Software
Houzz Logo Print
mragjr

Think we have a sick tree, help!

10 years ago

Live in 23 year old townhouse community, 25 miles south of Philadelphia. Out front is an original(?) tree (bush?) that is not looking very healthy especially compared to an identical sister tree maybe 80' away. These photos are from today. Any ideas, suggestions on what is happening? TIA

Comments (11)

  • 10 years ago

    mrag, your dogwood could be suffering from one or more of the following; Drought, improper pesticide and/or fertilizer use, one or more insects or insect-like creatures, including aphids, mites, and others....uh, there's more, but that should get us started. Now what, if anything, can you tell us about the recent history of the tree and it's immediate environment?

    mragjr thanked wisconsitom
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I believe the tree has been here 20+ years. The community has a 'landscape service' that cuts the grass, fertilizes, puts down weed killer, mulches, but I don't believe they do anything specific for the "trees." I don't think water is a issue, note how the houses drain towards the tree. There is an identical tree four doors down and there one can see how that seems to be thriving. Can we cut back a lot of the excess growth. (when)? The curled leaves suggest something ain't right, but I didn't even know it was a dogwood. I can include more photos if that might help. Thank you

  • 10 years ago

    If you can, take some closeups of BOTH sides of the foliage of the affected tree, and also of the whole tree. The tree is a kousa dogwood, rather than the native eastern dogwood. Kousas are usually trouble free, easterns not so much.

    mragjr thanked kentrees12
  • 10 years ago

    One can take a clean white sheet of paper, hold it below some branches, and tap tap tap to see if any spider mites fall onto the paper. Spider mites, while related to actual spiders, are herbivores which use their mouthparts to suck the juice out of plant cells, causing a stipling effect on the foliage. In severe cases, lots of foliage can be destroyed or made unusable by the plant.

    Aphids are small, soft-bodied insects which often cluster on leaf undersides, as well as flower stems and some other plant parts, which likewise suck the juices out of the leaves. Kentrees wants you to show us the leaf undersides, and this is one of the reasons why. Aphid infestation can cause curling, cupping of leaves, but so can phenoxy herbicide damage. Phenoxies are things like 2-4D, dicamba, etc. which are used on lawns to kill broadleafed weeds. They can and often do cause damage to trees.

    Just a few ideas to ponder. There's certainly a lot more where those came from.

    mragjr thanked wisconsitom
  • 10 years ago

    I've observed leaf curling on kousas that just seems to be a response to full sun conditions, no other factors involved. Maybe there are some kousa experts who will chime in?

    mragjr thanked arbordave (SE MI)
  • 10 years ago

    Agree with arbordave - curled and downward hanging leaves is a very common reaction from just about any flowering dogwood (kousa or other) to heat and drought stress. These are by nature woodland understory trees and often a full-on siting in hot sun will cause temporary heat stress. Not sick or diseased and should recover fully but can be assisted with some slow, deep watering from time to time in the heat of summer.

    mragjr thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Attached some additional photos as requested. I've also put a number more on a photo web page that might offer added information. I've lived next to the tree the last three years. It's only this year that it was looking challenged especially when compared to an identical more healthy looking tree very close by. It appears (and I can barely grow parsley) likes it's dry although it probably gets more water from the roof gutter drains than it should. It has lots of new, but straggly growth, in fact I started looking more closely at it as I wanted to trim a bit off. Your help is much appreciated. (I didn't see a number of replies before posting this, will absorb them now. But both trees should get "equal" sun and mine seems really low on seed pods/balls and has much more curling, thanks all)

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for the additional images.

    Typically, sucking insects are found on the undersides of leaves, but not always. I see no indication of them, above or below.

    Both sets of images show very green lawn areas along with large shade trees, that may be off property, that show no signs of moisture stress.

    Last sentence above, ...both trees...and mine has much more curling..., so both trees are affected, yours moreso.

    As arbordave and gardengal have mentioned, dogwoods in full sun typically have foliage that is curled downward. It is a response to the full sun and is not actual wilting. I've got loads of dogwoods here in TN (kousas and easterns) in full sun that exhibit that characteristic and they are perfectly normal. Shade leaves from the interior of the tree or trees growing in full or part shade will tend to have larger and somewhat flatter leaves held on a more level plane.

    For me, the UPWARD curling of the foliage is the dead giveaway, herbicide damage. Unfortunately all too common with the "weednfeed" stuff the mow and blow guys use. The good thing is the damage on your tree is PROBABLY cosmetic, and no permanent harm will come to the tree(s). I wouldn't want to see it happen every year though.

    The above are my thoughts, certainly NOT carved in stone, take them for what they are worth LOL.

    Ken



    mragjr thanked kentrees12
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Thank you all for help. Ken's comment on "the "weednfeed" stuff the mow and blow guys" put down sounds most likely. We do have nice grass and they are good at killing dandelions, etc., but who knows what they are doing to the Kousa's? Not sure if mentioned before, but there is a larger tree nearby as pictured below-also too many more here at http://mrag.jalbum.net/dogwood/index.html

    1) is there a good distance for 'weednfeed' to stay away from the tree?

    We are not in a drought here, but have had some hot weather. Note in the included photo where the gutter drains are. I would think that would give the tree more than a bit of water.

    1a) There is a water hose nearby if that would help much.

    I do follow that two identical trees can be quite different if only 80' apart. Still seeing so many flowers (bracts/flowers/berries) on one and not the other causes my amateur's mind to wonder.

    I would like to prune/trim/shape the tree (including top). It is beginning to block the view from the second story (and even the first floor) and the lower part is closing off what little yard there is. I think the base should be raised some. Right, wrong?

    2) If possible, exactly when and how much pruning would be advisable?

  • 10 years ago

    Interestingly enough, just the other day, the hired landscape contractors for the homeowner's association came by trimming bushes and such in front of the condos. I pointed out the Kousa to them and they immediately "cleaned" it up. Not having any prior guidance, I hope they did a good job which I share with you here. I wonder if they could have chopped the top a bit more so it is not as high?