Software
Houzz Logo Print
anniedeighnaugh

Colors that devalue your home?

10 years ago

From House Beautiful, they supposedly did a study and calculated how much some colors will increase or devalue the selling price of your home.

I'm not sure I buy it...I think a lot would depend on how the entire room is decorated.

Also, some of the "frightening" colors I would expect to see, such as shocking pink, didn't make the list, though I suspect it may be because so few people use that color in their house any way.

What do you guys think?


Comments (41)

  • 10 years ago

    As you suggest, poorly designed "research". Colors probably correspond to time periods and hence are often a proxy for how recently something was renovated.

    I think we have better research right here, in the post below. Don't use red, orange or purple. My guess is the people that were going to use that type of color march to their own drummer anyway and could probably care less.

  • 10 years ago

    I can't buy it. there are too many styles homes - for example, white works really well in MCM homes - to state any specific color or shade is a bad idea. I think the rule of thumb, when going to sell, would be to stay away from garish and harsh shares in main living areas, i.e.: bedrooms, living rooms, etc. Okay for work rooms like laundry rooms, craft rooms, even some bathrooms, I think.

    Anything that screams I think is not a good idea.

  • 10 years ago

    Many years ago when we were shopping for our first house, I still remember the one room that made me cringe. It was a kids bedroom painted in bright kelly green glossy paint, ceiling too! Ugh!!

  • 10 years ago

    I read that Zillow post, several days ago..if you're not factoring anything else, but try to see correlation between color-price only-you get a (very) skewed research. I guess Zillow is fine with it. These days, journalists(or whoever puts the content on a website?) write/print some unprecedented amount of ..(looking for a nice word..didn't find it)). Also make it very short, with some clickable headline. Probably think that others will find it easier to read that way..))

    I hate to say but that's also the reason I only read House Beautiful in its paper form, which I'm subscribed to. I can't handle their site. It irritates me. Most of online versions of magazines are. I feel like they make it in some specialized format for monkeys..:) Jumpy, bright, short. Usually no or little essence.

    Sorry for the rant..:) I know I didn't say one word about colors.

  • 10 years ago

    For god sakes its just paint. Cant believe someone would pass on a house just because of what colors are painted on the wall.

  • 10 years ago

    "Buyers disliked off-white and eggshell rooms." given that we live in the age of mixi-neutrals which are all some version of off-white this made no sense. I guess what they were really trying to say is it had to be off-white in the gray greige range... But the first picture in the article showed just such an off-white and I thought it was really pretty picture but the picture made absolutely no sense in light of the text of their article.

    Have you ever seen the decorologist's website? I think she's great with color.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Very silly artical considering Zillow estimates are only within 20%. Still, they are a bit closer than most.

    A lot depends on house style and location. I used to HATE grey but had little choice in paint shades when trying to marry existing things in my latest open plan house purchase like stone fireplace, lots of granite and off white beigy/grey tile floor. If I decide to sell down the road, maybe I'm screwed if people hate grey ...but I don't think so. My whole small community is Greige-y.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    WELL THAT"S WHY they call it "clickbait" - this one sure got me hook, line and sinker. And then you find it's a whole bunch of nothin.

    No such thing as a "bad" color - only bad (or lets say inept) color combinations and inappropriate contexts. One realtor told me once people arent looking for neutral, or any particular color - they're looking for the right colors - ones that look harmonious and well chosen. That screaming kelly green - it does sound horrendous as you describe it OP, and yet conceivably in context with certain yellows and/or whites and in right amounts/proportions, and in the right setting.... that same color could be just fine.

  • 10 years ago

    Well, a bad paint job makes sense in that it can be a signal that the rest of the maintenance on the house has also been done carelessly.

    But when they said that kitchens painted in off-white or eggshell sell for $82 less! Let's say they're looking at house prices that can range anywhere from $180,000 to $600,000, if we leave out the really low or high end stuff, and they can identify $82??? That gets lost in the rounding. Talk about misplaced precision!

