Software
Houzz Logo Print
deegw

Put lipstick on a pig?

10 years ago
last modified: 2 years ago

We have horrible 20 year old formica counters that really date our kitchen. The rest of the kitchen looks fine until you look closely at the cabinets and notice the wear and tear.

Should we spend $ for granite so our kitchen looks good in pictures and distracts the buyer from the less than optimal cabinets? Or should we just leave them be? Appliances are fairly new and are fine.



Comments (36)

  • 10 years ago

    It depends on what is standard for homes in your neighborhood and for the price point you'll be asking for your home.

    deegw thanked jewelisfabulous
  • 10 years ago

    It depends entirely on where you are located and what the market is like there. In a real hot market, it won't matter at all. If the people who are looking for homes in your area/location are viewers of HGTV, they'll be obsessed with granite. But if all the other homes that are competition are completely redone, yours will need more than countertops to compete.

    Talk to several good local realtors and ask them what's hot where you are.

    deegw thanked sushipup1
  • 10 years ago

    House near me just listed and sold in two days. No substantial updates and needs a new roof. Bidding ensued and she got more than listing. Thank heavens a family is moving in because the flipper vultures were lined up waiting to get in. So, depends on your particular market. Find a realtor you can work with and follow their advice, within your budget., They know your market best.

    In my case, the homeowner actually moved out ( bad dog), had the house staged and professionally cleaned. So yeah, lipstick on a pig but good school district and much desired neighborhood. It worked out well for homeowner,.

    deegw thanked User
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    My agent is on the fence about the counters as well. All houses in our price range are in good condition. Some homes are slightly larger, inferior locations, with nice but dated kitchens and counters. Others are smaller and newer with granite, also with inferior locations.

    I sent the pic to the agent this morning and asked her to show it around the office to get other opinions. IMO our house will be liked by families moving up and stretching their budget and can't mess with the kitchen right away. Or it will be an older couple downsizing or using it as a second home and they would probably want to do their own renovations.

  • 10 years ago

    Speaking as an older person who is buying a house to downsize to, as long as the kitchen is functional and not offensively decorated, it's fine (and yours looks good). I am watching my money (retirement) and have no more than a scholarly interest in kitchen remodels anymore.

    deegw thanked sushipup1
  • 10 years ago

    I would lean toward leaving it as is and pricing it a little more competitively. That's what we did in our last house. Plus, I find that every time I upgrade one thing in my house the things around it seem to look even more dated. So frustrating! And never ending, I might add. Does your house have anything unique about it? Hopefully it does and you will be able to market that special thing(s) and get it sold fast. Good luck to you!

    deegw thanked mydreamhomeideas
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I would clean the cabinets and, if you have paint to touch them up, do a little light touch up if needed. If you don't, just make sure the kitchen is very clean and well presented. If you do the counters, what you look closely to see now may jump out like a sore thumb and then you are worse off. If you really have to look closely, buyers may not even look that closely until they have moved in. If they do notice, a really clean home in good shape will be liveable until they can make the changes that suit them.

    And the older buyers are less likely to care -- even about making their own updates. When we sold my paren't last home, I thought we would have to correct a number of things. I cleaned up a bit -- most of my staging was on the bare courtyard entrance. The older couple that bought the house didn't care about the ceramic and brass pulls on the cabinets or that they were placed in the center panel, the mismatched fixture finishes, etc. They even bought some of the furnishings -- might have bought it fully furnished if we had been willing to let it all go.

    deegw thanked lascatx
  • 10 years ago

    I would leave it as is. It's entirely possible that a buyer might want to remodel the kitchen and the new granite countertops would not necessarily be an advantage, while they would be a big expense to you.

    deegw thanked kudzu9
  • 10 years ago

    As long as the rest of the house is clean with no stained carpeting, doorknobs and around light switches don't look like a million grimy hands have touched it, etc leave it as is. Of course I also said that to you in the kitchen forum. :)

    As a buyer, I would not want new granite cabinets on aging cabinets. Why would I want to pay for your granite choice when it's probably not even my taste (think how many granite choices there are), and knowing I'll have to dismantle the whole thing to put new cabinets in. Whether you put new granite in or not, I know I'll be trying to figure out what the cost of a new kitchen would be and I'd then try and figure out if you priced the house accordingly.

