Software
Houzz Logo Print
urbanlavaca

Linear drain vs. center drain pros and cons

10 years ago

We're building two showers (totally new for one, the other is renovating a current one but the plumbing is moving around anyway).

Is there an advantage or disadvantage to a linear drain? Any reason we should stick with the traditional center round drain?

Comments (20)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Center round drains are generally less expensive. Linear drains allow the use of larger tile.

  • 10 years ago

    Is the lower cost related to the labor involved in building the shower floor?

  • 10 years ago

    Is a linear drain better if building a curbless shower using smaller tile or doesn't it matter?

  • 10 years ago

    My elderly parents have a center drain curbless shower (4'x5') while we have linear drains in our curbless showers (5'x5.5' and 4'x6'). All work well. From the ageing-in-place point of view, the linear drain allows for a gentler slope. For those with balance issues, I would think it would be preferable.

  • 10 years ago

    Center round drains are generally less expensive. Linear drains allow the use of larger tile.

    I thought you wanted small tiles in a shower (regardless of the drain type) because they provide greater purchase /less chance of slippage. ?

    From the ageing-in-place point of view, the linear drain allows for a gentler slope. For those with balance issues, I would think it would be preferable.

    This is also tied into the size of your shower. A larger shower can be made with a more gentle slope. As for who has balance issues, etc., any of us could join that group anytime.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    mrspete:


    Looks are everything these days; it's form over function. How else does one explain the choice of marble as a countertop?


    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J0RTD7250II


  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    "From the ageing-in-place point of view, the linear drain allows for a
    gentler slope. For those with balance issues, I would think it would be
    preferable."

    well said Mspete, well said.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    There are large format tiles with a good cof so they are not slippery. And less grout means easier cleaning--an important function issue from my perspective.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    We used a (not Jadico) JACLO linear drain & cover with our MB renovation last year, and used 3" tiles, since the slipping thing is really a concern. It looks great. But I don't think I'd do it again. With the cover, the drain trench doesn't dry out between showers, and it develops gunk/mildew. We have started to clean it out at least every week or so, and spray the trench with vinegar. That's helping a bit.

    Unless ours is an anomaly, it looks like you have to accept a bit more maintenance for the good looks.

    (my goof... Mixed up the name of the drain with the name of one of my doctors... Who's great.)

  • 10 years ago

    I live in a dry climate, and have no extra care issues with our linear drains. They're gunk-free after four months of use and only minimal cleaning. We use the fans liberally and crack the windows open most of the time.

  • 10 years ago

    We have gunk issues in our linear drain - we clean it every 3 or 4 months. Why would that be any different from a center drain though?

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Jadico? never heard of it but i will say there are a bunch of overseas knockoffs being sold for nearly the price of a quality point drain. There are only a few high quality MFG im aware of so purchase wisely.

    Gunk? theres a lot to that. Starting with the quality and installation of the drain itself.

    Some linear drains do not have proper integral pitch and may not yet have an IAMPO or UPC approvals listed on the drain body....Ive even had a few stainless flanged drains that were bent from the mfg. Glad I caught that.

    Some have a lot of screws and bumpouts that can catch hair/debris,If youre drain is not set PERFECTLY level @ both axis this can be exaggerated as it doesnt drain properly nor completely.

    Now the market is flooded and i would be careful in youre quality selection and who installs it. There also needs to be a proper grate fit to allow for drainage as some grate covers are too snug.

    There is no question A quality Linear drain with proper approvals and expert installation can make for a nice flat stable shower floor offering low maintanance as with anything there are many factors to it working properly. shop and hire wisely.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for the input. I want it to catch hair (so the hair can then be disposed of in the trash, rather than clogging the pipe further down). I definitely like the look of the linear drain, but trying to determine the actual difference in cost is a challenge.


  • 10 years ago

    Just a quick correction. Our linear drain was manufactured by Jaclo, in Cranford, NJ. The drain is indeed IAMPO listed.

    I think the biggest issue we run into is that with my shedding of long hair, mixed with conditioner, it slows the flow, even with a good slope within the trench base. Oh well.

  • PRO
    10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I wont name any brand names but I had to replace this drain( this one private mfg'd for a big Tile suppiler) ..... Barely any pitch to it to start...... and its flange bent off axis. I was appalled to go thru my vendors stock of this drain and found many to be warped. to my point about shopping wisely.....

    I would put a bullet level in your drain where it pools and doublecheck just so you know why it happens.. But youre stuck with it now and if it doesnt rust youre best off living w/it. bummer

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    One thing to consider is how much elevation you have to work with in designing a curbless barrier free shower. You need a 1/4" per foot slope for a shower floor, so you have to make sure you have enough elevation to accomodate that. If you have a fairly large shower like a 5x5 than you need about 1" to 1 1/4" of slope to a linear drain on average. If you had a 3x5 shower and you had the slope running front to back you would need only about 3/4" slope to a linear drain on the back wall of the shower.


    On the other hand if you wanted a 6x6 shower with a center drain you would need about 3/4" slope from the perimeter of the shower to the drain in the center.

    So sometimes you go with what ever is feasible in your situation without having huge elevation changes between your bathroom and the adjacent rooms and to allow for an adequate slope for drainage.

    Field conditions at the site can make a huge difference. If everything is pretty flat and level already then great. But in remodeling situations and older houses, you can almost count on the floor not being flat or level. So you have to account for the thicknesses of products to correct these situations also. Hope that helps.


  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for the help. One bathroom is in a new addition, and all that is level and new. The shower will be 3x4. The other bathroom is in the old house (originally a porch) and has recently been leveled.

  • 4 years ago

    Useful reference: https://www.houzz.com/discussions/5493551/linear-drain-cleaning to evaluate the pros & cons.


    If you ask me, I think linear drain is more work to maintain/clean despite it looking nicer. That may or may not be a problem for aging in place, in terms of the cleaning aspect. As far as I know the old traditional center drains you don't really need to clean much aside from the cover.


    If it's a matter of relocating drain, there are also center drain infinity drains, that is a hybrid, center drain positioned but giving you the style and look of linear drain but as a square in the middle as opposed to a rectangle bar on one side. These also have hair catcher baskets in some designs. I wouldn't recommend this from a cleaning/maintenance perspective though, as a traditional center drain is probably easier to clean.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    The ONLY reason ever to do a linear drain is if you're using large format tile across the bathroom floor and continuing into a curbless shower. A linear drain is the only drain that will allow a slope across a single plane to achieve this kind of look (which is a fantastic floor look and makes any bathroom appear larger - when you have a unified floor of the same large tiles. Larger format tiles are unable to accomodate the curves required to slope into a single point drain the way small format tiles can. Linear drains from a functionality and maintenance standpoint are inferior in every way to a standard single point drain. After having designed and built a modern minimalist bathroom with the large format tiles and curbless scenario utilizing a linear drain - I will NEVER do it again. Thought I love the look of my bathroom, linear drain requires WEEKLY removal of the grate. It is disgusting to clean, does not drain well, water sits in the trough, hair collects all around the perimeter, gross slimy buildup occurs, etc... Trust me, you do not want a lifetime of dealing with this just to attain an aesthetic. Future bathrooms I design will simply transition to smaller mosiac tiles for the shower floor in order to accomodate a standard single point drain. It's a tradeoff I'm willing to make despite how much I love the look of continuous large format tiles across the floor. When I see people use a linear drain with small tiles I just laugh!