  • 10 years ago

    I don't agree with the study, but if they did the statistics correctly, I think the $82.00 would be showing up after accounting for the rounding. But this isn't a controlled study, either, so maybe not.

    But when I was doing clinical research, we would get results that would show significance even if the results were less than 1 mm. different.

    When I was getting my post doc we would read these studies and I would think "But intra examiner error of a well-calibrated blinded examiner is plus/minus one mm, and you have to start looking at plus/minus two mm to evaluate what the differences are so how can less than 1mm be significant?"

    It's because the examiner error is already factored out.

    But the other thing that I found in clinical research is that if your statistical analysis is weak enough, you can show significance.

    I was a blinded calibrated examiner, but I usually had a feel for who was treatment and who was placebo and in once study I really could not tell who was in which group, and I didn't think that either looked all that good. However with the right statistics, the pharmaceutical was approved because it showed there was a significant difference. I personally have never used this agent because I don' t think it really does anything of real clinical import.

    Way off topic I know.

  • 10 years ago

    The biggest problem is mistaking co-incidence for causality. That is where common sense shapes the exercise.

    I agree with the poster above, it is just more stupid content that is pushed at us all the time. No editors any more,


  • 10 years ago

    I agree -- if it's the walls, it's just paint! That can be fixed and easily so. Now if it's flooring whether tile or carpet, then that is going to cost money and many cannot do that sort of job themselves (where you can paint). When I watch House Hunters I am often amazed at someone saying as they walk into a room -- Ooh, I don't like that color at all (like it's a deal breaker) -- that color can be made to go away with at least two coats of paint!

    I say paint and decorate for yourself! If you are planning on selling, if you have any "funny" colors, you should change those to neutrals. And a freshly painted house is always nice when it's for sale. If you are planning on living in the house 10 years or less before you sell, then I would suggest neutral flooring. If not, do whatever you want -- I believe it was on this board I saw a beautiful blue tile kitchen floor that was amazing --

    Martha

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Martha I agree about the tile flooring making a difference . To me paint is just paint and an easy fix. I'm in Florida the land of tile floor. When I see a sea of ugly tile through all living, kitchen and baths it makes a difference on what I will offer if there are also other updating things going on. Ugly carpet I love because you can just roll it up and put down what you want. With tile you have to go through a huge expense with removal and mess before you get to laying the new stuff and the cost of that . I didn't buy one house due to a sea of med darkish beige ceramic tile.

  • 10 years ago

    Don't buy it either. Color so easy to correct can't imagine it being a deal breaker. I guess an exception would be somebody dead set on doing ZERO work pre or post move

  • 10 years ago

    I know people that HATE painting and maybe a house requiring painting would be a "no way" for them. I love to paint, so it would impact my home buying decision.

  • 10 years ago

    On the one hand it is just paint, but on the other hand, in a HCOLA there are probably people who can't afford to repaint, as someone mentioned. And now that lots of houses are open plan and have complicated angles and vaulted ceilings and such it's harder to DIY.

    I have definitely passed on houses not so much due to paint color, but to how lousy the previous paint jobs have been. I often see woodwork that is so clotted with brushmarked, lumpy latex paint, and banged up, to boot, that I think...okay, I could spend $20,000 in this house taking out the woodwork and replacing it, alone. Or probably more on stripping and painting. I don't even want to tell you what it's costing me to "just paint" my house as I go along, in the way I want it done, which I know I could not do myself, even though I am probably a better painter than a lot of people who do it professionally.

    This house is in my neighborhood, and I would pass on this because of the paint job. You can see and feel this paint on the wall. Every surface would have to be sanded in this house to get a good finish. It's not worth it, the house is already pricey.


  • 10 years ago

    I know it's just paint, but many people can't see past the surface of things. They can only see what is. How many house hunter programs are they saying things like they love the sofa or the bed... but those things don't even go with the house.

    Believe me, I get how you get the average family having 2.4 children. But it is misplaced precision for sure. Like the old joke about the guy who said the dinosaurs went extinct 250 million and 8 years ago. When asked how he knew that, he said, "Because 8 years ago, I went to a lecture and they said they died out 250 million years ago."


