Software
Houzz Logo Print
purrus

Need feedback on lighting for bathroom

10 years ago

Hi everyone,

OK, I've been racking my brains trying to find a light fixture for the ikea Godmorgon medicine cabinet. It is not recessed and sticks out about 5-6 inches from the wall. As a result, finding lighting to go above it that does not create a shadow is somewhat challenging. Google tells me that many others have suffered a similar quandary and found no decent solutions. (huge sigh.) Ikea does make two options, but I don't like either of them.

My style in this bathroom is quite modern overall. I am using white glossy subway on the walls with grey grout, and white 2-inch hex tile on the floors with grey grout. All chrome fixtures. I'm using the Ikea Godmorgon vanity also in glossy white:

I found a reno on GW that used the Talo Mini Artemide light above the Godmorgon vanity, which is where I got the idea. I trust GWers in general and know they put a lot of thought into things like this. It is expensive (at least to me), but lighting is important to me and I want to get this right.

(Here's the reno I found that uses this fixture above the godmorgon medicine cabinet: http://ths.gardenweb.com/discussions/2315694/finished-bathroom-sleek-and-modern-master-bath?n=52)

Link to fixture: http://www.ylighting.com/artemide-talo-21-mini-wall-light.html


From the looks of this reno, I think they built a soffit and attached the light to it. Right? This is not addressed in the reveal or any other threads I could find. Also the fixture is only 4 inches deep so they couldn't have accomplished this lighting feat any other way.

I am using a contractor for this and not DIYing, thank god, so I assume something like this would be within his skill set. However, I was hoping to use white subway tile across that whole wall, continued from the shower/tub stall, to make the room look bigger since it's only 5x8. Is there a way to build a soffit above the cabinets and still tile the whole wall without having it look strange or should I forget the whole idea and just paint if I have to build a soffit?

(To be clear, recessing this cabinet (or any other) is not an option due to the location of water pipes. I do need the storage of a medicine cabinet. Otherwise I'd just get a mirror and be done with it!!!)

Also, if I go with the Talo Mini Artemide fixture, my question is this: since I'm using all chrome on the bathroom fixtures, should I get the chrome finish ($80 more on an already expensive fixture) or should I just go with the brushed or the white? (And if I do go with one of those, which one?) I'm not looking for this fixture to be a feature, but to be streamlined and functional which is how all the reviews I've seen describe it.

Finally, will this likely be sufficient light for a small (5x8) bathroom, or should I add something else? These are only 8 inches wide, and my vanity is 24 inches wide; I could conceivably use two of these, but I'm not sure whether that would be overkill . I don't want a dark vanity--the whole point of building a soffit above these cabinets is making sure that I can see my face clearly. Each fixture comes with a 150W halogen bulb.

Here are the chrome and white options (again, Chrome is $80 more, and I'm having to have a #$@%ed soffit built...but I don't want to look back and wish I'd sprung for the chrome.)

Thanks in advance, everyone. I need to make this decision quickly, since my contractor will probably need to know whether to move the junction box for the light before he starts tiling, presumably... and I've been trying to figure this out for way too long.

Comments (36)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Definitely go for the chrome.

    Are you doing an accent band with the tile? If so, you could have it at the height just below the soffit and just paint the soffit.

    purrus thanked chibimimi
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    No accent band. I had considered it, but to save costs in favor of getting better options in other areas, I decided to forego it. Thank you for the advice about the chrome! That was my instinct, but ugh! the price.

  • 10 years ago

    Also, I don't know whether the soffit would be the width of the medicine cabinet (23 3/4 inches) or 8 inches wide (width of the light). I want to have an answer in case my contractor asks me which I prefer, and he might. (I seem to be asking for a lot more customization and have a lot more unusual ideas than he is used to!!)

  • 10 years ago

    You could talk to your contractor to see if a pendant or two hanging from the ceiling might work.

    Otherwise, you're looking for fixtures that are proud of the wall...candlestick style might work, but probably too trad'l for the look you're going for.

    Maybe look into barn lighting...


    2011 Foxhall · More Info


    Hawkseye III · More Info

    Lighting direct sells a bracket that will work with a pendant light hanging it out from the wall.


    purrus thanked Annie Deighnaugh
  • 10 years ago

    What Annie and Local suggested was my first thought. Either barn or an articulating arm library light. Local's pic would be my choice.

  • 10 years ago

    I'm just thinking the pendant would cast too many shadows. The light I originally posted looks more, well, glowing, for lack of a better word! (Does that make sense??)

    i am going to search for modern barn fixtures. It just seems like such an oxymoron to me, but maybe it isn't. Those pictures you've posted look good to me!

