Software
Houzz Logo Print
uscroy

Converting arches to pillars

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

I know it's unlikely anyone can definitively answer this question just by looking at the picture but I'd like opinions from those qualified to give an opinion.

I have these arches on the facade of my house and I'm trying to modernize. Think it's OK to square off the arches so there are 90 degree angles in the corners instead of curves?

My feeling is there are probably posts inside the brick on the ends of the arches so the corners would be OK to square off. I think it's unlikely that the brick arches are a load bearing feature.

Is there any way to get a concrete answer? Could I make exploratory cuts in the brick? If the arches are load bearing I imagine any cutting could impair their integrity.

Thoughts?

(Yes, of course I will cover up the brick -- probably with stucco or some sort of stack stone/exterior tile. I'm not going to leave the broken brick exposed.)

Comments (28)

  • 10 years ago

    When was this house built?

  • 10 years ago
    Built in 1973.
  • 10 years ago

    Ah ok, was just making sure it wasn't an oldie but goodie. LOL. As for your question, I will defer to the experts. :)

  • 10 years ago

    If you want to modernize, consider paint. It's a much less expensive solution and very easy to maintain. I have painted brick on my home. It's been the most trouble free exterior I have ever owned. The arches in the picture go well with the roof and are a charming feature. Sometimes it's best to compliment a housing style rather than fight it. Save your money and use it elsewhere.

    uscpsycho thanked homechef59
  • 10 years ago

    I agree with DLM2000 - paint it and play with landscaping. The arches appear to be well done and you can do a lot with paint and plants and hardscape -probably cheaper too...

    uscpsycho thanked just_janni
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    The arches are structural and holding up the roof, unless there is a very heavy steel or timber beam in there.

    If you can determine that they aren't structural you can do what you wish, or you will have to factor new structural support into your plans.


  • PRO
    10 years ago

    No way to determine bearing or non -bearing by looking at the photo. Best bet is to have a structural engineer examine them.

  • 10 years ago

    I agree with your desire to remove the arches to update the look. Call some local contractors, they can assess the columns. I don't know the entire arch is structural, again consult with local contractors for a good solution. The heavy arches cover your windows.

    uscpsycho thanked C Marlin
  • 10 years ago

    Those arches are much nicer than pillars. No way I'd change them.

  • 10 years ago

    Can you show a picture of the entire exterior instead of just the arches only?

    I would definitely call a good contractor and try to remove them. There are a few homes in our area that look similar and they look really out of place.


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    After talking to my contractor we're pretty sure that the arches are not structural and I could kill them if I want. Just to be clear, when I say "pillars" I mean clean, square columns and not round/ornate columns.

    Now let me respond to some of the posts.

    The house is in Los Angeles and doesn't look out of place in this neighborhood. There are many homes in this style, and other styles too, my next door neighbor has a super modern looking home. The stucco you see is already gone. I hated the color and the texture. I'm going with a sand finish in either white or possibly a grey. Gutters are going, eaves are going and I'm considering changing the roof as well. So major facelift.

    However, with all the expenses I thinking I'm going to leave the arches and paint them as someone suggested. Covering them with stucco is going to be too expensive, and if I start busting them out it's going to be even more expensive to clean up.

    These are vinyl windows and I don't think the white fames could be changed without changing the windows themselves. Not changing the windows, especially since I already bought some new windows to match the existing windows.

    I really loathe brick so I'm going to paint the chimneys as well as the arches.

    Here's a photo of the house. Parts of the photo look choppy because I photoshopped some trees and shrubs out to show an unobstructed view. (There are no trees growing out of the roof! lol)


    I am covering the wood siding you see with stucco and I am changing the garage doors.

    This thread is going in a totally different direction than it started (and the title) so I might be better served to start a new thread. But here are the decisions I have to make. I'd appreciate your thoughts.

    1) Color for the stucco

    2) Color for the paint over the bricks

    3) Color/type of new roof (I am leaning towards a metal standing seam roof)

    4) Color of eaves and new gutters

    From the time I started this remodel I always thought I'd go with white for the stucco because I like that look. But now that I think about it, since my windows have white frames would it look better if I got a different color stucco? This is probably a silly question to a designer but I really don't know. Looking at photos online, it's very rare to see a white house with white window trim. There's almost always contrast.

    Open to any and all suggestions!

  • 10 years ago

    If you are keeping the roof, I'm going to suggest Navajo white with the white windows. Navajo white is a strange color in that it presents entirely differently on the wall versus the paint chip on paper. It's much creamier than the chip. It will be softer than the white of the windows.

    I like the current roof. It has that Spanish hacienda vibe that goes with the arches. If you change the roofing material, you will need to wait until you determine the roofing material to decide on a house color.

