Software
Houzz Logo Print
nbekman

Foundation & crawl space advice

10 years ago

Hi all,

I am completely confused about what to do with my foundation and crawl space, here is the scrio:

We own a 1929 house in San Diego with a raised foundation and no insulation underneath, in the walls or in the attic. Unfortunately, our part of town has a lot of ground water and moisture, so at times (primarily in the winter) our house can feel musty and damp. Towards the front of the house the crawl space is deep enough to get underneath the house, but towards the back the dirt is too high. Prior to buying the house, the previous owner had a sump pump installed in the front of the house, which seems to have helped.

About 6 months ago, we added an addition along the back of the house. The contractor built a similar raised foundation with a wall around the perimeter. That foundation wall is only an inch or two higher than our cement patio in the back, and about 1.5 feet higher than our driveway in the front. He and I discussed my concerns about moisture, but he felt strongly that insulating the floor and laying black paper under the wood flooring would be sufficient to prevent moisture intrusion into the house. The entire back of the foundation does not have any vents and he advised against laying a moisture barrier (after multiple discussions) as he thought mold would simply accumulate under the barrier, and that if water got under the house it would then lay on top of the plastic.

Fast forward to now, we began noticing minor amounts of mold in our bathroom closet and assumed it was from the moisture from the shower. We removed certain items, but the closet began to smell, so I removed everything and wiped down all of the walls. The smell has continued, and when the contractor returned he noted that it is currently very damp under the house and that is probably the cause of the problem. He suggested that we open the floor in the bedroom closet (next to the bathroom closet, but not currently smelling) in order to install a sump pump in the back.

I am completely overwhelmed and disappointed that this is happening, and I have no idea how to proceed. Not that it matters now, but do you guys think that installing a french drain when the foundation was opened would have helped? Should we have installed a vapor barrier and/or cut foundation vents? I have read pros and cons on the web for all of these, and I find it extremely confusing. Secondly, what is the best course of action for us to take now?

Thanks so much, this all has been so distressing and disappointing, and I don't know who to believe or even who to call!

Looking forward to hearing your feedback,

-Nicole

Comments (6)

  • 10 years ago
    Update-I had a moisture and mold inspector come by who had a fancy moisture meter. He suspects a slowly leaking drainage pipe from the sink that is housed in the wall between the bathroom and closet as that wall is overly damp. The saga continues, will keep everyone posted!
  • 10 years ago

    I had a house in SD that was like yours. The behind property was much higher than mine. When it rained the crawl space filled with water.

    we have not had rain to speak of for a while.

    You may have a leaky pipe.

    you will need insulation and a pump as previously mentioned.

    Nicole thanked tim45z10
  • 10 years ago

    Your plumbing issue aside, having an enclosed crawl space with no vapor barrier could lead to rote in the long run. It's all circumstantial on how you proceed.


    In my case, we have an enclosed crawlspace and there is a complete vapor barrier as air tight as can be, no vents. Without it, the crawlspace and floor joists would rot because we're in an area that receives near 100% humidity throughout most of the year, and venting it would just raise the humidity inside, where as blocking it out, keeps it out.


    In your case it sounds like venting the crawlspace and putting up a vapor barrier against your subfloor/floor joists Only might be more ideal. The idea is to try to keep the humidity down, if you believe water would creep up under the vapor barrier from the ground, then having a complete enclosed vapor barrier wouldn't work for you and your next best option is venting it and installing a vapor barrier up against your subfloor/floor joists. However, if you feel that somehow even that could be penetrated by moisture, then you should just vent it with no vapor barrier.







    Nicole thanked FastInk
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Update: no pipe leaks are apparent at this point, and it also doesn't seem that there are any leaks in the roof, so we do think this is a groundwater issue. We haven't yet been able to fully assess what is happening down there, but my contractor has agreed to come back and add venting and access, as specified per code.

    I have been so confused about enclosed vs vented crawlspace, particularly for my property and location. In general, San Diego is not particularly humid or damp; however my neighborhood in San Diego has significant levels of groundwater. It's not enough to make a pool under the house, but definitely enough to cause damp soil and sometimes is even muddy (although that hasn't happened in the past two years once we got it somewhat dried out). Before construction had begun, I had wondered if we should properly grade the ground under the old part of the house, close up the vents and lay down a vapor barrier, but most of the contractors I spoke to here advised against it. Everything I read online seems to point to an enclosed crawlspace as conclusively superior from a building science perspective, but even the foundation experts in the area I trust the most seemed to feel that was either unnecessary or ill-advised, and I can't quite tell which it is and if they are right or not.

    To complicate things further, I pulled out my during-construction pictures and remembered that the old foundation wall is still there between the main part of the house and the addition, which now makes me wonder if we should leave the addition crawlspace fully enclosed without ventilation and just put down a vapor barrier in that section only, or if that would cause too much vapor transfer between the old and new sections. The old section does have two old vent holes, and I don't know if it would be better to leave them open or close them up.

    I am feeling a bit back to the drawing board now...options being:

    1) Proceed as planned and open vent holes in the new foundation, and likely also install a fan to draw air through the old and new foundation space.

    2) Leave the new foundation closed, add an access door somewhere and fully enclose the space with a vapor barrier (after ruling out any active water intrusion that we can't currently see)...BUT leave the old portion of the house as is...which is not properly graded, but vented and with a sump pump that appears to be working well enough to keep the space drier than it used to be. If we did enclose the new part, would we then remove the batts of insulation that were recently installed under the floor or take them out? For the old portion, does adding any foam board or spray insulation make sense or does that exacerbate problems (I have read both online in different places)?

    3) Enclose the new AND old crawlspace, which would likely also require regrading the old space and closing up the old vents. This would probably be the most costly, but based on my reading sounds like it would prevent the most problems...my main concern being that either the excess groundwater would cause mold under the vapor barrier and this strategy may not be recommended in my type of an area (again, no idea if that is true or not) OR that I could be throwing way too much effort/money into something that is not necessary or could have other unknown side effects to the house? Also, same insulation questions from option 2 apply here as well...

    Can I say confused?!?! Slowly but surely we seem to be making progress on this crazy house adventure. Thanks again!

    -Nicole

  • 5 years ago

    Now it's five years later? Did you fix the problem?

Sponsored
Haus Studio
Average rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars28 Reviews
Franklin County's Preferred Custom Cabinetry & Design Studio