Neither particularly matches, but neither seems a terrible combination either. First one looks a lot easier to clean! :)

I think you should keep looking!

I prefer the first one, I think it looks great! I'm a huge fan of Troy Lighting, they are great quality

I think a clearer picture and a bit further back may help for good feedback.

Maybe you could find something that combines a bit of elegance for your table, but also rustic and has a fair amount of glass to compliment the island's pendants and a light colored metal.