I am struggling with the same exact thing. I really really want the big but some are saying that I should go smaller. I also purchase the 6lighy linear room for over kitchen table. Wondering if all 3 in same room would be too much? Def looking for a statement tho. And my island is same size as yours

If you're putting the 6 light linear light over your kitchen table, go with the medium sized lanterns. The small will look too small in comparison...Just my opinion :)

Cheryl- did you go with the medium size? I’m working on the same project with the same size center island and wonder how they look.