  • 10 years ago

    It's actually a very handsome house but I understand the need for a refresh. First decision needs to be the roof type and color and the other elements will play off of that. Is the current roof in bad condition? If not, I wouldn't change it - of course that decides the rest of the colors but you still have a lot of options. Cleaning up the landscaping - for real, not photoshop! - will make a big difference. To get more of a stucco look without actually doing stucco, Thoroseal or Thorocoat makes a couple/few different masonry paints and one has a thick, sand-like texture that will somewhat fill in your mortar lines for a smoother, look.

    uscpsycho thanked DLM2000-GW
  • 10 years ago

    I also live in Los Angeles County, I see your type of house often, I'd still remove the arches to lighten up both the exterior and interior. Money is such a hassle. I love the roof, I think of a updated contemporary Spanish ranch look. Light and airy but traditional California casual.

    uscpsycho thanked C Marlin
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    If you keep the tile roof, go very light in color. Every house in my city is white and many have white vinyl windows, it looks fine. A house in Manhattan Beach I love is all white, even the rose bushes were white rose, I loved it. Never would have imagined it before seeing it.

    uscpsycho thanked C Marlin
  • 10 years ago

    It has a bit of a prairie feel and a spanish feel. I personally like the brick and the roof as it works well with the style of the house. If you have any photoshop skills, before removing the roof and/or painting the brick, why not try and see how the changes would look.

  • 10 years ago

    A lot of people here like my existing roof. It is really popular all over L.A., you see lots and lots of this Spanish tile around here, even on brand new mcmansions.

    But look at the photos I posted of the interior style of my house. Even if you like the brick, roof and arches, don't you think there is a major disconnect between the exterior and the interior?

    In addition, I am building a balcony and rooftop deck on the back side that will have 70+ feet of glass railing. I think that's another disconnect. Phase 2 of this remodeling nightmare will be a complete backyard makeover. Everything new will have a modern feel because that is the style I like.

    While I loathe the expense of changing the roof, sometimes I feel like I have to do it so that the outside and inside tie in together.

  • 10 years ago

    Yes, as you move along both the exterior and interior must peacefully coexist. Glass railing and brick and arches usually don't work together.

  • 10 years ago

    You want contemporary, definitely remove the arches, do you want subtle contemporary or every inch very contemporary? Very contemporary change the roof too.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I probably have to choose between changing the roof or eliminating the arches. It's too expensive to do both.

    From the front, the most predominant feature of the house is the roof so I think it's better to change that. At least I can paint the arches to harmonize them without a huge added cost. The arches will still be there but at least the brick look will be gone.

  • 10 years ago

    Look up prairie style. It pays homage to the past while being contemporary. I personally just hate to see a beautiful old home completely changed from what it is. My feeling is if you buy an older home its best to work within its parameters. The beauty of this house is that it is not a modern style box

    uscpsycho thanked cpartist
  • 10 years ago

    Where are the pics of the interior?

  • 10 years ago

    OOPS! I was thinking of another thread. I posted some interior pics in this thread - https://www.houzz.com/discussions/help-me-pick-a-door-style-dsvw-vd~3925636

    Busy now but I'll try to remember to come back and post the pics here. If you look at the photos you'll get a better idea of the inside-outside disconnect. The kitchen will also have a very modern/European look with clean lines, no handles, integrated appliances, etc.

  • 10 years ago

    As an example, my love is craftsman and shingle style homes. 6 years ago we moved into a condo that was known for it's modern style. Much as I wanted to make it into a true craftsman look, I knew it wouldn't work well with the condo. So instead of a true craftsman style molding around doors and crown molding, I created a simple squared off molding that paid homage to the craftsman look but worked well with the cleaner lines of the condo. With everything, I simplified the look and made it work within the parameters of the condo, so it bridged the gap between my sensibilities of wanting more craftsman traditional, DH's sensibilities of wanting more Asian feeling and what the building itself was telling us.

  • 10 years ago

    Actually what you posted would work very well with your style of house. As I mentioned, look up prairie style, and especially the father of the movement Frank Lloyd Wright's homes. But do a search here on houzz for prairie style and you'll see what I mean.

  • 10 years ago

    I looked at lots of photos of prairie houses and I'm not sure where the connection between my home and a prairie style lies. I think every single one had a shingle roof and none had arches. I did see a lot of brick in those photos so that seems to be the big thing my house has in common.

    As I think this through I think the money that would be spent on converting the arches would be better spent on some solar and a new roof that will keep the house cooler. We get awfully hot in the summer here.

    I also dislike the roof a lot more than the arches. So if I had to eliminate one, it would be the roof. I gotta say, this experience of remodeling the house and in a lot of ways transforming it, has been exhausting.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Unless the classic tile roof is in complete disrepair, "remuddling" it would be a big mistake. Your clean, modern interior works beautifully with the exterior style. No disconnect whatsoever. If you do decide to replace it, I hope they can remove it carefully (if that is even possible) so a homeowner with a taste for beauty can put it to great use. With all the tacky boxes out there, I hate to see a beautiful roof such as this go to waste.