Software
Houzz Logo Print
whoopster101

Clean, replace or reglaze tubs?

13 years ago
Houzzers,

We are currently remodeling two bathrooms in our house from the 90's. We just moved in a year ago.

1. bathroom one: the contractor told us that we have a solid Kohler cast iron tub and it is much nicer than anything we will be able to afford now. He also said the installation of a tub here would be very challenging because it is on the second floor, above the kitchen, and he would have to cut through the kitchen cabinets in order to redo the plumbing. For these reasons (which we hope are true!) we decided just to keep the tub. While the tub has no scratches or dents, it has collected dirt over the years where the anti-slip areas are. The picture depicts these stains (along with other dirt from the remodel which can be removed easily - picture 22 really shows the true buildup and not the temporary remodel related dirt).

Please let me know if you have tried any cleaning agents/methods that could get rid of the grime. We are hoping this tub does not need a reglaze since it is pristine aside from the dirt build up.

2. bathroom two: this tub is likely also cast iron but not a Kohler. It also shows some chipping, wear and tear of the enamel. I think removal of this tub will be less challenging.

Hence, we are debating whether to reglaze this or purchase a new tub. Reglazing is around $300, the same price we plan on spending for a new tub (either porcelain or cast iron). This tub's defects are shown in the third picture.

Thank you very much for the advice!

Comments (42)

  • 13 years ago
    Try using a solution of Oxi-Clean (use lots!) and water, and soak the tub for several hours or overnight; then scrub with a nylon brush & rinse well. Good luck!
  • 13 years ago
    Thanks! I will certainly try that for bathroom one, where I have to keep the tub. Do you recommend any particular oxyclean product? I looked this up - http://www.oxiclean.com/in-wash/Products/oxiclean-versatile-stain-remover-powder.aspx

    How much do you recommend per tub? Also, would this type of nylon brush be sufficient - http://www.amazon.com/Tools-Gadgets-2-Piece-Nylon-Scrub/dp/B0028LX8EY

    Thanks!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    If there is a room behind the tub drain, access to the drain from there is all that is necesary to re-plumb a new tub.
  • 13 years ago
    I don't think so, unfortunately - when the house was constructed it looks like they did not take that in to account - they probably did the bathroom first and then the kitchen downstairs. Also, since it is a townhouse, we can not cut the wall on the other side since it is the neigbor's unit.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Might be time to buy your neighbor a drink 8-)
  • 13 years ago
    Haha, do you think the tub can not be cleaned/reglazed?
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Reglazing is not applying a porcelain finish, it is a two part urethane finish and after that you can't use anything abrasive to clean the tub or it will scratch or remove the new finish. Scrubbing Bubbles will be your new friend.
  • 13 years ago
    Yes to both of your questions about using Oxi-Clean to clean the tub. I hope it works for you.
  • 13 years ago
    whoopster: I have a similar situation, but my tub doesn't have as much staining. I want to keep it, husband wants a new one, contractor says to keep it. Your post (and two papers I have due at the end of the week) inspired me to try the Oxi-Clean, but it didn't do anything. HOWEVER, I used the Mr. Clean Magic Erasers and the tub looks completely different. I think you'd go through an entire box, but for 6 bucks it could work. Let us know!
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you so much for the tip! I hadn't heard of this product so far but will certainly give it a shot and post the results. I hope I have a good "after" picture to post!
  • 13 years ago
    Have any of you used ROG1/ROG3? I just saw ths post online - http://retrorenovation.com/2012/08/06/how-to-clean-the-bathtub-slip-resistant-bottom-omg-its-like-new/

    Before I spend $50, I would certainly love to receive some confirmation that these products work.

    Here is how my tub looks now, after some basic scrubbing.

    Thank you for the input!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    You elbows are going to be sore. You need to scrub it for about a 1/2 hour with comet. Watch Nicole Curtis talk about cleaning these tubs on DIY. I think she may have a you tube on it.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I highly suggest NOT using comet on this tub. We had a Kohler tub with the similar non-slip finish at the bottom. Never could get that thing clean. The instructions that came with the tub specifically said to not use comet or other abrasive cleaners.

    We got rid of ours before Magic Erasers became available. They may have worked but we'll never know. We usually got the best result with soaking in VERY hot water with dishwasher detergent added - then scrubbing with a stiff bristle brush. It made it better - but never really as clean as I wanted it.

