Software
Houzz Logo Print
klem1

What would you do?

10 years ago

I know the issue is wrong and determental to structure but I'm not sure how hard I should come down on contractor. I had a new composition shingle roof installed by a local company that's been in roofing over 20 years and member of BBB with good reviews. Our area was hit 1-2-3 with tornados,wind and hail storms over the last 6 months so contractors are swamped. I suspect but haven't attempeted to prove my contractor hired a sub and sub threw togeather a crew consisting of bodies picked up off the street. At any rate I was assured by salesman that workers had years experience in the trade. Facias were weathered on the 50 year old home so I specified yellow pine be used to replace 90%. When facia material was delivered I noticed labels that said "mixed wood"and material had no plow groove to recive plywood soffit which stand's proud of 2x4 subfacia. Carpenter and salesman were suprised that I was questioning the material since they had been useing the same on other jobs. Off they went in search of material desinated suitable for facia and returned following day with double plowed redwood. Great,why didn't we start with this I thought. After job was finished,occupent commented how bent up metal drip edge was. I agreed it was unatractive but functional and replacing it would likly damage roof so I was willing to take it as is. When salesman came to collect I pointed it out and suggested they use heavier metal or be more carful because I feel many owners would object. When salesman offered reasons why metal kinks when nailed to deck,I climbed ladder to lift shingles and felt so I could see what he was talking about. This is hip roof and felt was under drip edge metal. Salesman noted that detail is optional, I noted my objection to felt under metal on inspection form then issued check for full amount. For fear of farthur damage I do not intend alowing people who couldn't install metal without damaging it to get up there and replace it. I will be asking contractor for partial refund. How serious do you think this is? Would you change it? What amount/% refund would you ask for? While choosing amount of refund,does this oversight suggest lack of professionalism on remainder of job? Do you consider my reason valid for not alowing origional contractor to change it? I will hire another contractor or use day labor under my supervision to correct it. I want your view,both professional and homeowner,just state from which you are coming. Those not familar with what I'm talking about might wait to see what pros and experienced diyers say about seriousness,but please express an opinion if you have one.

Comments (7)

  • 10 years ago

    Do you live in a warm climate? Around here(Kansas City) there should be ice dam rubber membrane from the edge of the roof about 4' up.


    The drip edge kinked because of the felt---not acceptable.

  • 10 years ago

    Ice dam isn't part of normal installations here.

  • 10 years ago

    "This is hip roof and felt was under drip edge metal. Salesman noted that
    detail is optional, I noted my objection to felt under metal on
    inspection form then issued check for full amount."


    felt over drip edge.

    not sure why you'd pay in full if you knew this.

    replacing drip edge and putting felt over drip edge could be done,

    by an experienced roofer. sales man may think this detail is optional

    but he isn't correct.


    contact the company owner to meet you and discuss resolution

    at no cost to you.


    best of luck.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    klem,

    There are several reasons which could cause the drip edge to be bent. It could've have been before installation, improper installation, or a combination or the two.

    Drip edge is thin, and have had it damaged in transit, blown off the roof when materials were placed on the roof causing damage, and had it damaged by a worker who mishandled it. You can cut the bad section out, and usually always be able to use the balance elsewhere on the job.

    I can only speculate what happened in your case. If it is damaged to where it's lifting up the material. It is probably because it was installed incorrectly. It could be a worker attempted to pull it to tight too conform with the fascia/roof deck. The drip edge is more or less a straight edge and won't curve to conform, so it bends or kinks. The worker has to be able to know the limits and exactly how to place the drip edge to compensate for too high or bowed fascia.

    When they installed the fascia, they should've have used a straight edge to line the fascia up with the slope of the roof decking. Guessing where it should be placed always gets poor results and leads to complications on the installation of the drip edge. I could go on and tell you what they should've done etc, but I'm only speculating at this point.

    NORMALLY the felt is placed OVER the drip edge on the gutter edge (eave), and the drip edge is placed OVER the felt up the rake side. Since this is a hip roof and doesn't have rake sides, the drip edge should have been installed first then the felt goes over it. However, local code dictates how it should be done. So, not knowing your local code, I can't truthfully say if it were done wrong. However, should the local code say the drip edge go over the felt at the eave, then the code should also specify if mastic should be applied at this point to seal the felt/drip edge.

    I would not say they did not use appropriate gauge of metal for the drip edge. Manufacturers usually manufacturer drip edge to pass all codes for the gauge. However, who knows if the contractor knows of a place where they could get a flimsy drip edge to cut corners. But, logic tells me they would've cut corners elsewhere because they wouldn't be a whole lot of money to make on a cut rate drip edge.

    I'm linking to a short video by GAF about drip edge. Note the section about the sequence of felt and drip edge NORMALLY.

    Good luck.

    Drip edge installation tutorial.

  • 10 years ago

    Rater,I paid the invoice because it was easier than messing with them tearing something else up. Withholding payment until the clowns made a bigger mess trying to correct their mistake isn't something I'm interested in. I will not run short on funds between now and refund. I'm confident of getting a refund although it may require filing a small claim for it. The main question I have is how much I will ask to be refunded. It gall's me to think of home owners paying for that kind of incompitance.

  • 10 years ago

    "The main question I have is how much I will ask to be refunded."

    use this time to find a competent roofing company. get a bid

    from then to establish how much it will cost to re-do.

    get a couple of bids, but find the company that will re-do.


    usually one with holds 20% of total price. in my experience.

    enough to hire someone else. in your case you need to know

    how much to expect to pay. get that number & then pursue compensation.


    best of luck.