inside . My husband liked the feel of the Maax as he was able to stretch out just wondering how it will hold up to daily baths since he takes one everyday and also wondering if they installed yours with a mortar bed? I just can't convince myself on acrylic vs cast iron except that we won't be able to get the soaking depth on a cast iron because of the 60x 30 or 32 restriction we are working with

  • 8 years ago

    We are very satisfied with the Maax Rubix 60x32 tub. It is modern, it is very large for either showering or bathing! Its smooth bottom has not been an issue. It was installed with a mortar be and with ledger boards. The Maax technical service folks told us that the mortar bed is not required but our contractor did it anyway. Nice looking tub.

  • 7 years ago

    Just had the rubix installed and even though I insisted on a mortar bed doesn’t apear it was done and It creaks quite a bit when stepping in it. It’s not secured yet so will have to dicusss with the contractor why it wasn’t done when they said they would , I would highly suggest mortar even though it’s not mandated in the directions

  • 7 years ago

    What bath did you end up with? I am considering the same tubs you listed. Would love to know your results and if you're happy. Thanks!

  • 7 years ago

    Maax Rubix. Very happy with it. Lots of compliments! After showering, there is water on the ledge that we have to wipe off, but not a problem for us.

  • 6 years ago

    I’m considering the 60 X 32 Jacuzzi Linea or the Maax Rubix (18” height) or possibly the Kohler Underscore. I was planning on the Linea, but have read some bad reviews about quality. For those of you that have it- any thoughts? I like the water depth of 17”, which is why I’m leaning that way.
    Has anyone had issues with slipping in the Maax? Lastly, how comfortable is the Maax Rubix to lay down and bathe? Is it too straight backed? Thanks in advance!

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    The maxx Rubix is very comfortable to lay down in and not too slippery .

    We did get the deeper one. Also, extremely easy to clean.

    My husband loves it ! He takes a daily bath

    Just make sure that they fully support the bottom of any acrylic tub you buy with mortar piles .

  • 5 years ago

    Same questions as above, considering a Maax Rubix, Jacuzzi Linea or a Hydrosystems tub. Maax super comfortable. Everyone still happy with choice?

  • 5 years ago

    Yes love the Maax just make sure the installer gives good support underneath with mortar piles . Mine didn’t and when my husband takes a bath the caulk seperates.

    It’s so easy to clean and very comfortable

  • 5 years ago

    Still very happy with Maax Rubix bath tub after 4 years! Be sure to have contractor add mortar underneath, Beautiful tub. Many compliments. No problems. Available now at HD.

  • 3 years ago

    @chris2000kc still happy with the Maax Rubix? Looking to purchase, but concerend about durability. (7 people showering in it on a daily basis).

  • 3 years ago

    I have had my maax rubix for 4 years ! its a great tub and has held up well its just that my contractor did not support the bottom as he said he would and I have separation of the caulk where tub meets wall when my husband takes a bath and tub full of water. I wanted this tub supported properly since my husband does take a bath every day.

    Other than that only have to be careful using epsom salts because can cause etching if not cleaned up. Its so easy to clean, i just use clorox wipe and little bit of dish soap.