    Cast Iron tub and sink surfaces aren't made the same way they were 40 or 50 years ago. They require more gentle cleaning products. You can probably try Comet if you've already decided to have it reglazed and feel you have nothing to lose.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Barkeepers friend is better than Comet. We buy old sinks all the time and this is the only thing I will ever use. I do not recommend refinishing- it is not a forever thing. Like said above it is difficult to care for. To me it sounds like your plumber is being lazy. Make nice with the neighbors and get a new one...lol.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    You need to emulsify the grease/grime caught in the non slip area. I use a product from the same company that does "goof off" called Contractor's Solvent which is a citrus based product. The best product I have used was from the Odo-Ban company and was called Grease Control, but I haven't seen it for sale in recent history although it may still be available through industrial suppliers.

    Polishing away the dirt isn't going to work - you need to get it to release from the surface.
  • 13 years ago
    Barkeepers, not Comet(causes new micro scratches in finish).
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    If all these suggestions don't get the tub clean to your liking, replace it. It's a matter of cutting a 12" x 12" hole in the drywall in the neighbors unit. That part doesn't even have to be done until the old tub is removed and the new one is set in place. The plumber can take preliminary measurements of the new tub and get the p-trap close to where it has to be, then set the tub in place. The access hole in the neighbors unit is only needed to connect the drain and check for leaks, one day maximum, patch up the hole and it's over with.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Mr Clean magic erasers will take away the shine eventually as well. They are abrasive, like very fine sand paper so I wouldn't think that over time they would be good for the finish of the tub.
  • 13 years ago
    We were faced with the same dilemma - remove or reglaze. In the end, in order to remove the tub we would have had to replace the surrounding wall and floor tile, an expense we did not to finance. Make sure it's just the cost of the tub before you make your decision.
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    I use ROG1 and ROG3 on my Kohler cast iron tub and I am happy with the results. However, my tub is a year and a half old and I've used the products from the start, so I don't know how well they would clean a badly stained tub. The ROG1 is white when it comes out of the bottle, but changes to a greyish purple after a few minutes. I'm not sure why this happens, but it hasn't stained my white tub. I don't use the scrubby that they sent with the products because it is really heavy duty and I felt that it might damage the non-slip area in the long run. Also, the scrubby is bright red and I was worried that the red color would transfer to the tub. Instead, I use an O-Cel-O brand no-scratch scrub sponge. Good Luck! : )
  • 13 years ago
    I use Baking soda and Lemon Juice ,make a paste and smear it on and cover it in plastic...wait a couple of hours,should be able to rinse,and it should sparkle......If this doesn`t work there is a product called Bar Keepers Friend in a shaker near the cleansers...I have found it also in the Dollar Store I use this with lemon Joy dish liquid..same process(This also cleans glass wear,pots ,pans,cookie sheets ,any baked on browned food stains no matter how long they have been baking on..cleans brass and copper too...have not tried it on the sterling silver ,yet...
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    If you don`t have the Lemon,White Vinegar will do..Just went back and read all the comments,some one sugested goo be gone ,prefer Avon Skin So Soft bath oil....I have also used it with the baking soda..FYI without thre baking soda),it is great for getting road tar off your car,bubble gum from hair,will remove oxidation from alunimum...and it is great on your skin, un diluted it can be used on skin skale ,removes flakes helps skin,great for oil treatment on your hair, also rub on your exposed skin and no bug bites...
  • 13 years ago
    start w/ d 40 or Shout , or Resolve type product to loosen grease and then follow w/ dishwasher detergent and Magic eraser, if this doesn't do it you are out of luck. Have found this to work on all nasty tubs.
  • 13 years ago
    Thank you all for your comments! Is there anyway to just remove the anti slip? I noticed that our second tub has had the antislip removed and, hence, is much smoother to the touch. After all these years I don't think the antislip will scrape off easily. I'm wondering if there is a solution that will simple lift it off

    Also, those of you who suggested Barkeepers, do you let is soak overnight or just follow the instructions and leave it on only for one minute?