  • 10 years ago

    Library light-I'm only concerned about rating for wet areas. Vanity is RIGHT by shower in a tiny bath. I will have a fan of course but would prefer a wet rated light.

  • 10 years ago

    Oh, also, local eater, since you asked, no--no ceiling light. From reviews it indeed looks like one of those would be fine in a bath. My contractor will be here today and I'll see what he says about building a small soffit. I'm just not sure whether it will look stupid or sloppy with my wall of tile. I wanted it to all look sleek!

  • 10 years ago

    Depending on the material the pendant is made of, it could cast fewer shadows if it has a glass shade that allows light through it...even if frosted, it will allow light through so fewer shadows.

  • 10 years ago

    My understanding is that Wet rated is really for outdoors.Here is a link that might be helpful LINK

    RE your soffit: If I were to do it, in your situation I would build the soffit exactly the size of the godmorgan cabinet you are buying. I would mirror the front and side of the soffit. This way it will appear as an extension of the cabinet. The 'box' will need to be less than the cabinet's dimensions to allow for the thickness of the mirror.

    BTW - I have seen the fixture that badger posted- its amazing!

  • 10 years ago

    How do you mirror something?? Just buy pieces of mirror and glue them on? I assume a glass place could custom cut pieces?

    If I used that fixture (that badger posted) I suppose I could just paint it, right, since the fixture covers most of it up? Or would the mirror still be preferable?

    mirroring the soffit is a genius idea!


    my contractor is going to think I am insane. He does not know I have a whole group of design geniuses as a secret weapon, lol!!

  • 10 years ago

    Contractor just arrived. reaction to the idea of a soffit and mirrors was not what I would call enthusiastic, but he said, yeah, it can be done. :) He isn't sure how mirrors would look and recommended just painting it white. He said there would be a gap between the cabinet and the mirror and seemed to think might look strange or thrown together.

  • 10 years ago

    My contractor thinks I am strange too.

    Tell him we dont want a gap, that's the point. Yes he might need 1/4 inch gor clearance. You can buy mirror tile at HD but might be better to go to glass place so they can cut hole for electric as that request may push your contractor over the edge.

  • 10 years ago

    lolol

  • 10 years ago

    He just continually looks at me like I am insane. you should have seen his face when I asked him if he could put an outlet inside the medicine cabinet. and then the ikea vanity OMG. He's a super nice guy, i just think he is used to very standard people who aren't overthinking stuff the way I am. hahah

    OK, so I could just take it to a glass place and have them cut a hole for the electric? Or for the whole face plate on this fixture, for instance? (I do think I am going to go with this one, chrome finish... I'm just worried about how far it's going to stick out in my tiny bathroom once I add the soffit... so I haven't actually hit purchase yet.)

  • 10 years ago

    What if you overlit and bounced lights off the ceiling instead of down toward the mirror?

    purrus thanked robo (z6a)
  • 10 years ago

    How would I do that??

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    If you're going to glue mirror onto a surface, you need to use mirror mastic. Any of the other construction adhesives will remove the mirror finish. Yes the glass guys can cut a hole in mirror. I have light fixtures through the mirror in my bathroom.

    But I'm not sure I'd go to that difficulty...I'd probably just paint it white. And there will be a gap as you have 2 different materials coming together. That's why my preference would be to skip the soffit and find a fixture that is proud enough from the wall to work with the cabinet.

    Adding outlets to a vanity is tricky as the drawers have to move and the outlet box could get in the way of the drawer. Also there's a greater risk of getting the outlet wet if it's not higher than the sink and vertical in the wall.

    purrus thanked Annie Deighnaugh
  • 10 years ago

    Robo- The over the vanity light will be the only light in the bathroom in case you didnt see that. (off topic- I typed a note to you in a thread about hard to find furniture)

    Purrus- If you will go with mirroring the bump out to give the illusion of seamlessness, what if the bump was not the full depth of the medicine cabinet, maybe just half the depth? I still think it will look seamless, though you may need an additional piece of mirror for the top of the godmorgan medicine cabinet or the unmirrored surface will break the illusion.

    I still prefer the look of the Chrome Library Sconce, personally, but it is definitely not as modern a look which probably explains my preference. My style leans modern, but less sleek, more earthy. :)

  • 10 years ago

    "He just continually looks at me like I am insane."-ahhaahaa. Story of my life.

    (sorry for not bringing anything useful to the discussion at that point..)

  • 10 years ago

    To be clear, the outlet is going in the medicine cabinet, not the vanity! Too much quick typing from my phone.

    This soffit (if used) will be high up on the wall too, so hard to see. Half the depth would be a nice compromise perhaps. I just wish I could see what it would look like in advance.