    If you dropped the price to account for the fact the house needs a new kitchen, then I'm more likely to bid close to asking. However if you put new granite counters in and then raise the price thinking you're fooling someone, then I'm going to lowball you because I still will know I need to redo the kitchen.

    BTW: The same holds true for bathrooms too. So if you put granite on your kitchen counters but your bathrooms still look like they are from the 90's don't expect to get top dollar.

    deegw thanked cpartist
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Frankly, I wouldn't touch it. It's not new, but it's not dirty or dysfunctional or offensive or totally off or anything like that. I could live with it for years until planning and attempting my own small reno.

    Our sellers put a bright white very modern Ikea kitchen in, and black granite too. It wasn't lipstick on a pig, but it was pig on a lipstick:) The house had totally different character..this kitchen didn't go with anything at all.

    I just felt they wasted their efforts, and money.

    Even the remnants of the old tile we found later under their flooring-were actually more quirky and interesting and fitting the house..

    Give the buyer something to dream about, and to plan for..

    deegw thanked aprilneverends
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    cpartist - GWers are not typical home buyers/remodelers so I am taking all the advice with a grain of salt. My agent has talked with other agents in her office and they have suggested that we leave the counters alone and offer an allowance which is the route that we will take.

    And no grime will be included. I have been on GW since 2001 so there is no need to assume that I just fell off the turnip truck.

  • 10 years ago

    Good plan. I bought two houses last year and looked at a lot of listings/photos over the past two years. I think new granite on old cabinets typically makes the kitchen look worse - in my opinion. Plus, who's to say a buyer would even want granite. Lower price and let me choose what I want.

    deegw thanked 3katz4me
  • 10 years ago

    I'd be very conflicted if I bought a house with new granite or obvious upgrades in order to sell, and consider ripping it all out. I'd rather buy a house with an old kitchen so I could just rip it all out and make it my own.

    deegw thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    I agree that granite on old cabinets is not a good idea. It will make the cabinets look worse, imho. We struggled with this in our last sale. The home had bright yellow laminate counter tops and white (painted) cabinets. The cabinets looked ok, but not high end. In the end we replaced the yellow laminate with one of those newer laminates that looks a lot like granite...wasn't very expensive and the kitchen looked really nice.

    deegw thanked peter826
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    We recently moved to a home in which the kitchen has granite counters and older, somewhat crooked wooden cabinets. Fortunately I love the look. To my eyes the cabinets have character and go fine with the granite.

    deegw thanked gbauer48
  • 10 years ago

    I agree with NC. As long as the home is clean, decluttered, and presentable don't go offering allowances for something the buyer may not find so off putting.

    Not every home buyer wants to immediately remodel the kitchen unless their favorite TV network is HGTV. You'll know who they are by buzz words like "it's so small" no matter what they look at.

    deegw thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    Those cabinets dont look that bad in my opinion, so I dont know if it would be lipstick on a pig. Might be a little wear and tear but still fully functional and dont look bad.

    The only risk you run with putting new tops on is that the buyer wont like color or veining of the new tops.


    deegw thanked Vith
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    cpartist - GWers are not typical home buyers/remodelers so I am taking all the advice with a grain of salt. My agent has talked with other agents in her office and they have suggested that we leave the counters alone and offer an allowance which is the route that we will take.

    Agreed we are not typical but I believe you said it's in a better neighborhood so I'm assuming the buyers to be somewhat more knowledgeable and also not first time buyers, even if they are not to the level us GW folks are.

    Your kitchen looks fine so I think you got excellent advice.

    And no grime will be included. I have been on GW since 2001 so there is no need to assume that I just fell off the turnip truck.

    I would NEVER assume you or anyone fell off the turnip truck or any other truck. When I listed my house, I believe I was given the same exact advice. It's sort of what we do. Give the clean the house, stage it, etc routine. :)

    Personally from what I can see the house looks beautiful.

    deegw thanked cpartist
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I would leave it as it is. I like it. It's sweet.

    ETA: And I wouldn't change a thing.

    In fact, sometimes I find granite bench tops intimidating. They are too grand or something. I like my rock out in the open, with (or without) lichen.

    Re GWers not being typical of buyers out there, I don't agree with this. All sorts read this site I imagine. I read it because I love the subject of the property market.