    Thanks to everyone for the comments! It would be great to get this nasty tub cleaned!
  • 13 years ago
    So you think this anti slip is after market sticky back add on? use IF it is plastic a heat gun or hair dryer and a wide putty blade , (thinner the better will help to lift it...I have never seen this type of anti slip in a tub...IF it is plastic maybe you can super heat it and use a razor box cutter to score small sections at a time to remove...Is your other tub compleately smooth or is there residue from the backing...??Bathrooms are tricky places to use acid or toxic solvents because there is not enough air flow...if you don`t know what you are doing you can damage your lungs or eyes....
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    This discussion is becoming a slippery slope so to speak.
  • 13 years ago
    I do a two step process in my non-slip tub - first I spray it with Kaboom foaming cleaner, let it sit for about an hours, then rinse thoroughly. This will remove most of the dirt and soap scum. Then I go back with the Magic Eraser, and it's like new.

    What I've been doing lately, is keeping a thin white terry towel in the shower to stand on (if your tub is also a shower) because wearing flip-flops all day my feet get pretty dirty, and this is helping to keep the bottom much cleaner between scrubbings.
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    Wow, that is amazing!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    This is my favorite new cleaning solution. I found it on Pinterest and it really, truly does work. Fill a spray bottle with a 50/50 solution of vinegar and Dawn (the blue one). Shake and spray it thickly onto the tub. You need to leave it on for a while. I wait about an hour if there is heavy soil/soap scum. You should then be able to just sponge off all the grime. When it is just usual light soil, you can spray it on, wait, and then just rinse it off. This stuff is amazing - I use it for everything now. Oh, and by the way: I purchased a huge bottle of Dawn at Costco, and I also understand - although I have yet to get some - that Walmart (and other places, I'm sure) carry something called industrial strength vinegar or something like that in a big bottle. Good luck - I hope whatever you use works because it certainly would be great to save that tub!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    I have been using a generic product from the local dollar store. It's called Daily Shower Cleaner. It prevents soap scum and mildew stains. I just spray it after we use the tub and then rinse it later when I have time. I can't believe how it has brighten the surface of my tub not to mention the caulking around the edge.
  • 13 years ago
    Here's a tip my aunt learned from maids at hotels - they don't bend over go clean tubs. They use brooms! Let me tell you, this is the tip that will change your life big time if you have a tub!! The bristles find all the nooks and crannies and do the work for you. You can thank me later.
  • 13 years ago
    @calikym, thank you for that great tip. I have a tub for the first time in decades - and I have a back that is not happy with me bending to clean the tub. I will try the broom trick next time it needs to be cleaned.
  • 13 years ago
    Just use it exclusively for tubs. "Bristles" s be plastic. Get an angled one. :) you're gonna be shocked. Oh yah!
  • 13 years ago
    whoopster, serious congratulations! Before our last bathroom remodel, we had a Kohler Tea for Two that we had put in brand new. It ended up looking like your 3rd photo in your post above about ROG1 and 3. I cleaned it frequently and with everything I could find that was suggested by Kohler. As mentioned above, this was before Magic Erasers were around.

    I love a good long soak and got to where I hated that tub. Even when I had cleaned it myself, it never really felt clean. We finally remodeled again (due to a water damage issue) and the Kohler came out. I love my new tub...but might have kept the Kohler had I been able to get it as clean as you got yours.

    Enjoy your soaks in your squeaky clean feeling & LOOKING tub!
  • 13 years ago
    That looks amazing!!!!!!
  • 13 years ago
    Happy that you were able to get your tub sparkling clean! I think the trick is to clean often - of course, in this case, it wasn't your fault! : )
  • 12 years ago
    whoopster, your tub looks amazing. My cast iron tub is the color tan. I have tried everything but I have white streak marks that I cannot get out for the life of me. There is no build up of soap scum because it is smooth. Any suggestions?
  • 11 years ago
    That's amazing ! I never would have thought that you would get your tub looking that clean...it looks brand new. I know you must be thrilled.
  • 10 years ago

    Lifespan of a cast iron tub is 100 years...glad you didn't reglaze before using elbow grease. Good job.

  • PRO
    9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Just clean the tub to save money, if you want to replace a new one, I recommend you the solid surface tub (cast stone tub), you needn't worry about the scratch in future, because you could remove the scratch easily with # 800 sand paper to be a new tub!