Software
Houzz Logo Print
stephperrone

Thinking of change trim color from BM White Dove to BM Simply White

10 years ago

Here's my dilemma: BM white dove is the trim color throughout our entire house and has been for over 14 years but I think I'm ready for a change with my latest painting project on the 1st floor. I'm thinking of going with BM simply white or cotton balls as trim but I have a built-in cabinet installed about 2 years ago between kitchen/dining room that's in white dove.
Painting the built-in is not an option and wall color will be BM edgecomb gray eggshell.
So, I have 3 questions:
(1) If I go with simply white or cotton balls as trim color, will my built-in cabinet in white dove look odd and/or dirty instead of beautiful?
(2) Should I just stick with White Dove?
(3) Should I paint my ceiling the same color as my crown molding and trim but in a different finish?

Comments (6)

  • 9 years ago

    I see this is an old question, but I'd love to know the same. I'm thinking of going from BM "White" (it does look a tad gray-ish/cool) to BM White Dove, but I have white plantation shutters in all windows. Unless I find someone to repaint the shutters (some could use help, but most look ok), I think it will be a disaster switching. At the time we painted some trim, we thought BM White matched best, but some days I think Super White would have been better. I do love White Dove, but it's a little creamier than the other choices and may look odd unless I commit to every door and trim piece in this house. Must be easier when building because it all gets done at once.

  • 9 years ago

    Can you let me know why you were thinking of switching in the first place? That is, what you ended up not liking about the white dove? I'm trying to decide between White Dove and Simply White for trim in my whole downstairs (no idea what color[s] of white are currently there, but everything needs to be fixed). Leaning towards WD because our kitchen cabinets will need to be repainted, and I think I would prefer a creamier white than the brighter white for the cabinets, and I'm assuming I will want the cabinets to match the trim. However, I'm sometimes worried that I'll find that the WD looks too yellowish. Help!

  • 9 years ago
    You need to use whichever white trim color best coordinates with your wall color. In my case, white dove did not coordinate with my wall color, while simply white did. It took me at least a week of trying out different whites before I landed on one that really looked great with my wall color. I got help from this forum and also from the Benjamin Moore designers. It's worth it to take your time and get the right white, because it can make a huge difference in the look of your room. Good luck!
  • PRO
    9 years ago
    I had two different painters bid our first floor and tell me that my original choice of trim color, Benjamin Moore Simply White, had coverage issues. I'm not sure how a color could cover any different than any other color, but it may have something to do with the base?? I would reach out to some skilled painters to make sure that they haven't found the same to be the case. We went with white dove. I did sample cotton balls on my millwork, but it seemed to have a yellowish, almost greenish cast in some lights.
  • 9 years ago
    I was thinking of switching from WD to simply white for a crisper/whiter white. After 15 years of WD I thought I was ready for a change, but i decided to stick to WD for 2 reasons: I invested in a custom built in cabinet that is WD and the WD looks good with the Edgecomb gray on the walls.