    Based on the amount that I can see of your house, d-gw, I like it A LOT.

    deegw thanked tete_a_tete
  • 10 years ago

    Granite is heavy and you might risk the cabinets not being able to support it. This is what I heard from a kitchen designer at a big box store, when I asked for differences between solid surface and quartz. She said quartz was 25 pounds per sf, IIRC. I have laminate now, so if I don't replace base cabinets the weight of the countertop could be a concern if I choose stone.

    deegw thanked Jane
  • 10 years ago

    Granite is about 17 lbs per square foot for the standard 3 cm thickness; natural quartz is the same; and manufactured quartz, which is about 93% quartz and 7% resin, is a bit less, but not enough to make a difference. As is not uncommon, the big box store person didn't know what she was talking about. So a piece of granite would put a weight of less than 70 lbs on a cabinet that was 2' wide and 2' deep. If your cabinets can handle your 10 year old sitting on the counter, they are strong enough to handle a solid top.

    deegw thanked kudzu9
  • 10 years ago

    It looks fine - I think you can safely cross it off your list of things to worry about.

    deegw thanked Debbie Downer
  • 10 years ago

    I would not update the counter. If I were buying the home, I'd much rather do that myself and install what I wanted or leave what you have there (which looks fine). We have looked at a lot of houses lately and most of the "improvements" weren't in keeping with the style of the house or what was already there and more than once the thought of "lipstick on a pig" did come to mind. :-)

    deegw thanked sunfeather
  • 10 years ago

    I think it looks clean airy. If I dreamed of a different color granite than you put down, I'd be sighing a tiny bit inside, looking at a brand new expensive counter not of my choosing.


    deegw thanked c t
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    A slew of 1960s houses I bought in the late '80s had been lovingly renoed.

    I could care less as they were shortly pounded to rubble to make way for new homes.

    deegw thanked worthy
  • 10 years ago

    d, granite is so taste-specific! We bought an older house last year, kitchen remodeled by proud homeowner with a very busy and (to us) hideous granite. I struggled to find positive things to say to her at closing. The location is what sold us on the house, despite the not-so-good kitchen.

    Your cabinets look great (envious!). Please don't offer a counter allowance up front -- to see it in print it might lead buyers to perceive a negative where otherwise they would not. Save the allowance card to play if the counters become a negotiating point with an otherwise eager buyer.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    My kitchen looks almost identical to yours, so same thought process here. In my market, move-in ready is huge. I would put ikea wood counters in and clean, touch-up the cabinets.

    Renovating a kitchen of that size would be 50k+, so the next person will have the same thoughts, counters are terrible, but cabinets are old, i.e. I'm looking at a huge reno.

    You want them to think that they can live with the kitchen as is for now. In my market, the laminate with oak edge wouldn't fly.

  • 10 years ago

    From what I can see your house looks beautiful! I do not know your area but I think the allowance is a great idea!

  • 10 years ago

    I would not offer an allowance unless the countertops were not useable. That opens the door to buyers wanting an allowance for other dated items.

    If the counters were damaged beyond repair then replace them or give an allowance.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Why should I give an allowance for something that's totally functional? Maybe I should fund their future reno too?

    Nobody ever gave me any allowances, and I never thought to ask for them. Didn't even cross my mind. One thing when something has to be repaired. Another thing when something is older/not to my liking. Either you like my house, or you don't. Either you can live with something, or you can't. Make up your mind. ("You" is some virtual non-existing buyer that will ask me for allowances lol.)

  • 10 years ago
    Amen to that!
  • 10 years ago

    How about updating with new laminate? It is the wood trim around the current laminate that makes the whole kitchen look a little dated. There are some very pretty new products available and for a few hundred bucks, it would cost much less than granite. A potential buyer may feel it is a kitchen they could move into, and "live with" for a while if it had a newer, barely used countertop product, knowing a complete reno may be needed down the road, which can appeal to many buyers. It's hard to see the condition of the countertops, but I understand your desire to update or clean them up a bit, especially if there are any scratches or stains on them. The rest of your home looks lovely and very well kept, in the picture you posted.

    I do agree with other posters, do nothing or spend as little as possible-not granite.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    My house with the "pig" cabinets and the formica counters has been on the market for one day and just got a cash offer of 94% of list! No counter allowance. Fingers crossed that the rest of the negotiations go well. Real estate is a crazy business.

  • 10 years ago

    Congratulations. Here's hoping for a quick close.

    So glad you decided against "fixing" the formica counters.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Haha. Good on you. Yay. Please keep us posted.