  • 10 years ago

    DH installs carpet and wood for a living and has done all our tile work (floors and walls). He's willing to do THAT but won't touch a paint brush anymore.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Pal I can sorta see your point about bad paint jobs. I did a lot of fixing in sons house ( and most of mine) with dried long dripping paint where some twit loaded up a roller and started at the top, or didn't sand wall hole patches and painted over, or painted over badly done window caulk and painted over parts of bronze window frames or painted bugs and pet hair into moldings/baseboards ect...

    i think since I'm not getting any younger I would pass on a future house with years of bad paint jobs.

    i would never pass on a house just because I didn't like the color though. I can't even wrap my head around that mentality. If the excuse is that a family would not have enough money after buying to paint the walls, well that doesn't make sense. What are the chances of walking into a very low income house and having it perfect and in a shade you want?

  • 10 years ago

    If the excuse is that a family would not have enough money after buying to paint the walls, well that doesn't make sense.

    It doesn't make sense. But you see a fair number of houses with the cheapest miniblinds or paper "temporary" shades, and very little furniture here, for years after people have purchased their houses. I live in a high cost of living area, and also people will mortgage to their limit, but they will often not hold back significant money for furnishings and get a less expensive house--at any price point.

    Here it is very easy to find out when the house was last sold, and sometimes I will see even a high priced house with almost no extra furniture, and little better than a bed sheet over some of the windows and assume that they had to sell for some reason very soon after they moved in--only to look it up and find they have been living in the house for ten years.

    What are the chances of walking into a very low income house and having it perfect and in a shade you want?

    Almost none, I'd imagine.

  • 10 years ago

    Pal, I think it is more common for those of us here to think in terms of whole interior painting. I think for most low income buyers they think more in terms of a room at a time painting. So, I still can't fathom not buying due to just a color of paint.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I saw a house earlier this year that had all the rooms, except one (which had fake wood paneling) was painted mustard yellow. All I could think when I saw that house was how many gallons of primer I would need to make it livable. If everything else had been great I would have looked over the horrendous paint color. But, based on my limited experience more often than not bad paint colors was also combined with other issues in the house, such as a ugly flooring, ugly kitchen, horrible bathrooms, etc. The paint is just one more thing that the buyer doesn't find attractive.

    And to me that makes sense. If someone finds an intense mustard yellow color attractive then their other decorating choices are also likely to be reflective of their personal tastes which would not align with mine.

    Not to mention with so many homes that have vaulted ceilings it's not just a couple cans of paint. I have 20 foot vaulted ceilings in my house. I'd need to hire a professional to paint those, and goes beyond a couple hundred bucks.

  • 10 years ago

    For everyone who said, it's just paint.... We sold/moved/bought cross country this spring, so I looked at a lot of houses online. The horrible paint jobs did nothing to make me feel warm and fuzzy and like "this is home". I couldn't see myself living there, and it was just depressing. I moved on until I found some houses that did feel comfortable.

    Now, in an extreme seller's market, where there is huge demand and low inventory, I might have felt differently. This was a pretty normal market.

    I did notice that all the horrid houses I saw online took a long time to sell if they sold at all, and the clean neutral homes, even if not updated to the nth degree sold very quickly.

  • 10 years ago

    In my opinion and experience (valuating 1000's of homes for the banks), its the market that dictates how a buyer will respond to a home in bright colors. In a sellers market where inventory is limited and demand is high, no one will give a hoot, but in a market where demand is low and/or it's a Buyer's market, colors can make a very big impact on how many people will actually be willing to look at the property in person. I've seen where a buyer will easily use the cost for new paint as a way to get the price lowered.

  • 10 years ago

    Ha Ha Sushipup, we practically quoted each other!

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I've seen where a buyer will easily use the cost for new paint as a way to get the price lowered.

    Yep. I've been looking at houses for some time now on and off and am totally appalled at some of the paint color choices. Bright purple, neon green, aqua blue, the list continues. All in the same house. And if it's a bad paint job. . . These are dumpy little houses either.