    Believe me I would love to skip the soffit. I just don't like the look of the pendant or shaded lights as much in this bathroom. It is small and I don't want a cluttered look and I worry about shadows. (And then there is my sleek look, which I'm trying not to disrupt.)


    more later, off to the tile shop for a quick errand!

  • 10 years ago

    sort of like this


    East Village Studio · More Info

  • 10 years ago

    ..Would you consider something like this? Wall projection is 9.5 per description..?

    They have many finishes and options on this one. They have glass ones too. A popular shop with great reviews

    https://www.etsy.com/listing/241795548/white-wall-sconce-brass-light-multiple?ref=shop_home_active_26

  • 10 years ago

    Aprilneverends, those are really cute! The problem with that one, though, is that it is a little too tall. I also can't have something that hangs down like that because my medicine cabinet is so tall, and the doors need to open. the Godmorgon cabinet is huge--37" tall! with my 8 foot ceilings, and vanity, and faucet, there isn't a lot of space for a light fixture. That's why the tech lighting one would be perfect.

    I'm just still not certain that it will give me sufficient light if most of it is wasted on being directly above the fixture. :(

  • 10 years ago

    The site that aprilneverends posted does custom work, you get a light like below with the projection extended. Lots of lighting shops can customize like this for you. I ordered something from Cedar and Moss a year or two ago and they modified to fit my needs, not alot of money to tweak. Rejuvenations lighting is also very accomodating as is Worleys Lighting(also on Etsy). I

  • 10 years ago

    You may want to check locally too. I live in Maine and I have a custom light maker few miles from my house.

  • 10 years ago

    I did go ahead and order the tech lighting span bar fixture. If it doesn't work out, I will check out a custom option. I'm still not sure whether or how much i should try to bump it out, and if i do bump it out, how I should achieve that. ugh, so many decisions to make.

  • 10 years ago

    yes, Worsley..them, I wanted to mention too..also lots of different depth, finishes, etc.

    The one that I like here has the fabric shade, so light is much more flattering than almost any.

    https://www.etsy.com/listing/249028247/sconce-wall-lamp-modern-lighting-clement

    PS disclaimer-have no idea whether it's ok for bathrooms..code-wise.

  • 10 years ago

    purrus - sounds like you've got in under control, I am sure it is going to come together great can't wait to see it.

  • 10 years ago

    I'm totally not sure I do, at all. I just need it to get here, need the drywall and at least some tile to get on the walls so I can envision some of this. The maybe I will have some idea of whether this light will be sufficient.

    I could add some recessed lighting later if needed. Mainly I don't want to waste the light this fixture puts out.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Revelation---I don't think there is a water pipe in the way. I looked after contractor left yesterday and it looks like supply lines are lower in the wall ( the whole wall is not gutted, just the lower part). I have this kohler cabinet in the garage, which I ordered awhile ago but had planned to teturn, and since I also just realized my ceilings upstairs are only 7.5 feet tall, I actually think the IKEA cabinet is too large for my space. So I am going to forevo the IKEA cabinet and attempt to return it assembled.

    Assumkng he can actually recess this cabinet it will give me a lot more leeway to choose a light fixture, though I still may go for that uber cool tech lighting one!

  • 10 years ago

    My problem now is, where will I have my husband's razor and toothbrush plugged in? There is no space on the small vanity counter top and the current outlet is at an awkward distance away. I wonder if contractor would move the current outlet closer to the sink and create a new one closer to the toilet so I could make a charging station out of an acrylic container of some kind? Is that a code violation of some type (outlet too close to toilet)? I know razor and toothbrush plugged in on the sink is not going to work for us.

  • 10 years ago

    We have an outlet near the toilet which we use for our night light. Outlets near water shouldn't be an issue so long as they are ground fault circuit interrupters (GFCI)...meaning they pop off if they get shorted out. We have a shallow cabinet between our sinks. Inside we have an outlet and plug in the toothbrush and waterpik. Maybe something like that would work for you near or over the toilet. The only thing about over toilet cabinets if you have to be sure to shut the lid before you get something out of the cabinet. You also need the high enough so you can still access the toilet plumbing when necessary.


    Carisbrooke, North Vancouver · More Info

    purrus thanked Annie Deighnaugh
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Hmm, I had planned to put a train rack over the toilet for towel storage. So I was envisioning just a simple acrylic tray on the toilet lid for toothbrush/razor charging (but that is sort of gross, I guess). I just know we are going to be short on counter space for idle charging items. Sigh.

  • 10 years ago

    Maybe a chrome/glass shelf underneath the train rack? would that be too cluttered? I'm just trying to find space for all the things in this little room!!

    (Then at least H's toothbrush isn't, you know, sitting on the toilet...)

    something like: