Software
Houzz Logo Print
jenmagnotti

are pottery barn sofas good?

10 years ago

I'm looking for good quality living room furniture. Where's the best place to look?

Comments (16)

  • 10 years ago

    It really depends on your budget and definition of quality. You can spend several thousand dollars for a high quality sofa but you can also spend less and have one that will still last for quite a while. When starting the research and purchase process, it is easy to get pulled in the direction of paying a lot for specific design features but it is also good to keep in mind that sofa styles and your personal and room style preferences will likely shift at some point so a higher-priced, top-of-the-line sofa may not be your forever sofa. That is not to say that you should not pay for the quality you are looking for but, even if you decide to go with a more mid-range option, you may still be happy with it. Focusing on an upholstery that will last based on your lifestyle is an important consideration.

    Jennifer Magnotti thanked Elle
  • 10 years ago

    yes, we are not looking to spend $10,000, but also not $600. I just don't know where to start. We are in our mid 30's and have two kids, but they are not toddlers anymore and know how to be respectful of furniture.

  • 10 years ago

    These are our first proper purchases, and I don't want to buy something that will lose shape and look saggy in a year.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    I would try Ethan Allen. Their furniture is still nice quality.


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I am convinced there is more often than not little correlation between price and quality. I've seen expensive couches that were built like crap, but looked great. And inexpensive couches that could last 10 years but might not fit many decors. However something that looks good, uses good materials, and is built well will always command high prices.

    If your living room is not the family room/den that will help longevity. Heavy use will wear out a couch. That's physics. Ethan Allen is good, but I've always found their more modern offerings rather thin, if you care about that.

    The best place to look when figuring out how well made it is is under the couch. Turn it over and look at the framing and see how well everything is matched up or if pieces are misaligned or the nails missed their marks. It is amazing how poorly built a $2-3000 couch can be.

    Most chain furniture stores will have range of offerings that should be more than sufficient, at least until you figure out exactly what you want in style, materials, and build. By then you will probably be able to afford a nice, close-to-hand made offering from a local craftsman.

    As for pottery barn, I've always found their offerings expensive for what you get, but the stuff isn't awful and isn't atypical of chain boutique stores.

    Joe

  • 10 years ago

    Jen, there is a long discussion about quality furniture somewhere on Houzz or GW - if you haven't searched for similar threads yet, it would be worth it - lots of experienced and quality advice. My experience with PB is that their prices are high for the quality, which is mid level. EA is priced even higher, and is also mid quality - covered in other Houzz discussions. If you like PB, maybe wait for a sale and don't plan to get more than 8-10 years out of your couch :)

  • 10 years ago

    I'm still a fan of Craigslist. But you have to be patient until the unicorn shows up.

    Joe

  • 10 years ago
    big fan of PB, always have been. that being said I wouldn't buy a couch from them now. we did 12 years ago, but I think the quality has suffered. someone might know why???? I would look for a store that carries Lee and order a couch from them or of you're lucky get a floor sample
    like several have said, depends on if you want one that lasts 5-7 years or longer
  • 10 years ago
    I have the PB Pearce sectional - love it. It looks the same as I bought it 3 years ago. Made in the USA. Super comfortable.
  • 10 years ago
    I have two PB basic sofas, both about 15 years old. One has all down cushions, which cost more, but I'd recommend. It has held up better. We are just now thinking of replacing slip covers. The bones of both sofas are in fine shape. We sit on both every day.
    BTW, we also have a few chairs, also great. They are comfortable and I have washed slip overs many times---even the ones that recommended dry cleaning. I dry cleaned at first (expensive), but at a certain point decided to take a chance.
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    What part of North America do you live? Do you have access to Interior Design showrooms that only Trade members have access to? Also what sort of style are you looking for? I may recommend a few mid-level lines that might work.

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    If you like the style, Eckornes Stressless is very comfortable and has good choice of materials and colors.

    We want a power reclining sofa for next major furniture purchase and plan to get one that is part of the
    Celena line from Best Home Furnishings (special order from Ivan Smith). Choice of different materials and colors. Maybe $2,000 in leather.

    Went through an $800 sofa that lasted about 10 years.

    For sofas, mattresses and chairs, I never purchase without trying out in person.
  • 5 years ago

    I have a Pottery Barn sectional that is around 20 years old now, and still looks great. It's in Everyday suede, so I am able to wash the covers in my washing machine. The singular issue is the zipper came loose from washing a bit too frequently. However, I browse through sites like Craigslist to get a wider idea of what's out there and noticed that a lot of other sofas don't hold up very well. I was thinking about getting a RH sofa, but noticed that they don't hold up--the cushioning looks flat and out of shape after a couple of years! It's too bad, because I was really hoping to get one. Same goes for ZGallerie, which was the other brand I was looking into--does not stand the test of time. So, whatever you think you want to get, look at used ads of that model or brand online to see how much it deteriorates from regular use. My PB sectional is in my den, plan on keeping it, but I was hoping to change things up in my formal living room. It looks like I may be going with PB again.

  • 2 years ago

    We have a PB leather sofa and a PB Wells in performance 'suede' fabric. After 4 years of constant use for both, they are both in excellent condition and in construction, materials, etc. Recommend. Waited for them to go on sale.

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    Oooops, OLD ZOMBIE POST.__________WHY DO THESE "PROS" HAVE TO REVIVE THEM? So annoying....and I can see why someone obviously gave them grief.