    I know paint can be changed easier than anything else, but I'd be factoring it into cost. And if you've never done it yourself, it's A LOT of work to do it right when you're tackling a whole house.

  • 10 years ago

    I ignored paint colors and staging when I bought this house.

    All the walls (except two accent walls), all the trim, and the carpet were all slight variations of the same color. The walls and trim were supposed to match, but were slightly off, with a pinker undertone to the trim. The carpet has a greenish undertone.

    I found the whole thing vaguely nauseating. The pictures are very flattering.

    Actually the people who rented it were not going to rent it unless it was repainted, and new rugs were put in despite the fact that the house had already just been repainted and new rugs installed when I made the offer on it. We compromised. Right now the house still has some of the carpet. Nonremovable vomit stains, red wine stains, hairspray residue and all. Like many renters they move in demanding the Ritz-Carlton, and leave it like a Motel 6 in a bad neighborhood.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    So this morning, House Beautiful announces SW color of the year for 2017 called Poised Taupe. Supposed to be like "gray and brown had a baby".

    Isn't this one of the colors they just said would devalue your home?

  • 10 years ago

    One is a report on the opinion of Zillo Digs, the other is a report on the opinion of color forecasters at Sherwin Williams, so the agendas are different and House Beautiful is just the messenger.

    It's confusing though, because print magazines used to have an editorial Point of View. Now with all the online versions of everything with the consumer consuming at a gluttonous rate and expecting something New Every Day--at least-- they are just regurgitating whatever they are picking up from various sources themselves.

    But I don't think that the conflict is all bad. And HB regularly has pieces about designers and paint colors and there are often differing opinions within the same article.

  • 10 years ago

    ...there are often differing opinions within the same article.

    Of that I am well aware. They are often posting a "yes do" and "no don't" in the same article.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Interesting color Annie. It's one that could look good with vibrant wall art or cabinetry/accent furnishings . Not the same as what I chose to calm down vibrant Cherry cabinetry in an open plan but close (not as much brown yuck). I wouldn't much like it in a monocramatic scheme because I would find it depressing. However, mixed with some vibrancy it could be nice.

  • 10 years ago

    I like this color. Does look like a baby. Of some animal. Maybe a dolphin? Lol, I don't remember right now. But it does beg to touch.

  • 10 years ago

    In general color would not be a deal breaker in the "hot market" around here, where bidding wars and houses selling for above asking price is common. As for the selling price of $82 dollars less based on paint color, who would repaint for that difference? That is the cost of one gallon of premium paint, not factoring in labor and other materials.


  • 10 years ago

    For people with vision, it is "just paint". For people without vision (or design sense), it is a problem because they cannot pick out paint colors. To say "It's just paint" diminishes the value of selecting paint colors - not everyone can do it. People may know what they do not like, but they may not know what they like until they see it.

  • 10 years ago

    I think that color would look pretty on cabinetry with a crisp white countertop.

  • 10 years ago

    Not buying the cause-effect relationship. In medicine, this is what we refer to as "True, true, and unrelated" for two different symptoms/conditions.

  • 10 years ago

    I had to laugh when I read Palmipsest's post about renters wanting the RItz Carlton. That is so true! It seems that every renter we had wanted new rugs, we'd put them in, and then a year or 2 later when they moved out, we had to replace them because they were destroyed. We finally sold the rental property, it was becoming harder to find tenants who wouldn't leave a big mess and every bit of junk they didn't want, they left for us to get rid of.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ummmm, Bonnie, they don't ask for the cost of the paint, they ask for a credit of a couple of grand or more so they can hire someone else to paint.

  • 10 years ago

    Annie, poised taupe on my monitor looks like that baby just did something....

    At any rate, when I bought this home, the gray walls didn't impress me. Over time, they all got repainted. There were too many other things more important than the wall color.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Kukkirish, I'm sure that is often the case. I was referring to the article re: white walls in kitchens:

    "Perhaps most surprising? Buyers disliked off-white and eggshell rooms. In fact, homes with kitchens that were painted in either shade sold for $82 less than the predicted estimate."