The tile I chose for my kitchen renovated is Artigiano from Daltile. It is a ceramic tile that is made to look like old handmade tile. This was a last minute change for me (that I'm regretting); I'd planned to go with a plain ceramic subway tile. http://products.daltile.com/documents/salessheets/DAL_Artigiano_SS_1605.pdf

The problem I'm having is with the backsplash right above the bar sink. I don't like the line of 4 tiles just above the faucet. They were grouted today and now I especially don't like the way one tile is set back and the other 3 are sticking out. Again, they are supposed to look handmade, I just got a little more of the old world look than I'd hoped.

My question is, can these four tiles now be taken out and replaced with other tile to give the backsplash in that area a smoother appearance?

[The tile behind the range hasn't been grouted yet.]

Thank you for your help...